Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

forrest blades

Posts

forrest blades

#1

forrest blades

DP

>Can anyone tell me the cheapest place to purchase Forrest Blades? Thanks to everyone in advance.

Re: forrest blades

#2

on saving saw blade expenses

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If you are interested in saving money your time (and money) would be better spent investigating whether another blade will do what you need of it. They are both an expensive blade to buy and an expensive blade to maintain (they gum up and get duller quicker than a typical blade due to atypical side clearance).

It seems that the selling point for these blades( and this company does do a lot of advertising that you are paying for) is smoothness of cut. There are few operations in building furniture where smoothness of cut is an issue. End cuts are usually hidden and edge cuts are usually jointed by jointer or hand plane.

Almost all the sawing operations I do for building furniture I do on a 7 1/2 or 8" thin saw blade costing about $20. They are safer, quieter, less dust and cheap. For the few operations where I need them, I have on hand a 10" rip and a cross cut blade (Freud, but most any bland works well).

Re: forrest blades

#3

Re: on saving saw blade expenses

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>There's a local saw sharpening service in my town. I go in and talk to him, and buy what he recommends. He's been keeping the cabinet and industrial guys working for the better part of three decades. Why would I not need something like those folks use?

He sells, among other brands, FS Tools. Those blades have worked well for me, come in all sorts of variants, and are 60% of the price of the Forrests, and need far less tweaking, in my local shared experience.

Or you can track Amazon for a Forrest blade. Your choice.

Re: forrest blades

#4

Re: on saving saw blade expenses

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Don't agree with you. You said:

"..... and get duller quicker than a typical blade due to atypical side clearance).....

Like anything, you have to take care of it. My factory sharpen (on a TK) ran seven years. I shipped it back to Forrest, paid $25 and it's ready to go again. Perhaps I should expect more, but I'm pretty pleased with the service the blade's given me.

And then you said:

"It seems that the selling point for these blades( and this company does do a lot of advertising that you are paying for) is smoothness of cut. "

Here I do agree with you. The cut off the blade is one of the things that Forrest brags about, and I've learned to completely rely on.

Lastly, you said:

"There are few operations in building furniture where smoothness of cut is an issue. End cuts are usually hidden and edge cuts are usually jointed by jointer or hand plane. "

Once again, I disagree. You come off the saw and to the "jointer or handplane" because that's what you're used to doing. I come off the saw (with a Forrest blade) and go straight to glue-up, every single time - no jointer, no handplane. That saves me time, and it allows me to have a much more accurate finished product as I'm consistently cutting to the line, not to the line plus a little bit to allow for future machining.

Look - the Forrest may not be for everyone but frankly, the only folks that I've met that are not believers are the ones who have not spent some time with one. But like everything, they're a compromise. They do not do a good job ripping thick stock and as you've indicated, their limited side clearance can cause sap/gum build-up and this can lead to burning when ripping. This in turn leads to maintenance and that means blade cleaning - a "chore" that takes about five minutes. But I've lived with my blade for almost ten years now, and it's always my primary go-to blade. I've run it on a benchtop saw, a contractors saw and now a cabinet saw and it's still my primary blade.

I guess I'm saying not to knock it until you've tried it. I did a lot of research before buying mine and that included "listening" to the naysayers. But I found that most of the naysayers had never actually tried one, or were pleased with the cut that their father's "25 year old steel blade that has never been sharpened", meaning neither opinion was weighted too heavily. Lastly - I'm considering buying another one and have no problem at all spending the $$ that's asked as I know I'm buying a very good tool.

Rob

Re: forrest blades

#5

May I share a Forrest blade story?

Michael Dresdner

>Many years ago, when I was writing for Fine Woodworking magazine, I was asked to do a controlled blind test on saw blades for an article.

Several other woodworkers joined me for a controlled test of sixty different saw blades. Each was set up on the same, perfectly tuned saw, and performed a number of cuts in a variety of materials (cross cut veneer, solid wood, plywood, etc.)

Each blade was assigned a number, and we created a chart to evaluate the various cuts for each blade. The person making the cuts filled in the "ease of cut" column, but the others were filled in by a panel who did not see the cutting, nor know which blade was which number.

When the chart was finished, everyone involved in the test immediately switched to Forrest blades, though none of us had ever used them before the test. The results were that lopsided.

Over the years, other companies have come closer to Forrest blades primarily by copying what Forrest does. That was not difficult to discover; Jim Forrest, who recently died, was completely open about what made his blades better, and insisted that anyone could do what he did, and that he was more than willing to tell them how. (He told me and even gave me permission to print the information in an article.)

I think Rob said it best. There are things you can do with a great blade, and IMO, Forrest makes great blades, that can make a huge difference in how you work, the time you spend, and your results, but that does not mean you should buy something pricey if you don't need that quality, or if you don't see or utilize those differences.

Remember, if a tool is good, it follows the adage "Tools don't cost money; tools make money."

Re: forrest blades

#6

Re: on saving saw blade expenses

Fred Davis

>Blenn ,

I remember when the old man at Bay Area Carbide started carrying FS blades (made in Germany) and asked me to try one, after that I purchased several for the reason you stated, much cheaper than a Nordic Industrial grade blade and the difference in cutting performence was slight , though you will find that they do not have the number of resharpenings in them that some industrial blades do.

FredD

Re: forrest blades

#7

Re: on saving saw blade expenses

Fred Davis

>

Re: forrest blades

#8

Re: forrest blades

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>Well, I ordered mine a few years ago from Lee Valley so I probably paid near full price. As someone stated above, I'd hit Amazon to see if they can find a cheaper price. Otherwise, just try Google and see what you find. I know that WoodCraft is now stocking them if you have one close and want to save some shipping.

They are pricey but I love mine and it's in the saw most of the time. Like any blade, keep them clean and sharp, which I should do to mine now that I'm thinking about it.

They aren't the greatest at ripping so I'd recommend having a separate ripping blade available, but you can do shorter bits and thinner stock (say 3/4" and under).

Re: forrest blades

#9

Re: forrest blades

Allan D

>I've had a thin kerf Forrest blades for a couple of years and I love it. I bought it from Amazon when they had it on sale for less than 80 bucks.

I place a high value on a tool which will save me time. If I can avoid jointing a piece the high price is worth it to me.

Re: forrest blades

#10

Your story sold me on my first Forrest blade.

Scott in Montana

>Your story sold me on my first Forrest blade. Thank you!

I recently posted a question on whether anyone had tried the Tenryu Gold Medal 10" combination blade ($96). And maybe how it compared to the Forrest. I didn't get any comaparison replies.

I was thinking that after this many years of using the Forrest Woodworker II that maybe a new and improved technology might be out there. Anyhow I bought one of the Tenryu Gold Medal blades and hope to try it out on a bunch of 8/4" claro walnut this weekend. Not that the Forrest isn't doing a great job, I am just curious and recieved a gift certificate at the tool monger's shop for Christmas.

When I bought my Forrest blade, it came with coupons for five free sharpenings. I use the blade a lot and have only gone through two of the coupons so they must hold an edge. I do clean the blade every year or so whether it needs it or not. :O)

Scott in Montana

Re: forrest blades

#11

Re: on saving saw blade expenses

Kirk Constable

>Well, I've got to disagree with almost everything you've said other than the fact that they're expensive to buy. I have two 30T WWIIs, that I've been using for probably 8 years or more. I take the WWII off the saw when the dado goes on... otherwise, I use them for everything, inlcuding a whole lot of MDF. Most of my work over the past 10 years has been with mesquite, and I've cut a LOT of it. I don't 'baby' them. I think I've sent each of the two blades back to Forrest for sharpening once, and one of them may have gone twice. When I started a cabinet job a few years back I bought an Amana plywood blade (almost as expensive as the Forrest) and found the cut inferior to either of the WWIIs as to chipout.

I'm not generally brand concious, but I'm sure a Forrest man. :-)

Re: forrest blades

#12

Re: forrest blades

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>I've gotten good deals from Amazon, forrestblades.com, and WWing shows over the years. You've gotta keep an eye out for sales at Amazon and forrestblades.com.

Re: forrest blades

#13

you have made a flawed assumption

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I own a WWII. It is the least used blade in my arsenal, which means that it does do some rarely used operations better than anything else I own. I have shoved thousands of bd ft of hardwood across a table saw using a wide variety of carbide blades, but in retirement I'm down to only a few hundred bd ft a year in a mostly hobby environment.

By my standards a blade is dull when it splinters on the exit of a cross cut on a ring porous wood like oak or ash. By this measure the Forest blades dull faster than blades with more "set" in the teeth and this observation was confirmed by the saw shop I use which, to quote them, "sharpens hundreds of them a year". Forest's recommendation was to saw with the blade in a higher position, something that I find unsafe.

I would remind you that the start of this discussion appeared to be how to save money on a saw blade. Not buying a Forest blade unless you find its smooth cut compelling remains one means of saving money on a saw blade.

Re: forrest blades

#14

Re: on saving saw blade expenses

Bob Stev

>I disagree as well with everything but the advertising part although I have had two bad experiences with Forrest in the past. I bought a WW2 that wasn't sharp on one side and had to return it for another and I sent Forrest a number of blades for resharpening and they came back damaged and poorly sharpened. Forrest did resharpen them a second time for free once I notified them but one of the blades was never the same and it was my best blade.

Even with that I have two WW2s and need another as these two seem to always be rotating to the sharpener. I gave up on Forrest resharpening though and have them done locally by a great shop. They do seem to go dull quickly although I cut lots of mdf and Wenge.

As for saving money with cheap blades you are losing more in time hand planing and jointing every edge than a blade would cost. I glue up right from the saw and expect the cut to be good enough to do so, that only happens with a good blade. Next to sharp planer blades nothing else in the shop can save time like a good blade. Spend the money and you won't go back.

Bob

Re: forrest blades

#15

Re: forrest blades *LINK*

Dave Paine

>I do not think there is a place which is always "lowest" price. Forrest blades are frequently on sale, e.g., Amazon (links to other sellers).

I included a link to a very comprehensive series of tests done by Scott at Sawmill Creek.

I have tried a few blades myself.

I have a Forrest WWII, 40T regular kerf and 30T thin kerf. I also have 40T Rigid thin kerf and a 24T Freud thin kerf (LU87R).

In my own tests, the Forrest does produce the best cut. Smooth and requires zero sanding/hand planing.

The Forrest blade can result in more burning. As another person stated this blade has "non standard" clearance, which means the steel of the blade is thicker than other blades. This can cause more resin/pitch to build up.

My recent purchase was the Rigid blade. 40T thin kerf. More side clearance on the steel than the Forrest, and it can reduce burning on certain cuts, such as thicker than 4/4 maple. I like the Rigid, but the cut is not as smooth as the Forrest.

I tried the Freud blade, and put it aside after a few cuts. I did not like the finish of the cut.

Finding the "best" blade is a constant search. I have not found the perfect blade. I have found some very good to excellant blades, but no blade is excellant for all cuts.

Good luck in your search.


http://sawmillcreek.org/showthread.php?t=61724&highlight=blade+turns

Re: forrest blades

#16

Re: on saving saw blade expenses

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Fred, that may be true, about the number of resharpenings in them. I'm a hobby guy, and there may be 6 or 8 blades in the rack now. Mine tend not to need sharpening all that often.

I've been going to Bay Area Carbide since the old fellow retired, and I deal with 'the kid' who bought it after working there for over 20 years. They do excellent work.

Re: forrest blades

#17

Re: on saving saw blade expenses

Fred Davis

>Glenn, did you ever think it was a bitch trying to park in front of Bay Area Carbide's shop ;-))

FredD

Re: forrest blades

#18

Re: forrest blades

Fred Davis

>I have read this thread with interest and I find it interesting that there was no mention of saw tuneup.

Doing so if you haven't will let you enjoy the full benefits of a good saw blade, poor saw setup will deliver poor cuts regardless of blade brand or expense.

Somebody pooh poohed saw setup accuracy recently as being not necessary to get it down to a few thousandths or less.

Actually I have seen arbor runout in the .004 to .006 range ruin any chances of glue line rips, chip free cross cutting , because of heeling until it was got rid of.

Same goes for fence and mitre slot alignment with the blade.

There are articles explaining this procedure everywhere , in woodworking magazines, online ,but I suspect going out and plunking down a hundred bucks for a heavily advertised blade that will get you to wood cutting Nirvana before the saw is brought up to specs is the case more often then not.

FredD

Re: forrest blades

#19

Re: you have made a flawed assumption

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Fair enough - but by my count, my blade's cost me about $12.00/year and I'm thankful for it each time I use it. With this accounting, I can even convince my wife it was a good buy :)

Rob

Re: forrest blades

#20

Re: forrest blades

steve arntzen

>FYI: Currently Rockler is selling Forrest blades at 20% off, and free shipping.

Re: forrest blades

#21

Re: forrest blades

Joe Clark

>I am a cabinetmaker and have used a number of blades over the years. I first was a little leery of a blade that was so expensive and after trying one I purchased several and now own enouph so that I always have a sharp one on my Delta unisaw at all times. I use 12" chopmasters on both of my miter saws and have spares. I did not want to buy melamine Hi/AT blades because of there cost and once again now use nothing but those blades. I have over the years, tried several differant blades and now for the most part use mostly Forrest blades for most functions except ripping plywood for kicks and subtops as there is no sense dulling a really sharp blade for that. Expensive, YES! They are a great tool and will have a place in my shop for years to come!

Re: forrest blades

#22

Re: forrest blades

David Parsons

>I have a 10" WW II 40 tooth and it was a replacement for the 30 tooth I purchased thinking it was the other. After using it for a couple of days, I wrote Forrest and told them it was a piece of crap, and Mr. Forrest called me and set up the transfer personally, with no extra cost. They do have as good customer service as anyone!

The 40 tooth works OK but not enough to justify the cost, in my opinion. I have 2-10" Freud 84LU (I think) combination blades. One is at least 25 years old and the other is about 10 years old. I find little difference in the cuts they give, except the Freud is better for ripping. I have recently purchased a Freud 10" straight line glue blade and it is very superior to the Forrest, or any other blade for that matter, for that purpose. It does leave perfect edges for glue joints. I build some cabinets for myself and also clocks for sale and gifts. I use mostly ash plywood and hardwood as well as some cherry and walnut. I am not a heavy duty user but I have done this for a few years and know a good blade from a bad one. For instance, the Delta blades are not too good. I have had very good luck with Freud blades, although this experience is with the commercial ones that are no longer available locally, but are through the internet. I think the Forrest blades are good saw blades, but I don't think they are more for heavy commercial users. A hobbiest would be well served by Freud commercial blades, unless he has more money than he needs. I really do not see any real benefit for the extra cost.

I will be honest and say that I got the Forrest because of the hype and the ads, but I don't think they were much different, except for the price. I can say that the 30 tooth blade was not good for anything. I gave crappy results for ripping and crosscuts. I do not know why they make it!

Re: forrest blades

#23

data?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Your post describes blades as "good" and "bad" and "crap" without ever mentioning any performance data that led you to these conclusions. Personally I don't find good value in the Forest blades because the benefit of a smoother cut is of little value to me relative to the compromises this blade makes to get this smooth cut. But to simply say some blade is good or bad without saying why you judged it to be so is of little use to anyone making a decision on what blade to buy. I haven't ever heard anyone complain that the Forest blades fail to make exceptionally smooth cuts with a properly tuned saw so long as they are sharp. If someone needs this capability then the extra cost of these blades and their propensity to gum up and dull more quickly may not be significant.

Re: forrest blades

#24

Re: forrest blades

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>Mr. Forrest indeed did provide good customer service. And given that his company has been around for some time and many do find his products useful and a fair value, shows his respect for his customers. To continue to trash his product was more than unkind. His blades may not be for you. That's OK. Personally, your post should have stopped at the point of relating Mr. Forrest's customer service.

Re: forrest blades

#25

Re: data

Ralph in Huntington Beach

>I'll tell you the reason I switched to Forrest blades. When I first started off in woodworking about 20 years ago, I wanted to buy the best tools for the money. When it came to saw blades I saw all the advertisements for Freud blades and bought their combination blade (LU84?) and at first I loved it, but very quickly found that the carbide would chip and crack on at least every other tip. Since I was new to woodworking, I assumed it to be my fault somehow and bought another one. I really tried to watch what I was doing with the new blade, but it didn't last any longer than the first one (yes, my Delta contractor saw was very well tuned up). Maybe it's just that blade thought, as I have a Freud 20 tooth rip blade that I use when ripping a lot of 8/4 stock and it seems to be holding up well.

So after talking it over with the boss, she gave me permission to spend the money on the Forrest blade. I loved it then and I still love them today and have never never had a chipped tooth on any of them. I bought the WWII 40 tooth and eventually bought the 30 tooth blade and a couple of others as well. The 30 tooth stays on my saw (PM66) most all the time as it rips well and even cross cuts so well that I almost never find the need to switch blades.

I've had them resharpened and they come back like new, they'll last my lifetime.

That's my story and I'm sticking to it.

Ralph