Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

band saw

Posts

band saw

#1

band saw

Jean

>Looking for a band saw for a friend. Not table top. Easy to see guide and easy blade change would be great. Low vibration would be a plus also. Any suggestions would be appreciated.

Re: band saw

#2

It would help if we knew......

Barry Irby

>what your friend expects to do with the saw. Many of us have a 14" (diameter of the wheel) Delta (or Jet Or similar) band saw. That limits the cut between the blade and the frame to about 13" and the height of the cut to about 6". Most of these saws permit the addition of a "riser" block that increases the depth of the cut to about 12". That's important if you want to resaw wider boards or cut wider thin pieces of veneer. So, these saws will do a decent job of resawing , but if that is the primary use, they are often under powered and slightly frail. You might consider going to a larger more heavily built saw with a bigger motor. If your plan is to cut thin (under 6" thick)stock most any of them would be fine. Remember, a big saw will do everything a little one will and more. The disadvantages would be increased cost, they take up more room and they are harder to move when moving time comes. I have a Delta and would be inclined to buy another or a Jet because they are commonly available and parts and accessories are consistently available.

Re: band saw

#3

Re: band saw *LINK*

David Lykins -Dallas GA - guitardude

>I don't have hands on experiece with this saw, but I've always read rave reviews by magazines and owners of the Grizzly 14" Ultimate Bandsaw. If I had the cash I'd sell my 12" JET and buy one with the riser kit. Hard to beat for about $500 shipped to your door.


img

G0555 14" Utlimate Bandsaw

Re: band saw

#4

Re: It would help if we knew......

Jean

>Barry,

Thnank you for your insights.

I believe you are right in mentioning that the big ones can do everything the small ones do and more. I think my friend wants to eventually do all of the tasks you mentioned, so it makes sense to get one that will do it all.

Re: band saw

#5

Re: band saw

Alex Grigoriev

>I have one. It's pretty good; some shortcomings that sould be the same for other similar 14" saws.

1. I added at-the-blade under-the-table dust extraction port. Does wonders.

2. With the riser block, the frame becomes less rigid. Gets off alignment as you change blade from 1/4 to 1/2 and tension it accordingly. That happens because the long connection bolt stretches too much. The frame cast is also not shaped in optimal way for the best rigidity.

3. The table came a bit crooked. Again, because the ribs configuration is suboptimal, and its rigidity is compromised by the blade slit.

4. I replaced the tires with urethane ones.

5. Balanced the upper wheel. Could not do that for the lower one.

6. Loosen the upper and lower axles. Otherwise the bearings were overtightened and they were not rolling freely.

Re: band saw

#6

Re: band saw

Jim Dillon

>Jean,

Like many, I also have the Delta 14 inch bandsaw purchased roughly 10 years ago. It has been a wonderful tool and over time I have made numerous additions to the saw to increase its capability. However, considering the cost of those additions, and IF I had the space (not to mention the money), I would opt for a larger BS if I were shopping today. There are some very nice ones available these days, but I really haven't kept up on the individual comparisons to give any worthwhile advice. Certainly, dust collection appears better with these bigger models, and I think that is an important consideration. Just my two cents and have fun shopping.

Jim

Re: band saw

#7

Re: band saw

John K Jordan

>>IF I had the space (not to mention the money), I would

>opt for a larger BS if I were shopping today

After getting great use from a 14" delta with riser for years, I purchased an 18" saw (rikon). Wish I had done that a long time ago - more power, stronger frame/better tensioning, wider blade capacity, larger table. The cost is higher but the floor space required isn't significantly more. I had a lot of vibration until I seated it properly against the concrete floor - smooth now.

JKJ

Re: band saw

#8

Re: band saw

Jim Dillon

>John,

That's interesting to know about the larger capacity BS floor space requirement. Gee, I was just out in the shop for something else, and looked over at my faithful Delta and tried to imagine if a bigger BS would fit in the same space. Ah, that's what dreams are for 8-).

Jim

Re: band saw

#9

Re:Floor Space-I know the feeling

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Hi Jim,

I know exactly what you mean. Last year I was looking around Craig's list for months in hopes of finding a mint condition 6" jointer for my #3 son. As luck had it, a nearby cabinet shop was geting rid of a beautiful 8" machine with two extra sets of knives for $250-$300. It was just too long-bedded for my son's shop, so I looked at mine. Same deal--I couldn't make it fit. We had to pass it up.

George