Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

width of raised panel rails and styles

Posts

width of raised panel rails and styles

#1

width of raised panel rails and styles

al hillier

>I am making some new doors for existing kitchen cabinets. The upper doors are only 13 3/8" wide and 10 3/4" high. I had planned on making the doors beneath these with 2 3/8" wide rails and styles.

Besides the safety issue of narrow rails and styles - is there a recommended minimum width for the rails and styles for the glue joints to be adequate - say 1 1/4"? We may end up using double strength glass for the panels in these upper doors.

All the articles seem to reference widths between 2" and 2 1/2"

Thanks in advance for any thoughts.

Al

Re: width of raised panel rails and styles

#2

JL

Re: width of raised panel rails and styles

JL

>Given the relative strength of the modern glues, I think that the strength of the wood itself would be more of a consideration. I.E. how much wood would it take to prevent from racking, breaking, etc. Another item of consideration would be what looks right - what sort of ratio of rail and stile to panel looks good.

I'd sit down with a pencil and paper and draw some scale drawings. I'd then cut a couple of sample rails and stiles and see what looks good and also how much abuse they will take. My $0.02.

Re: width of raised panel rails and styles

#3

Re: width of raised panel rails and styles

Sawman

>Al, I have done a number of kitchens and been faced with similar size concerns. IF I reduce the stile and rail it is not by much because it ends up standing out from the other doors.

Tom

Re: width of raised panel rails and styles

#4

Re: width of raised panel rails and styles

Barry Irby

>And, I would also look at the article on the strength of joints in the current FWW. It found that butt joints with glue were stronger than stub tenon or stick and cope joints. I and slightly baffled. The difference was significant. I suspect their joints did not provide as much surface area as they might have, but I don't know.

Re: width of raised panel rails and styles

#5

Re: width of raised panel rails and styles

Jim Dillon

>Al,

The size/type of your hinge might dictate the minimum width of your stile. If you are using a European-style hinge (as I did), then the minimum width of the stile is roughly 1 3/4 inches. This gives you around 1/8 inch margin between the hinge bracket and the inside edge of the stile.

On my smaller doors (11W x 17H), I chose 2 inch wide stiles and top rail, and a 2 1/2 inch bottom rail. On the larger doors (17W x 36H), I chose 2 1/4 inch stiles and top rail, and a 2 3/4 bottom rail. I drew scale pictures first using Delta Cad - a 2D drawing program to give me a better idea of the final look.

Regarding strength, I used offset mortise and tenons which automatically generates an inside strip for holding the glass/panel. I never felt strength was an issue, especially with modern glues. And eight years later, the doors are still doing fine. Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: width of raised panel rails and styles

#6

Re: width of raised panel rails and styles

Alexander Grigoriev

>If you analyse the failure patterns in FWW test, it's not much a matter of glue surface.

For a butt joint it's a matter of low strength for pull from long grain surface.

For strongest joint, its failure mode would be wood shear. Lap and bridle joints had that.

In that test, mortise/tenon type joints failed because the tenon was too thin (1/3 of the stock). Floating tenon failed also because it was too narrow. Were it positioned closer to the outer side, it would experience less force and the joint would stand more.

The only joint where the glue failed was miter joint. Because it was end grain to end grain, it seemed to be starved of glue. I'm not sure if it was simply cut on a saw, or it was also shot with a plane after that. I would expect shot surface hold better, provided also with enough glue. Apply glue to both sides, let it stand a bit; only then put them together.

I would expect the strongest joint would be a miter with full-width tapered spline in a tapered groove (see picture). Groove bottom should be rounded. Spline thickness should go from 1/3 of stock on the bottom to 1/2 of stock on the top. Though it might still have fatigue issues with twisting force. For that reason, non-tapered spline might be better in the long run.


img

Re: width of raised panel rails and styles

#7

Re: width of raised panel rails and styles

Fred Davis

>I have make countless numbers of cabinet doors and like Sawman , I rarely vary the width of the stiles , through out the job.

For doors with top and bottom rectangular rails, I make the bottom rail about 1/4" wider in width then the top rail.

This looks better, many shops will make the top and bottom rail the same width so they can reverse the hand of the door, not having to make lefts and rights so to speak.

Mortise and Tenon was the traditional joint for cabinet doors, until the Biscuit came along, which is much faster and as strong as needed , even Wood Institute came around to that conclusion. Haven't had a joint fail to my knowledge yet.

FredD