Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

How do I do this/how did THEY do this?

Posts

How do I do this/how did THEY do this?

#1

How do I do this/how did THEY do this?

Phil Berman (Montville, NJ)

>below is a picture of a mantel whose front is shaped in 2 different planes, i.e. the front of the mantel bows out in areas and in in others, along with the curved shape along the bottom edge of the piece. I've seen an original, as in from the late 1700's, in person, so I know that the moldings along the edge framing the opening of the firebox were applied. I've successfully created a blank that fits to the piece I'm working on, but obviously can't just use a router or a molding plane to shape the face because of the curves in the 2 different planes. I've considered a scratchstock, but this molding requires removal of quite a bit of material and have been advised against this route. Hand carving is a possibility, although I don't know how I'd get a straight-enough line using just some carving tools. So, how do I make this? Have I misinterpreted the construction of this thing? Does anybody have any idea how the French did this in the 18th century, without benefit of power tools or even electric light for that matter? I'm stumped!!!! By the way, in real-life, my mantel is being constructed of 8/r walnut which was cut into thirds, mitering the center section at 4 degrees on each side, then the whole thing put together and chopped,shaped,carved, and had a lot of bad words thrown at it.

Thanks,

Phil


img

Re: How do I do this/how did THEY do this?

#2

Re: How do I do this/how did THEY do this?

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Phil, I am not sure how they did it back then, but for now, you should be able to do this with a router. I add a sub-base with some camber sawn in that will allow it to go down into some hollow, without bridging. Since you won't be able to ride along on the base, as you normally would, concentrate on keeping the axis of the router perpendicular to the work at the point of contact.

If you have a fence that has the roller bearing attachment, I sometimes replace the roller with a block of UHMW with a sawn round nose up and down its 1.5" height. If you can't carry the pattern through the steep parts, you can carve that portion easier than you can carve a long straight molding.

A day or two ago, there was a discussion about climb cutting. Well, this may provide some benefit, but with major challenges. On the end where the rotation is most likely to blow out, might benefit from climbing. With the work clamped securely, a good stance, and elbows in close, with the arms locked with the muscles on both sides working against each other. I would rotate in at the waist, taking a few light nibbles to begin with, until I was able to take heavier passes on down through the stretch. Followed by a finish cut back the normal way.

As I try to write this, I realize that there is no way to find words to explain the changing dynamic of what the router will try to do when anyone tries to do what is basically free hand routing. Only through practice does one realize the fine intricacies that allow you to know what to expect when using a router in some of the more challenging applications.

I don't know if I have told you anything that helps, but good luck with the project.

Re: How do I do this/how did THEY do this?

#3

Re: How do I do this/how did THEY do this?

john lucas

>Phil Although it can be done with a router the time it would take to make the jigs wouldn't be worth it. I would cut it like you do a cabriole leg using the bandsaw and then clean it up with a spoke shave and hand carve the recessed parts. It's not as hard as you imagine to get a straight line. Just take your time.

Re: How do I do this/how did THEY do this?

#4

Re: How do I do this/how did THEY do this?

Philip Berman

>Thanks. I did just that, cut the blank as I would a cabriole leg and used spokeshaves to finess the fit to the curves, but I have in fact been leary of going at it with a gouge, thinking that that's not the way to get it. Perhaps I'll make up another blank and give it a shot. Thank you.

Phil

Re: How do I do this/how did THEY do this?

#5

Re: How do I do this/how did THEY do this?

Pete LaBelle

>"They" had the benefit of taking a week or so to do it, as labor was cheap back then. "You" (we) figure we need to do it in a day.

You don't see many of those things, cause the cost was pretty high, even in those days.

A lot of things can be done with adequate time. In today's culture, time is too valuable, thus is not spent where is used to be.

Re: How do I do this/how did THEY do this?

#6

Thank you to all who responded

Philip Berman

>I've actually spent the past several months attempting to find information on recreating something like this, both on the web and in print, but have come up with nothing. Not even an old FWW article! I've already created the blanks for the molding, and have decided to use one of my wooden molding planes that has a pleasing profile to do the straight pieces, and a combination of carving tools and scrapers to tackle the non-straight sections. If it's presentable, I'll post a picture of the result.

Thanks again

Phil

Re: How do I do this/how did THEY do this?

#7

Re: How do I do this/how did THEY do this?

Bill White

>Pete is right, and in most cases the workmanship shows the result. It is a shame, but....

Bill