Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

table repair

Posts

table repair

#1

table repair

JUDY MORRILL

>Hi All-

I'm looking for an educated opinion on how to repair an antique table. It is a small occasional type of table with 2 drop leafs , probably over100 years old and made of cherry. The top split and spread and some misguided person attempted to screw the split together. The leafs and apron came off ok.

I'm thinking that the best way to repair the top is to remove the screws and and clamp the to pieces together split side up and carefully plane them both together with a jack plane or smoothing plane to hopefully achieve 2 matching surfaces taking off as little as possible. I'm a little leery of using the router for fear of chipping although it would be with not against the grain. Also not sure if I should just glue it or dowel or biscuit it back together for strength.

Thanks,

Judy

Re: table repair

#2

Re: table repair

John E in SC

>Not sure if I'm visualizing your problem correctly (picture might help), but I think you're on track with removing the screws and gluing the split back together, then smoothing the surface (a light sanding might be all that's needed.) I really don't see where a router could be involved at all. As long as you have good long-grain contact, no dowels or biscuits would be needed. If the screws are actually through the surface that is being glued together, you might need to sand lightly to "de-fuzz" those areas and make them smooth prior to gluing so you get a nice tight joint.

Good luck, and let us know how it works out.

John

Re: table repair

#3

Re: table repair

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Judy,

I would remove the screws first. I've had split table tops which came together nearly perfectly under slight clamping pressure, and there was no need to joint the two mating edges. Try that first. If they mate, edge glue them up. Use cawls to keep the assembly flat. The modern glues have sufficient strength to bond the halfs of the table permanently.

George

Re: table repair

#4

Re-read your post...

John E in SC

>After re-reading your post, I think I'm visualizing better what you're intending to do - you're talking about planing away the area where the split was to get a smooth surface BEFORE re-gluing, correct? That would decrease the width of your table, and then the aprons might not fit correctly. Also, the grain on top of the table wouldn't match, making the seam more visible. As long as you carefully clean up the split with a little light sanding to remove any old glue, fuzz from the screws, etc., I think you would get much better results just gluing the split back "as is" rather than trying to plane it down.

Re: table repair

#5

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: table repair - why did it split?

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Why did it split in the first place? Was is because the table top was solidly fastened to the framework with no provision for expansion/contraction? That'd be my guess.

Did it split along a glue joint (failed joint) or in the middle of a board?

If it's on a glue joint, (probably hide glue in a table that old) then you might be able to just carefully scrape off the old glue and re-glue the joint. Re-mount the top with a method that will allow for subsequent seasonal movement - like 'Z' clips, or those 'figure 8' clips that are sold for that very purpose.

If the split is in the middle of a board, and goes the full length, then the method you suggest will work. I'd try to fit it together without planing first, though. If that works, then no planing will be needed.

If you do have to plane it, I doubt you'll need to remove so much that the fit to the aprons will be drastically affected. The 'Z' clips or 'figure8s' will compensate for that.

Jim D.

Re: table repair

#6

I'm confused

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I am not picturing this wound, particularly the role of the screws in the attempted repair. A picture would be a great help. Pictures are easy to post on this site and someone can help you if you get the picture taken.

The table may be valuable so do't risk screwing it up further. Let us be clear on the nature of this split, where it is located, how bad, etc. before offering suggestions on a repair.

I agree with others that splits can be easy to repair. But when I have gotten into these problems often the reason the thing split in the first pace needs to be fixed before the split. Just recently had such a case with a lady's cherry table (were you using an alias?) The split resulted from other loose joints. She didn't want to pay to have it fixed which was too bad as it was a wonderful old table and its lose joints were eventually going to be its total ruin.

Re: table repair

#7

Re: table repair

JUDY MORRILL

>Some clarification is in order. I don't know why it split but I suspect as Mr. Delaney suggested it was because it had no room for expansion as it split the length of the board,the board itself not a glue joint. The screws were driven diagonally underneath through the split in an attempt to pull the split together which it did not.Its been left like that for many years.(Homer Simpson's great grandfather)? It wont mesh back together by simply gluing and clamping. There's about a 1/32nd gap in the center of this split which runs the length of the board (24"). What was the void of the crack or split is full of dirt or whatever. The finish is so poor its hard to see the grain and since it is going to be refinished it might be a good idea to strip it to see.

Re: table repair

#8

Dale Lenz

Re: Sounds like a job for an 06~08

Dale Lenz

>plane is in order. The crack is full of dirt, so even if you could squeeze it shut, gluing not a good option, at this point. As you suggested there are several options to true up the joint prior to glue up. I would use a hand plane, but that's me. Joe's Cabinet shop in town might rip on a table saw and reglue, not me, but I'm not Joe. If you let us know what town you are near, maybe someone here would be willing to assist.

Sound like you are talking of the center piece of the table that has cracked. Could be the method the maker attached the top to the base(?). Good luck and let use know what took place.

Re: table repair

#9

Re: table repair

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>One detail to keep in mind: after the top is repaired will it have enough width so the leaves will hang okay? If the top is too narrow the leaves won't 'fall'.

If it looks like the top will not have adequate width after repair, your options are to make a new top or add a piece of cherry at the repair joint. If you decide to add a piece of cherry, try to select stock with annual rings the same as the old wood on either side. This will cause similar light reflection off the two different pieces of wood and will tend to make the repair less obvious.

Re: table repair

#10

table repair???

Ralph Turney in Huntington Beach, CA

>Has anyone noticed that the piece is an antique and wouldn't a good cleaning be the first order of things and then decide on a method to fix it? I am not to well versed on the protocol of antiques, but from everything I've seen and heard, isn't the finish is the most important part?

Now, it's not my piece and the owners can burn it if they want, so I'm not trying to tell anyone what to do here.

Might there not be a better way to fix this piece than with table saws and planes though???

Ralph

Re: table repair

#11

Re: Sounds like a job for an 06~08

JUDY MORRILL

>I think a tiny bit of hand planing is going to be the way to go. The owner who is a friend wants to refinish it as whats left of whatever finish it originally had is distressed to say the least. Dull and dark.Thanks for all the suggestions. I'll let you how it goes and may get a picture up if I can endure the dial-up speed of uploading. Thanks for reminding me about using cauls whoever that was.

Re: table repair

#12

Re: table repair???

Steve Schoene

>I agree about cleaning rather than stripping. In particular anything you can do when regluing the split to avoid having to sand the top surface at all would be worth the effort. But in general it is best to do the repairs first, then clean, and if that's not enough only then strip, using chemical stripper.

Sanding old finish off a cherry table will distroy any economic value and make it much less attractive to boot. A sensitive refinishing, retaining as much patina as possible, and avoiding such none authentic materials such as polyurethane varnish, won't hurt value terribly much on pieces that were not painted and in particularly if they were made in a factory, especially if just 100 years old. If made before about 1830 the issue becomes more complex.

For cleaning start with a solvent such as naphtha to remove oily dirt, and then use a small amount of detergent in water to remove water soluable dirt, though don't get it soaking wet in the process. You might be surprised at how much benefit this can achieve.