Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

rough sawn lumber

Posts

rough sawn lumber

#1

rough sawn lumber

DP

>Possibly a dumb question, but is rough cut lumber graded as for as quality? This is the first time that I've purchased lumber like this, and I'm having a very difficult time ending up with 3/4" boards. I took 6 boards 7"x 88" and flattened one side with the jointer and then went to the planer. Only one board I was able to get 3/4", the rest go down from there, the thinnest one being 9/16".

Extremely frustrating when you pay $450 for 150 bd ft of lumber. Any thoughts or suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks,

Danny

Re: rough sawn lumber

#2

Re: rough sawn lumber

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>If the lumber is warped or cupped, you can usually get a better thickness yield by cutting the parts a little oversize before planing them down on the jointer, then to the planer.

Also, this gives the wood a chance to stress relieve before being flattened. Very often there may be stress between on side of a board and the other. If you cut the parts out after you have it down to thickness, and it warps, then you will even loose more, but if it is oversize at this point, it is easier to finish with more thickness on smaller parts.

Re: rough sawn lumber

#3

Re: rough sawn lumber

Stephen Kirk

>I'm guessing here, but it sounds like you might be trying to remove a lot of defects, such as wind or bow from the full length of the board. Sometimes you have to remove a substantial amount of wood to get a board flat. Generally, I will only flatten a full length board - say 72-96" if I need a board that long. Otherwise, if you have boards with significant wind or bow, cross cut them into smaller pieces and then flatten. You will often save a lot of thickness that way. If you need a long flat board, pick through the stacks to find the best you can. I use almost all rough lumber and I've generally had pretty good luck with it. Since a lot of 4/4 lumber is cut a tad thick, if I'm careful I can sometimes get a flat 1" thick board out.

Also, if you are running a 7" wide board on a jointer I can only guess you have and 8" jointer?

Probably be best to tell us more about the type and shape of the wood and what your intended use is.

Re: rough sawn lumber

#4

Dale Lenz

Re: rough sawn lumber

Dale Lenz

>When I first started purchasing rough sawn green lumber, I'd ask for 1" lumber. Learned very quickly to order the lumber sawn at 1-1/8" because of your problem. Also, as others have stated, rough cut the length you need to mill first.

Re: rough sawn lumber

#5

Re: rough sawn lumber

Barry Irby

>All good advice, so far.

I have a bunch of rough cut lumber I had cut myself. There is a sort o contest involved with all of this. If you order the lumber sawn thicker, you get fewer boards out of the tree or log. If it is thicker and it dries nice and straight and flat, you may mill away more to get down to the thickness you wanted. BUT, If you have the lumber cut thinner, you may have more boards, but is the they dry crooked and cupped you may not be able to get any "full thickness" full length boards preped.

If you try to prep full length boards, you will suffer a lot to lose on the thickness as you have discovered. I approach this by cutting the pieces down to size first as mentioned by others. But, I like to leave them about four inches too long, because my planer leaves snipe on the ends of the boards. By having them too long, I can cut the snipe off at the last minute. This is a trade off. I am losing four inches of full thickness (nearly) wood, but you are losing a lot of thickness.

This is a much more complex process than meets the eye. Stock Prep. You must really think it through and it is not nearly as simple as shoving a few boards across the jointer and through the planer. You must take into account the original condition of the lumber. Wonderful perfectly straight dry lumber is a breeze compaired to some of the the real world stuff. You want to develop some sort of good relationship with your suppliers to get the best possible stock to start with. As you can see, straight thicker lumber might actually be cheaper, even if it costs more to start with. You must also know the limitations of you machines. Does you planer leave snipe? How wide is your jointer. Not much point in buying a 16" wide board if you have a six inch jointer and a 12" planer. A lot more strategy here than many would have thought.

I have a Performax sander and can surface wide boards on it. Very slow, but a real joy. It will also eliminate the snipe left by the planer, giving me the ability to plane lumber to nearly exact length and then sand the last hundredth off.

Rethink the process and do the steps in a different order and you will have much better luck. Welcome to wood working with rough lumber.

Re: rough sawn lumber

#6

Re: rough sawn lumber

DP

>I do have an 8" jointer. The smaller length of cuts that I needed, was no problem because I was able to select the part of the board that worked the best and cut roughly to size and then to the jointer and plainer. The 80" boards that I need is where the problem has come. Live and learn I guess. Thank you for the responses.

Danny

Re: rough sawn lumber

#7

need more information

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>To answer your question, lumber is normally graded just after it is sawed, and before it is dried.

If you bought this lumber from a typical supplier it is a good bet that it is suitable for typical applications, ie, others are using it successfully for what ever they are making. Perhaps you are using it for an atypical application (a table top 7' long) or you are over-processing it for a typical application.

What are you making from these flattened pieces? If you need dead flat pieces of the size you stated you are going to have to select some unusually flat lumber to begin with and likely have to start with thicker pieces. But even for a table top 7' long I would not feel the need to over flatten.

Re: rough sawn lumber

#8

Re: rough sawn lumber

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>If you need an 80" long piece in your project, another thing to consider is do both sides have to be surfaced. Somethings like to the rails of a couch or aprons of a table only have one visible side. So, just surface one side and perform measurements for joinery off this side.

If you are doing something like a bookcase, well then you have two visible sides. However, over a length like 80", it's really hard to tell if the entire board isn't perfectly. Oftimes you can get by by bringing the board close to your intended width and then sanding smooth. If you have a small about of twist/cup/bow the assembly can often take care of that.

I learned when I first started - after experiences like yours - that we often have to make ourselves work with the wood, not make the wood work for us.

Re: rough sawn lumber

#9

Re: rough sawn lumber[Simple solution?]

Larry_Wyatt(Cole's Dad)

>First of all, never a dumb question.

Secondly, it seems to me(along with all the other sage advice that you've received) that for long pieces, get 6/4 lumber. I learned the hard way that stock selection is one of the, if not THE, most important part of making a project.

Larry

Re: rough sawn lumber

#10

Re: rough sawn lumber

Charlie Self

>One of the downsides of prepping your own lumber is the different quality cuts you get from different mills. Around here, I buy from one guy, who does a good cutting job. Another seems to cut wedge shaped (lengthwise) boards, that are 1-1/2" on one end, 13/16" on the other. That's never going to make much more than a 9/16" or 5/8" board, unless you can cut off the thicker parts and work from that point.

Cripes. Today was to be a shop day, but it got down to -1F. I moved down here from upstate NY. I now feel like someone slipped me back while I was asleep! I doubt my heaters will get the shop to the point I can assemble tools today. Maybe tomorrow and Monday.

Re: rough sawn lumber

#11

If cupping is the problem.

Basil

>Sometimes if I need a wide board and have a wide board but it's cupped so bad I can't use it, I rip the board down the middle with a circular saw, joint the 2 halves flat on the same grain side and on the same cut edge then glue them back together and run them thru the planer. Most times, if you're lucky and watch what you're doing, you can't even tell it's been cut and glued back together.

I have my own plentiful stash of rough cut lumber and tend to be a bit wasteful sometimes. But there are times when I have to be frugal and squeeze as much as possible out of a limited stack. I use my roughly 2/3's rule of thumb at those times. If I need a 100 board feet of good finished wood, I better have at least 150 board feet of rough cut lumber before I even start.

Basil