Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

OT: Attic insulation quesiton

Posts

OT: Attic insulation quesiton

#1

OT: Attic insulation quesiton

Terry Alexander

>I am building a new house in West Texas. No code requirements out here in the sticks except for the EPA.

I hope I can describe/articulate my dilemma accurately.

I have 10' ceilings in the master bedroom, kitchen and great room. However, in the mstr bedroom, the south wall starts at 8' and then slopes to 10'. There is about an 8 ft. length from the 8' part until it reaches the 10' part where all I have is 8" of space to put insulation. I am using R30 for the ceilings and it is supposed to need 10" of space. I can get this into the 8" space no problem. BUT...there would not be any room for air to circulate from the soffit to to the attic on this section of the house. I have plenty of circulation everywhere else.

Ah....having said/typed all of that....

Is it ok to not have air circulating in the space?

Or...do I need to (example) nail 1x2" on all the joists (or are they rafters?) and then nail a 1/4" piece of plywood so that it has 2" of circulation and leaves me with 6" of insulation space?

Sorry for the epistle....but didn't know any other way to describe the problem.

As always....TIA for the advice/assistance.

Terry Alexander in West Texas (north of Abilene)

Re: OT: Attic insulation quesiton

#2

Re: OT: Attic insulation quesiton

George Koch

>Terry, there are styrofoam channel vents made just for that purpose. They hold the insulation away from the underside of the roof sheathing to insure proper air flow from soffits to ridge vents. Check with your insulation vender. George

Re: OT: Attic insulation quesiton

#3

Re: OT: Attic insulation question

Barry Irby

>George is right. I don't know your local climate (and I'm too lazy to try to look it up), but if you have any knights where the temp falls below about fifty degrees, you should provide for ventilation. This is a very complex subject and there are many answers to your question, but using the insulation troughs available at the borgs and insulation suppliers is probably a good answer and safe.

You can install a 1 X 2 rib down the center attached to the underside of the sheeting to hold the insulation down and provide a channel up the middle and that will do it in a mild climate. Locally (Virginia) I have seen failures where the area between the insulation and the sheeting sweat or collected condensation and the sheeting rotted and delaminated.

Re: OT: Attic insulation quesiton

#4

I only had 2x6 rafters so

Jeff Fischer

>I used r-19 with 1/2" foamboard that I cut and folded to make a channel for the air to pass thru. The one I used had a foil face for some radiant barrier effect. This is a 4 foot slope on the southwest side of the house and this modificacation made a real improvement.

BTW: If you haven't sheathed the roof yet, the radiant barier osb really helps.

Re: OT: Attic insulation quesiton

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Two Musts........

Jesper, Denmark

>You must have air circulation between the roofing and the insulation.

You must have a vapor barrier between the insulation and the room.

Re: OT: Attic insulation quesiton

#6

Re: OT: Attic insulation quesiton

Mike Fitterling

>It is wise to have ventilation over the insulation and insulation that is compressed is much less effective. You would probably be better served by thinner insulation (lower R) that would not have to be compressed that would also leave that ventilation space.

Re: OT: Attic insulation quesiton

#7

Vapor barrier?

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>"You must have a vapor barrier between the insulation and the room.

I was thinking of what you said, and thought..... none of the houses around here have vapor barriers in the roof. They just blow that white fiber puff insulation directly onto the top of the drywall ceilings. That it.

$250K-$900K houses between 5-20 years old in Atlanta climate.

But it's days like yesterday (way too cold) that we remember that they don't really even put insulation in the walls of houses here. They're supposed to but it's a ridiulously little amount.

Houses up north felt warmer at -30�F than houses down here at 20�F because of the insulation, or lack of it.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT: Attic insulation quesiton

#8

Re: OT: Attic insulation quesiton

Tom MacGregor

>You can use high-R value (not pink board) rigid foam sheets to boost the insulative value in a narrow space. It's expensive, but it's a one time cost. Our Vermont home has 1-1/2 inches of foamboard and 12 inches of fiberglass in the walls, 1-1/2 inches of foam in the ceilings with 30 inches of blown-in on top. We heat the entire house with one 29,000 btu LP space heater and no ductwork. And remember that insulation cuts down on airconditioning costs, too. It will pay for itself in the long run.

Re: OT: Attic insulation quesiton

#9

A well ventilated attic...

John in NM

>and a warm climate and you don't need the barrier. I forget the exact figure for ventilation, something like 1 square foot per 50 or 100. It also depends on if all the ventilation is near the peak or if its split between the peak and eaves (that works better of course).

With the metal roofing I used, there were these little L shaped pieces meant to fill the gap under the ridge cap where it sits on 1" tall seams. About 1/3 of them I left out and instead put in corrigated plastic material (coravent is one brandname, owens corning also makes it). Works really well (roof sheathing stops a couple inches short of the peak), and I didn't have to make yet another hole in the roof for a whirly-dealy.

Re: OT: Attic insulation quesiton

#10

Re: OT: Attic insulation quesiton

Bill Wilkinson

>Two comments - no Three!

1) Insulation that touches the roofing plywood will limit air circulation under the roof, - this affect the cooling off of the shingles IN WINTER AND IN SUMMER - many neighbours that have poor air / attic cicrculations can be diagnosed by the premature aging of the asphalt shingles on their roofs - sometimes it cuts 10-12 YEARS off the lifespans of the shingles.

2) the air/vapour barrier goes on the WARM side of the insulation

- up here in Montreal, that means it goes on the INSIDE.

- down in Florida it will go on the OUTSIDE

It is there to reduce CONDENSATION of water vapour coming from the warm (HUMID) side, migrating through the insulation to the cold side, and condensing on the cold side, and rotting the wood, and creating mold.

3) Fiberglass wool insulation that is compressed reduces the insulation value, but not in the way that you may think.

ie - an 8" batt compressed into a 6" space gives less insulation value that the same batt in a full 8" space, BUT that 8" batt in the same 6" space gives MORE insulation value than a 6" batt in the same space. (THis is because an over-compressed FG batt will limit air circulation more effectively and give more insulation value - remember that it is the unmoving air that insulates, not the FG wool itself. I often use overly compressed batts for SOME small spaces - I am "wasting" money, but getting more insulation value where I want it.)

Thus it depends on your constraints and requirements are you limited on space, or on how much insulation batt thickness you have to work with.

4) (Yes I know I said three)

The amount of insulation that is recommend is based on the cost of heating or cooling, RELATIVE TO the cost of purchasing and installing that insulation. I personally feel that since energy costs are expected to rise in the future, that we could double the amount of insulation in many cases and have it pay off in a rather short term

(In my relatively new house, I upgraded my attic by 35%, and my basement walls by 80% for a total cost of about $1100.00, and I feel that it has almost paid for itself in about 3-5 years. I did it that way because it was simple to go from 9" batts in the attic to 12", no added labour costs. Similarly, in the basement walls, they simply built the wall a little father out from the concrete, and put in a thicker batt (R20 vs R12).

P.S. - don't forget the air circulation under the roofing ply

Let us know how it goes...