Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Grinding wheel question

Posts

Grinding wheel question

#1

Grinding wheel question

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>I asked on the turning forum earlier in the week and received a number of answers. I thought I'd ask here too.

I need a decent wheel for my cheapo Ryobi 6" high speed grinder. It will be used to renew edges on irons (would like to try hollow grinding), chisels, and turning tools (rarely).

From the suggestions on the turning board, it seems a 3/4x6 or 1x6 100 grit Norton 3X I Grade wheel would be good. I will also need a wheel dresser tool.

Does the 100 grit Norton I 3X sound reasonable? I thought maybe 100 grit would be a good middle of the road grit.

I have some Hock A2 irons if that matters?

Thank you.

Joe

Re: Grinding wheel question

#2

Re: Grinding wheel question

Virgil J

>High speed and 100 grit sound like a recipe for overheating to me. I would be much more comfortable with a 60 grit "H" wheel. I have a 60 H on my 3450 grinder and it is all to easy to overheat part being ground and I have a fair amount of off hand grinding experience. The next upgrade in my shop is going to be an 8" 1750 rpm grinder and I'll put a good quality 46 H and 60 H wheel on it.

Re: Grinding wheel question

#3

Re: Grinding wheel question

GalenV

>There is nothing wrong with the LOT cheaper Norton white wheels you can get at sharpeningsupplies.com for less than $15. I thought the 100 grit wheel put a good edge on my HSS lathe tools with light pressure. You are not taking off but a split hair of material to restore an edge. I like the wider 1" wheel but you need to be sure you have shaft length on your 6" grinder.

Re: Grinding wheel question

#4

suggestions and some sage advise on how to

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>1. Read my article in the Articles section on wheel theory and selection. It helps to understand the fundamentals of wheel construction and use and will help interpret advise and make a selection.

beyond that.....

You will have a much easier time grinding the edge of a chisel or plane iron if you round(crown) the wheel. Grinding is NOT thrusting the tool straight into a flat wheel and hoping for the best. Grinding is a "touch and go" operation as the tool is slid back and forth across the wheel supported by a nice big flat tool rest. The tendency is for the tool edges to get over-ground compared to the tool center and this problem is mitigated with a crowned wheel. The crowned wheel enables one to only grind the middle of the tool edge and this ability is essential. That said, a 1/2" wheel is all that is useful. A 1" wheel is a 1/2" of unused wheel surface.

The Norton 3X wheel is a consumer version of their "tool room" ceramic abrasive "SG" wheel. The main advantage of the ceramic abrasive is longer wheel life compared to a soft bonded wheel of equal or better coolness of grinding. The ceramic wheels make a lot of sense for production, and maybe turners, some of whom seem to grind a lot. In my opinion if you need the long life buy the "professional" SG wheel. If not, get a soft bond pink or white wheel. In my mind the consumer 3X wheel (meaning 30% ceramic and the rest normal white) makes little sense to the user (as compared to the marketer).

Stanley plane irons are the test of one's ability to grind cool. They are so thin that heating is a problem. I have ground them with up to 120 grit at 3600 rpm, providing the wheel is a very soft bond. It is the bond and the grinding pressure that is most important, not the wheel speed nor grit size. More than not burning, the challenge will be whisking off tiny controlled amounts of metal. In that regard 100 grit and slower speed may be helpful for CONTROL, more so than coolness.

All that I have said applies to sharpening, not so much reshaping or manufacturing tools. Again, for sharpening, the main challenge is the controlled removal of tiny amounts of metal at the tool edge.

Final comment, hollow grinding with a wheel is the preferred way to sharpen. It is very quick to follow the hollow grinding with very quick honing with any of a number of honing abrasive techniques. Personally, I prefer the low cost and speed of diamond honing.