Finish question
walt
>Quick question, I just about to finish a desk that I made out of Cherry...is there any good finish that would work on the wood? Is there something about the wood that could cause problems?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Finish question
walt
>Quick question, I just about to finish a desk that I made out of Cherry...is there any good finish that would work on the wood? Is there something about the wood that could cause problems?
Solvent based lacquer
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>Don't use any thing involving linseed oil unless you want ugly blotching.
Clint
Re: Solvent based lacquer
Lee Schierer - McKean, PA
>I use solvent based lacquer type finishes on all my cherry and it works great. Sand to 220 and apply the finish. I normally ues Deft Clear Wood finish from a can with a brush. Please note that solvent based finishes need to be used in a place with lots of ventilation. Lacquer based finishes can be successfully applied in unheated buildings, which is what I do in the winter months so I don't fill the house with fumes. I use an unheated detached garage with the garage door open.
Lee
Not so!
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>To answer your question Walt, cherry has no particular finishing issues, but it must be sanded with great care.
Woodworkers cherish the curl in maple and do all they can to bring out this figure. But some, when it is encountered in cherry, call the color variation and differences in light reflection "blotching", a pejorative word if there is one. Shown is a picture of the back slats in a ladder back chair I recently finished. It was properly sanded (more on this factor later), stained with an oil based mineral pigment stain, and then varnish top coats applied.
I am delighted with the play of light off these figured back slats and the oil and stain brought them out.
Now I have seen figured wood like this with ugly darkly stained regions. This flaw is a result of improper sanding and staining technique, not the stain or varnish. I meticulously sand cherry and maple carefully progressing up to 220 grit. If there are any dull places at 220 I know that I didn't spend enough time at the courser grits. These dull places are torn grain catching saw dust and they will in turn catch stain and make an ugly dark spot that could indeed be called a "blotch".
To apply my oil stain I use a rubber as is used to apply shellac. I lightly dip it into the stain and then transfer stain from rubber to wood by rubbing just as I might do applying shellac. By this means I control the amount of stain transferred from rubber to wood.
Many flood stain onto the wood and then wipe off what they can. There is no control over color development with this technique. Poorly sanded places sop up vast amount of stain and appear overly dark.
the rest of the chair
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>The chair was made by Haley-Daniels, Bera, KY. I finished it. A neighbor put the seat in it. We like them. Very comfy.
Re: Finish question
George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA
>Good Afternoon Walt,
I take a different tack, and try to avoid staining cherry at all. I also don't use lacquer because of SWMBO's absolute aversion to the smell. Instead, I set the piece outside in strong sunlight for several days after thoroughly preparing the surfaces as Bill recommends. The sunlight will darken the color/shade noticeably. However, the application of 2 coats of Seal Coat shellac, scuffing with 320/ tacking, and then repeated rubbed out coats of 50/50 poly/naptha allow the cherry to fulfill its color destiny. I use paste wax when the finish work is complete. The above schedule is what I used on a secretary desk I made for my #3 daughter from a tree felled by hurricane in her back yard.
I believe my method yields a pleasing result, but so do the others. Take your pick and plunge.
George
Re: Finish question
R. Gryder
>Pretty doggone nifty work, George. R.
Dont stain...
Chris Knob
>When you rey to "age" fresh cherry with staining, blotching can be a problem as oil dissolves pitch deposits within the wood causing uneven penetration of stain. The best finish for cherry IMHO I have found over the years is nitrocellulose lacquer and sunlight. If you have an aversion to spraying that noxious stuff, the second best is wipe on oil based polyurethane.
Lacquer finished cherry
Lee Schierer - McKean, PA
>Here are a couple of pieces of mine that were made of cherry and finished with lacquer, no stain.


Note: The dark areas become light colored and the light areas become dark when the angle of lighting changes.
Lee
Re: Dont stain...
jerry mayfield
>Mr. Bob Flexner says most cherry will blotch even under a clear finish.
Regards
Jerry
Re: Dont stain...
Chris Knob
>It will but far less if you do not usean oil soluble dye/pigment stain as most commercial products are. As I said, I get my best results with lacquer which blotches very little
Re: I agree with the Colonel
Glenn Madsen near San Francisco
>except I use an alkyd varnish, rather than a poly. That's a personal choice, and comes from an aversion to yellow cans, mostly. ;-)
George does much more with cherry than I, though.
When doing my last major cherry project, I did up sample boards for the finish, and let the wife sign off on the one she wanted. Eased the pain for a number of reasons.
Re: Finish question
Brianna
>I really like this.. Very nicely done!