Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Knife hinge fear

Posts

Knife hinge fear

#1

Knife hinge fear

Dan Collins

>Friends: I am just about done building a Krenov inspired cherry lingerie cabinet for my wife. The base is about 30 inches high and the cabinet on top it is about 36 inches tall and 24 inches wide. The inside of the cabinet has 4 drawers and 3 shelves. I built 2 paneled doors (3/4 inches thick) for the cabinet. Each door is 36 by 12 inches, so they weigh a fair amount. My plan was to install knife hinges for the doors. Now fear is setting in. I have never installed knife hinges. The ones I bought from Lee Valley (1 3/4 by 3/8) seem to have some play in them such that the door might tilt slightly towards the middle, slthough maybe that "play" disappears with precise installation. I don't want to ruin the doors and the case by installing knife hinges and then find out they cause the doors to sag slightly towards the middle. I like to think that getting stuck with something on a project is an opportunity for creativity. However, this time it is just creating fear. My shop usually gets real clean while I procrastinate over these kinds of issues, but my shop is now spotless and the creative inspiration hasn't happened. I'm thinking maybe I should just use some regular hinges and save the knife hinges for a smaller project. I thought your collective wisdom, experience, and suggestions could help push me in the right direction. Thanks for your insight. Dan Collins

Re: Knife hinge fear

#2

Don't fear

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Everything you do in your shop is subject to analysis and positive decision making. I haven't used the hinges you describe, but I question how you decided that they had slop in them. Most, if not all, reputable hinges I've seen and/or used have been very tight and positive. I wouldn't expect less from Lee Valley hinges.

I'm from the old empiricist school that prefers to make current decisions on the basis of existing conditions. You have a cabinet and you have doors. I suggest laying out your hinges based on a real-world mock-up of the parts and pieces. Make shims or wedged shims to place your doors in the exact positions you want in the cabinet, then mark out your hinge locations accordingly. If you're using offset knife hinges, you have an advantage in that you can mark a line on both door and frame where the offset comes through.

It's fussy work, but worth it. Keep on and don't revert to less acceptable solutions.

Let us know how you make out.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Knife hinge fear

#3

I had the same experience

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I overcame it by installing the hinges in a practice door and installation in the real door, after a multitude of hours making said door, was slightly lessened.

Re: Knife hinge fear

#4

PS

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I make doors a bit large so that I have a 1/16" or so for fitting after hinge installation

Re: Knife hinge fear

#5

Re: PS

jcousins

>just take your time - lay them out carefully - chisel out the recesses incrementally. in an old fww there is an article on setting them - i will look for the issue in the morning.

they really are great hinges and and don't take anything away from the cabinet wood.

jerry

Re: Knife hinge fear

#6

Re: PS

Dan Collins

>Thanks Jerry. If you have the issue number, I'll check the magazine at my library. FWW usually has good pictures to help explain the process. Dan

Re: Knife hinge fear

#7

Re: Knife hinge fear, 'You can do it!

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>Dan,

I understand your fear.

I've no direct experience with knife hinges, but I googled "installing knife hinges" and there seems to be a lot of info available. When I find myself in a similar situation, I usually read everything I can find on the subject, and then fortified with the sure knowledge that there a plenty of other folks in the world who can accomplish the task, just go ahead and do it. The method of building a 'practice case and doors to try it on first' is probably the best advice.

Good luck and let us know the results of your efforts.

Re: Knife hinge fear

#8

Re: Knife hinge fear, 'You can do it!

tek,brunswick

>I have installed Knife hinges in the past and they are usually pretty solid. They are a little harder to adjust than Butt hinges. I like the idea of a trial run. I would use your doors and a mock up opening. Make any adjustments in mounting on the mock up opening and leave the locations on the doors alone. When you have the fit you want transfer the layout to the real carcass. I am assuming everything is made to size already. If not, Bills idea of planing slightly over sized doors to fit would be a good way to go. Please come worry at my shop. It is a mess. I assays seem to find some other task more fun than cleaning.

Good Luck

Tom

Re: Knife hinge fear

#9

Read Krenovs method

bradt

>The best article on installing them is in one of Krenovs books, I don't remember which one but I think it is the second. He is the recognized master of this type of hinge and he explains clearly what happens to the doors when they are installed in different locations. A worthwhile read before doing your first set. I have installed them many times and still reread his instructions each time as a refresher.

Brad

Re: Knife hinge fear

#10

Re: Read Krenovs method

jcousins

>check issue #49 - p53. must admit that the ones i have botched (by making the recess too deep) can be shimmed with cardboard - the cardboard on the brusso hinge package is good material to use.

jerry

Re: Knife hinge fear

#11

Robert Settich, in his great book.................

Art Silva

>"Choosing & Installing Hardware" covers Knife Hinge installation on pages 46 & 47 with color pictures. Taunton's Complete Illustrated Guide series of books have become the "go-to" source for serious woodworkers. Good luck. Art

Re: Knife hinge fear

#12

Re: Knife hinge fear

Jim Dillon

>Dan,

Go for it! I've installed about 20 so far, albeit the double-offset variety, and love them. They are fussy, but attention to achieving reproducibility in the position and depth of your hinge mortise will help.

First, since you have a wonderful resource in your local library, take advantage of FWW's online magazine index to search for "hinges". I did that and found at least a dozen references to knife hinges. I like one by Scott Gibson in FWW #152 pp 108-110, but others are likely good too.

I used the router for cutting the mortise. Exact positioning of the mortise at each location is critical. While overkill, I had on hand the mortise jig described in Bill Hylton's book "Router Magic" and it made the job easy.

Several things come to mind. If you do decide to use the router, along with a fence (not absolutely necessary if you want to do some chisel work), make sure to always position the fence against the SAME side of the work piece, i.e. the outside face, or the inside face. Second, practice setting the depth of the mortise on a piece of scrap wood and tend to sneak up on the depth, although using the hinge leaf to set your depth can get you close if not right on.

Yes, you can bend the brass hinge pin (DAMHIKT). As you trial fit the door with the bottom hinge in place, it is easy to bend the pin when you slip the door in and out. So be careful at that stage.

Use steel wood screws, if you have them, to cut the threads initially, and be sure to use wax lubricant or something on the screw. I was able to use brass screws in jatoba (a very hard wood) by being careful. A centering punch is also useful to make sure the screw hole gets started in the center of the hinge hole.

Jim

Re: Knife hinge fear

#13

A few tips.

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>While these hinges look and work great, as you have already heard, the are a PITA install. However, once they are installed, I just can't imagine that you will have any future problems after they are in.

I have installed them on long runs of doors where any discrepancies would ruin the horizontal lines that I was working hard to achieve, so leaving anything to chance like measuring errors led me to adapt jigs to take out that chance.

One thing that I do, it leave the top of the cabinet loose, usually M&T joints, so it can slide up and down. Go ahead and install the hinge to the door, then the top portion of the cabinet portion of the hinge. saving the bottom portion of the hinge for last.

I then make a little fixture to hold the bottom portion of the hinge in place using double sided tape. Once the doors are fitted to the cabinet during the dry-run using shims to hold the doors just right. You can then lift the door away, and insert one screw in the bottom plate, then remove the jig, to do another dry-run, then remove the door, and scribe around the bottom carcass hinge leaf, knowing that it is where it should be.

Once the mortising is all done, the top can be brought on down to its final height.