Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

OT, Trajectory? Archery

Posts

OT, Trajectory? Archery

#1

OT, Trajectory? Archery

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>I have gotten back into archery hunting after about 20 years off. Last weekend, I was up a tree at the head of a little draw, which compelled me to climb higher than I normally would to get a good vantage over under-story branches for most directions, but down the slope, the angle was pretty steep.

I started wondering if I had the opportunity to shoot down that way, should I estimate the distance as straight line, or distance over the ground from the base of the tree?

Any good carpenter would know that a right triangle with a base of 4 a height of 3, will have a hypotenuse of 5. So If I shot at something 40 feet out from the base of the tree, should I aim as if it were 50 feet away?

What say yee math or physics wizards? At that distance, the difference would be about 4 ~ 5" difference in drop.

Re: OT, Trajectory? Archery

#2

Keith, I wish I could tell you...

Ellis Walentine, Host

>...but I've put out the word to some of the best archery hunters I know. I hope they'll weigh in...

Ellis

Re: OT, Trajectory? Archery

#3

Re: OT, Trajectory? Archery

Walt Segl

>Keith,

Check out this link http://www.archersadvantage.com/TipSheets/UpDownHill.htm

I think it will answer your question. My take is I don't take shots over 30 yds and always use a laser rangefinder. Practice, practice and more practice! If you aren't certain about the shot pass it up. As long as you can get a clear heart/lung shot you are good to go. My Bowtech always seals the deal:-)) Ask Ellis, he has had some steaks and backstraps and seems to like venison.

Good luck.

Walt

Re: OT, Trajectory? Archery

#4

Re: OT, Trajectory? Archery

Craig

>There are two factors that effect an arrow after it leaves your bow, Wind drag and gravity. We will ignor wind drag, it is a fairly small component. The main thing that effects drop of an arrow is the amount that gravity can pull the arrow toward the ground. This force works perpendicular to the surface of the earth and effects the arrow over the horizontal distance that you are shooting. There are some complicated force vector discriptions, but basically you should us the horizontal distance from you to the target. There will be slight variation and it is best to practice these shots if possible. And don't dismiss the third component-Wind.

Re: OT, Trajectory? Archery

#5

Re: OT, Trajectory? Archery

Frank Mutchler

>Keith,

"The largest single problem tree-stand hunters grapple with is learning how to compensate for downward arrow flight. An arrow always hits higher than normal on downward shots because gravity has less effect on its trajectory. This means you must aim lower than normal for killing hits. Hitting much lower depends on several factors, including the speed of your arrow, the angle of your shot, and the distance to your target. As a general rule, you should aim for the horizontal distance to an animal. In other words, a deer standing ten yards from the base of your tree-stand tree requires a ten-yard shot - even if actual shooting range is 15 yards. Some bowhunters pace off level distances around a stand to predetermine shooting yardages from the base of their trees.

Since tramping near a stand tends to frighten approaching game with lingering human odor, it makes more sense to use a top-quality rangefinder like the Ranging Model 50/2 to calculate distances from the tree trunk below your stand to nearby landmarks. If you jot down these ranges on a notepad, you can commit them to memory after you climb aloft.

For close-range shooting from a tree, so-called pendulum bowsights work tolerably well. Saunders, Browning, and others sell such sights. As you increase your downward shooting angle, the aiming pin on such a sight rotates farther and farther upward to compensate for flattening arrow trajectory. Most pendulum sights must be adjusted for the precise height of your tree stand. Otherwise, sight placement is apt to be off. Correctly used, pendulum tree sights can be deadly out to 25 or 30 yards. Beyond these distances, such sights do not work well at all. Pendulum sights also tend to be more fragile than fixed sights - something that disturbs some serious bowhunters."

Shooting Industry, 1989, Chuck Adams

First time I shot at a nice buck from a tree stand the arrow went high. I didn't have a computer then and Google didn't exist.

Re: OT, Trajectory? Archery

#6

Thanks Walt for that link.

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>There was more information there than I wanted, but that was the answer that I had expected. After posting, I was trying to reason this out. As I usually do, I tried to push the numbers up to extreme levels to imagine the results.

For example, I imagined that if I was 100 feet higher, and shooting at a target only 10 feet out from plumb, I knew I would need to aim lower as if it were the 10' distance. However, I hadn't taken into account the parallax issue, which would require an even lower aim.

I put a ladder up yesterday, and have started shooting down from the roof of the shop now. I think that is going to help a lot.

Re: OT, Trajectory? Archery

#7

time distance and gravity

Robin in Atascadero CA

>Back when I took physics in college one of the experiments we did was to prove that if you drop a bullet at the exact same time you fire one from a gun and from the same height they will hit the ground at exactly the same time. The lesson is that the force of gravity is the same regardless of the speed an object is traveling in a horizontal direction.

You need to compensate your aim because of the time the arrow is in the air not because of the distance.

Robin

Re: OT, Trajectory? Archery

#8

Re: OT, Trajectory? Archery

John K Jordan

>The geometry changes radically with a free projectile fired from off-horizontal. All I can recommend is to practice FROM a height. A buddy of mine practiced like a maniac, but always on flat ground. Oh, he was good.

His first shot from a tree stand missed by about 2 feet. The next one missed by just a foot.

JKJ

Re: OT, Trajectory? Archery

#9

with the name of Newton this should be...

Roger Lance in GR, Michigan

>easy for you....like others have said your namesake thought that S=1/2att solved the calculation of distance an object will drop towards the earth over time at a constant value for gravity at about 32 feet/second x second....for calculating the distance an object will move horizontally while gravith works on it, you have to know the speed its moving horizontally...muzzle velocity in the case of a firearm and in the case of a bow, its its "muzzle" velocity with a particular arrow and broadhead...the faster the muzzle velocity the "straighter" or flatter it will fly (less trajectory needed) to hit a target as gravity will have less time to work at pulling the arrow toward earth...bow hunters up here practice from treestands with the actual equipment they will use hunting to get what you are asking answered...if my bow shoots faster than your bow, i don't need as much trajectory as you will need with all other variables equal.

Re: OT, Trajectory? Archery

#10

Yea Roger, I have a copy of Isaac's " Principea"

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>around here somewhere. I should have just dug it out and studied it. ha,

I have been getting up on my roof to shoot down at my target, across the parking lot. My shop is an old grocery store, 50 X 100', so I can start at one end, and work my way toward the other to increase the distance. I can tell that this is going to help. However, it was so cold this morning before work, that I nearly froze after just a few rounds.

I have looked at the range finders, and won't be able to afford that this year, having just bought other new gear, stand, and clothing. It seemed weird to give up my home built climbing stand that I made back in the late sixties, but it saw too heavy for this old man. It was only one part, so I had to bear-hug the tree, to pull it up. Of course back then, I was like a big cat that could kill a deer then climb a tree with it in its grip to eat it up there.

I am still shooting my old Jennings model T which I bought back around 1974 ~ 75, but with a few improvements, it is still shooting pretty good.

Re: OT, Trajectory? Archery

#11

Re: OT, Trajectory? Archery

Ron Jackson

>New range finders made for archers have an angle compensation feature. Take a peak at Cabelas web site.

Re: OT, Trajectory? Archery

#12

Re: OT, Trajectory? Archery

Andrew F in Australia

>As someone who spent about ten years barebow hunting every weekend, I can't answer the question but empirically.

If you're aiming at something below your feet, you aim a little lower (ie: assume that it's a little closer.) As you got up the tree, you'd be aiming a little lower on the animal.

About the 3-4" you're speaking about should do it.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: OT, Trajectory? Archery

#13

Re: Body position

Roger Peterson

>Keith,

Along with a lot that has been suggested here in regard to physics and trajectory, I would also keep in consideration your anchor point at full draw and position of your bow arm in relation to your torso.

If you are practicing on the ground note how your bow arm is perpendicular to your torso. When we get in the tree however, many tend to drop their bow arm instead of bending at the waist to maintain the proper position, that which you practiced with your bow arm perpendicular to your torso.

Not a master bowhunter, but I take 2-3 deer a year from 15-25' stands and have shot high on a number of them, typically when I lose concentration of my approach to the shot. Not just buck fever, I get just as excited taking does. I practice from my garage roof to help prep me to remember to bend at the waist to help avoid losing my position. I was taught to make a T with my body and maintain that when drawing from a tree stand.

Re: OT, Trajectory? Archery

#14

Re: Response to arrow trajectory

Roger Peterson

>

Re: OT, Trajectory? Archery

#15

Re: time distance and gravity

John C. (Virginia)

>Not sure if this is responsive, because my bow/arrow experience is nil. However, I do have a good amount of experience with firearms, and with sighting. Gravity is a constant, so the sights are adjusted accordingly. It's subtle, but a pistol zeroed for 25 yards shot level will pass it's point of impact twice, once on the way up at about seven yards and again on the way down at 25. Soo, if you are within 7 yards and holding true, you'll impact low. Beyond 25, you'll be low again.

I would assume the same applies to bow/arrow shooting -- assuming a true pull and release, point of aim point of impact will depend on how the bow is sighted.

Of course, YMMV. John