Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Wood Allergy Question

Posts

Wood Allergy Question

#1

Wood Allergy Question

Barry Irby

>I am apparently allergic to walnut. I have posted about it before and am being more careful. Tried today to work it wearing a N-95 disposable mask from 3M. My nose is irritated and I can blow a little blood. I have been using a North half mask with canisters set up for particles and odors (charcoal). I know when to change the charcoal filters, because I can start to smell stuff through them. The disposable masks don't have the charcoal. Now I am wondering if just the smell of the walnut is enough to irritate my nose?

Re: Wood Allergy Question

#2

Re: Wood Allergy Question

Fred Davis

>The oil in Walnut is toxic to many woodworkers, few plants grow under Walnut trees for that reason.

In adition , Walnut sawdust is toxic to horses hooves and ruins them , so it is not used in horse stalls for bedding

FredD

Re: Wood Allergy Question

#3

JL

Re: Wood Allergy Question

JL

>The juglones in the walnut have a particular vapor pressure (slight but still there). This means if you can smell it, they are getting through your mask. The charcoal in your other mask absorbs organic material - including the juglones.

I am afraid if you want to continue working with walnut, you'll need a mask that stops organic vapors - not just dust. Some good quick mask testers are oil of wintergreen or "banana oil" (amyl acetate). If you can smell them, the mask won't work against organic vapors.

Bottom line - if you can smell it - it is getting through.

Re: Wood Allergy Question

#4

Re: Wood Allergy Question *LINK*

wilbur

>To continue this train of thought, filter ratings describe how much stuff they filter, and what they filter. The letters N, R, and P mean:

N = filters airborne particles, not resistant to oil

R = filters airborne particles, somewhat resistant to oil

P = filters airborne particles, strongly resistant to oil

and the numbers mean:

95: filters 95% of airborne particles

99: filters 99% of airborne particles

100: filters 99.97% (surprise!) of airborne particles

So if the allergens that are triggering your allergies are in the walnut oil, your N95 mask won't do a thing for you. Even if the allergens are in the dust, your filter is letting 5% of those particles through. What you need is a respirator with a P100 filter in it.

More info on this is at http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/npptl/topics/respirators/disp_part/

As far as respirators go, I really like this one from AO Safety. It's on sale right now at Amazon:

http://www.amazon.com/AO-Safety-95090-Quicklatch-Respirator/dp/B0000DCBDQ/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&s=hi&qid=1231112284&sr=1-3

It's very comfortable, fits well to my face, comes with replaceable P100 filters, and is only $40 on sale right now, with free shipping. I can wear mine for an entire afternoon without feeling uncomfortable.


AO Safety P100 respirator

Re: Wood Allergy Question

#5

Re: Wood Allergy Question

Alexander Grigoriev

>One time after routing walnut without good dust capture, I got phantom smell which lasted for a week. No good.

Re: Wood Allergy Question

#6

Dale Lenz

Re: Might ask you doctor...

Dale Lenz

>but it's somewhat common during this time of the year, dry air, that I will sometimes blow a little bit of blood from my nose. It's been a topic at work within the last week or so, several folks have be having slightly bloody nose blows.

Re: Wood Allergy Question

#7

Re: Might ask you doctor...

Barry Irby

>Good idea, I have skin on my ankles that is so dry I would happily scratch it until it bleeds. To many permutations and combinations. I get most of my shop time in the winter. Might be a combination of dry air and walnut.

Re: Wood Allergy Question

#8

Get to your Doc and get a definition

Chris Knob

>Alergies come in all kinds of grades. What you seem to be describing is an alergy of the irritant variety...that is the reaction is local and not systemic. I doubt walnut "vapors" are causing your nasal irritation...it's the dust itself in contact with your nasal mucosa that is problematic agent. As long as you are not suffering other, more serious, global allergic issues, (skin irritation, blotchiness, a feeling of a swelled throat, hives, wheezing) you can probably continue to work with walnut using a proper barrier mask but as I stated, get your allergy graded first by your doc. I would predict you wont have much of a problem with this in the future.

Re: Wood Allergy Question

#9

Remember what "smell" is.....

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Smell is your nose receptors coming into contact with airborne molecules of whatever it is that you smell.

This is a great and sure way to get lots of "ooooo-yucks" from kids when you discuss this in relation to smelly cheese, or the smells when someone "cuts-the-cheese" ;)

Happy Woodworking!