Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

SWEET WOODS

Posts

SWEET WOODS

#1

SWEET WOODS

Carl Barton

>Someone asked me to try and reproduce a Civil War era Nuckllos type canteen using what he called a "sweet wood" such as cedar. As I do not know my different types of woods my first thought was cedar is not a sweet wood. So as not to limit myself to looking all over the place for a large enough size piece of cedar to make this canteen I was hoping you all might be able to clue me in as to other what other woods are considered as "sweet woods".

As I just retired from the Navy after 33 years and a bit borded right now I thought I might give making this canteen a try.

Thank you,

Carl

Re: SWEET WOODS

#2

Re: SWEET WOODS

Fred Davis

>Among Yellow Birch's many names is Sweet Birch, the only "Sweet" wood I know of.

FredD

Re: SWEET WOODS

#3

Re: SWEET WOODS

steve mackay

>The term is a mystery to me BUT . . . I sure wanna see a home made wooden canteen ! AND HOW YOU DO IT !

Re: SWEET WOODS

#4

Re: SWEET WOODS

Carl Barton

>Steve,

Well it is going to warm up tommarrow, 57 degrees, so I am going to go out in the shop and put some wood on the lathe and give it a shot. I am sure I will be turing more than a couple blanks before I get it right, but I have been wanting to give it a try.

The Nuckolls canteen looks like a plate with bulges. It is constructed in two halves, one half of the bulge sticks out 3/4 in, the other side 1/2 in. Then you mate the two halves. Of course the inside has to be carved out as well. I have a diagram from the Confederate Museum in Richmond, VA which they made from the original Civil war canteen they have. The person I am making it for son works at the museum. So at least we have a detailed set of plans to go by.

The problem the person who asked me to make this for has a reproduction and the two halves were glued together with epoxy. Since he is a Civil War re-enactor he wants all of his gear to be authenic and period looking. Epoxy was not around back then, but tree resin was and the original has an unkown substants where the two havles mate, I am thinking this may be a tree resin. I am going to try and mate the two halves by with a tounge and grove method. Since the man wants to drink water out of this canteen like they did back in the 1860's I do not want to use any resin or glue of any type. Once water is in the canteen the wood should swell and seal the tounge and groove. At least that is a theory. I am going to use pecan wood since that is what he suggested, but I am going to make a prototype out of a bunch of maple I have laying around.

Anyway that is the long story. If I get it some what close I will post a picture.

Carl

Re: SWEET WOODS

#5

Re: SWEET WOODS

Howard Norman

>Carl, I had never thought about how the Army carried water in the field during that time. It is an interesting thought. I would sure like to see a picture of what you come up with.

Re: SWEET WOODS

#7

Re: SWEET WOODS

Dick Coers

>Frank Klausz showed a technique to make a water tight tray. He nails the frame together. Then he goes around the edge that contacts the base, with a #9 wire, tapping that wire into the wood with a hammer. He removes the wire and nails on the base.

When the water leaks into the joint and contacts that compressed wood, it will expand that fiber and seal the joint.

He may have done that on Woodwright's Shop, but I can't remember for sure where I saw that video.

Re: SWEET WOODS

#8

Re: SWEET WOODS

Barry Irby

>I saw that too. He indented the edge with the wire or nail as you described, but then he planed the edge down to the bottom of the groove, leaving it flat, but with a row of compressed wood in the center of the edge. That wood expands and seals the joint.

Re: SWEET WOODS

#9

Here's one

Ellis Walentine, Host

>I got this one from an old-time cooper, Dave Miller, who used to demonstrate his craft at our woodworking shows. His act was pretty authentic, down to the covered wagon that he towed behind his pickup truck and all the tools and trappings of the 19th century itinerant cooper. It's typical coopered construction, with maple panels set into coopered birch staves, all held together by two thin metal hoops and a wraparound of what appears to be lauan. Of course, North American coopers would have used hickory splint or other tough, flexible wood for the straps. The bung and tapered stopper are made of yet another hardwood. It's difficult to identify any of these woods since the surfaces are so rough. I hesitate to sand everything down just to get a better look at the grain.

I'm afraid I'm no help on the sweet wood question.

Ellis


img

Re: SWEET WOODS

#10

Re: Here's one

Carl Barton

>Ellis,

Thank you. I am going to go with cedar. As I was doing research on the web it appears from that most of the canteens seem to be made from this wood. I will take some pictures as I try and make this and post them all here are Wood Central when I am done.

Carl

Re: SWEET WOODS

#11

Re: I have emailed you a "solution"

Carl Barton

>Bill,

Thank you. I saw that email when I loggedon this morning.

Carl

Re: SWEET WOODS

#12

Re: SWEET WOODS

Carl Barton

>Wow that is one solution I did not think of. I think this idea would be allot easier to do than a tounge and grove that I was thinking of. I might have to give both solution a try.

Thank you to all.

Carl

Re: SWEET WOODS

#13

Re: SWEET WOODS

steve mackay

>I know he is corny but I love Mike Rowe. I had never really thought about "useing" the phenomenon of wood swelling to one's advantage untill he went to the cooper's shop. If a big, huge barrel why not a smaller canteen ? Actually theres probably a whole lotta physics go'n on there !

Re: SWEET WOODS

#14

A.J. Hamler

Civil War wooden canteens

A.J. Hamler

>Carl...

I hate to admit it, but I have no idea what a "sweet wood" is. Not really familiar with the phrase, except as it applies to individual boards. (I got a really sweet piece of 12"-wide 8/4 red oak yesterday. Due to a minor surface defect, he only charged me for an 8"-wide piece. Sweet!)

However, wooden canteens of the period used a variety of woods. You mentioned cedar, which is an excellent choice. A better choice might be cypress, as it is an excellent water-holding wood. Also consider juniper. White oak isn't the best choice, but you could consider it. (It might be very prone to cracking, though, if you let it dry out after use.)

Wooden canteens were used primarily by Confederate forces, while the Federal army used tin canteens almost exclusively.

The Confederate army started the war in pretty good shape. It was essentially split off from the Federal army as states seceded from the Union, taking with them former U.S. Army personnel and equipment, so both sides were fairly equally equipped at the start. As the war progressed, the numbers on both sides quickly skyrocketed and new equipment had to be produced. The industrial North had no problem churning out ton after ton of metal equipment, including canteens. The less-industrial South almost immediately had problems with metal goods. As a result of metal shortages, all metal was diverted to the production of weaponry. Associated accoutrements such as canteens shifted to wood or other materials.

Of course, any battle that Federal forces lost -- which was most of them in the first two years -- supplied equipment to the South. As a result, there was an interesting bell curve of equipment. The average Confederate soldier at 1st Bull Run in 1861 probably had a metal canteen leftover from U.S. Army stores when his state seceded. A typical soldier a year later at 2nd Bull Run probably had a wooden canteen. By the end of the war, it was probably a 50-50 split of wooden to tin canteens, as the Confederates had captured enough equipment that small things -- like sturdy metal U.S. canteens -- were, if not exactly plentiful, at least more available than in the middle years of the war.

A.J.

Re: SWEET WOODS

#15

Re: SWEET WOODS

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I recall hearing my grandfather use that term. Mostly in relation to getting sticks for roasting hot dogs or toasting marshmallows. He said you wanted sweet wood not bitter. If you peeled the bark off and tasted the wood it would taste sweet as opposed to bitter.

Lee

Re: SWEET WOODS

#16

Re: Here's one

Dick Coers

>Carl,

You're not talking about using aromatic red cedar are you? That stuff is not good for food contact, or human use. It has too much oil in it to be good for water.

Re: SWEET WOODS

#17

Re: Civil War wooden canteens

Carl Barton

>A.J.,

Sounds like you are intrested in the Civil War as I am. I had 100 family members who faught. Of course these were Uncles, cousins etc etc etc. I wrote a book for our family historical socity in which I documented over 300 men and women in the US military since 1776. As far as the Civil War 99 of the 100 faught for the South. I have been going to all the major battle sites to see for my own eyes and soul where these men faught. When the wife and went to Gettysburg it was something to see the actual site where my Barton kin charged up Little Round Top ( 48th ALA Inf) and one of the others in the Peach Orchard ( 9th GA INF). The ALA soldier was wounded and died three months later from his wounds and the 9th GA died at the Orchard.

I am taking the information I gain at the battle sites and updating my book with this information. Since I am now retired and live here in VA I am at the center of it all and have the time to be able to do this.

Carl

Re: SWEET WOODS

#18

Re: Here's one

Carl Barton

>Dick,

Nope, not the type at all.

Carl

Re: SWEET WOODS

#19

Re: SWEET WOODS

Carl Barton

>Steve,

I never thought of doing this either. That is why this forum is so great to bounce idea's off of each other. I made one half of the canteen this morning after mulling it around my head for a few days on how to best appproch the project. It worked out great, now all I have to do is the other half. Once I get the two half's completed I am going to try the idea you posted, I think it will be much easier than tring to use a tounge and grove method.

I have been taking pictures as I go along so I will post them and the procedures I used once I am done.

Once again thanks for the idea.

Carl

Re: SWEET WOODS

#20

Re: SWEET WOODS

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Carl,

My imagination conjures up thoughts of Sweet Gum because its also nice to chew. Also sugar maple, and sugar pine. What root do they make beer from? I know all about the beer part.

George

Re: SWEET WOODS

#21

Sassafras

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Is what root-beer is flavored after now. I think this would be the best choice that I have heard mentioned thus-far. It is light, strong but not too hard, and decay resistant.

However, I think I have a book which indicates that it the tea made from its root bark does contain a carcinogen. As a kid, I would dig the roots for my dad who still liked to make and drink it. The old-timers thought it was an elixir, and was good for the liver etc.