Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Strugglin' here with mags...

Posts

Strugglin' here with mags...

#1

Strugglin' here with mags...

Bill White

>Sure don't know it all, but I'm not a novice either. So....what woodworking magazines do you folks read, subscribe? Just got my latest Rockler publication, and it was read and tossed in 15 min. 'cause there was very little "meat & taters" to the issue.

Bill

Re: Strugglin' here with mags...

#2

Re: Strugglin' here with mags...

Bill Houghton, California cold in Sebastopol, CA

>"Fine Woodworking," which was lost in the wilderness for a while, has improved again.

"Popular Woodworking," which has a good balance of beginner's stuff and advanced stuff, and good treatment of hand tools.

A year ago, I'd have listed "Woodwork," which, while it got strange and arty at times, also touched on subjects you'd never find in other magazines; but it was recently purchased by another publisher, and I'm holding back recommending until I see how the new kids do.

Depending on your interests, you might also look at "American Woodworker."

Although the individual magazines are more expensive this way, I'd buy a newsstand issue or two before subscribing; see what you like. This is another area in which everyone's mileage varies.

Re: Strugglin' here with mags...

#3

A.J. Hamler

Here's how to choose

A.J. Hamler

>As to which magazines to get, why that's easy.

Just check the table of contents. If you see the name "A.J. Hamler" for that issue, buy it.

A.J.

P.S. -- "Woodwork" was purchased by the same company that publishes "American Woodworker."

Re: Strugglin' here with mags...

#4

Re: My vote goes to Woodsmith

Chuck in ND

>And I like ShopNotes also. But thats just me. I think picking a magazine is a very personal choice.

Re: Strugglin' here with mags...

#5

The Only Mag In This House is .357

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>

Re: Strugglin' here with mags...

#6

Woodshop News

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Woodwork was the highest quality fish wrapper, but it will deteriorate with the new ownership.

Clint

Re: Strugglin' here with mags...

#7

Re: Strugglin' here with mags...

john lucas

>I'm not sure what to recommend because I get almost all of them. One month I like Fine Woodworking the best, the next month it's woodwork, then American Woodworker etc. My problem is I've been working in wood so long and subscribing to the magazines so long that many articles repeat themselves so I'm always looking for that new little tip or new take on an old technique.

Of course new tools come out all the time and I like to keep up with them just in case I find $100K laying around.

It really depends on your level and how far you want to go. Woodsmith, Shopnotes, Wood magazine, and Woodworkers Journal are good for learning and building their projects. American Woodworker, Woodwork and Fine Woodworking offer more advanced studies and fine articles on styles and design.

Re: Strugglin' here with mags...

#9

Paper Quality and Light Reflection

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Hello Bill,

I find it increasingly frustrating to read articles available in many of the WW mags. The gloss paper produces a glare which is uncomfortable enough for me to quit reading. Print size and boldness are also critical. I can get through some "Wood" issues because of reduced glare. For me its a shame not to enjoy the best instruction/reading available because of a physical disability.

George

Re: Strugglin' here with mags...

#10

Popular Woodworking and Woodsmith

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>

Re: Strugglin' here with mags...

#11

Re: Strugglin' here with mags...

Fred Davis

>For what I take in woodworking magazines for what it is worth.

WoodShop News..... will keep you informed about wood prices and trends and new tools and some very informative finish techniques by acknowledged experts.

Fine Woodworking...... or just FWW is probably the leader in Furniture Making , design , techniques, comparison tests on tools and articles by well known woodworkers.

CabinetMaker Mangazine....is a free trade publication that caters to cabinet shops and has a annual publication on tools and machinery.

It covers shops from the smallest one man operations to huge shops with advanced CNC production runs.

There are some very good cataloques such as Lee Valley/Veritas tools, Restoration Hardware, WoodCraft, CHS, all have hard to find items, generally not available lcoally.

This is my no means a comprhensive list , but given the info in them , well worth the taking.

FredD

Re: Strugglin' here with mags...

#12

Fine Woodworking

Greg

>

Re: Strugglin' here with mags...

#13

Woodcraft Magazine

Joe Hurst-Wajszczuk

>Fellas-

With all due respect to AJ, who did get the ball rollin', I think it's time to give Woodcraft magazine a new look.

Start with the cover. Projects. Good ones. Built by some of the biggest names (and nicest guys) in the woodworking business.

Next check the masthead. For those of you who still wax poetic about AW's good old days, you'll like what you see. On the other hand, if you're a WOOD reader, check out the editor-in-chief. The combination of East-meets-Midwest has made for a most interesting year.

Now look at the stories. Using our combined experiences, Jim and I are working hard to offer y'all a woodworking buffet. Power tool and handtool techniques (without mention of must-buy $2500 smoothers). Take-it-to-your shop finishing stories. Plus lots of easy-to-follow projects.

...In baseball, we'd call 2008 "a building year." You can expect to see even more in 2009.

(And yes, we're part of Woodcraft. This means that we do try to find reasons for you to buy something. So does everybody else. But look at it from the other side; all magazines cater to advertisers. Woodcraft could buy pages in other books, but they've chosen to sponsor us in order encourage folks to do more woodworking.

As I see it, if that Convenience-Plus list saves you from a Sunday afternoon race to the hardware store, than it has done it's job. We're making it easier to shop with us, but you're always free to vote with your feet.)

At the risk of opening the floodgates, I'd like to ask you all to give us a fresh look. If you like what you see, tell a friend; if you don't, email me.

joe_hurst@woodcraftmagazine.com

And if anyone thinks they can do better job, I'd like to invite you to try your hand at magazine writing. Our game could use some fresh faces. I'd be honored to help you share what you know with the woodworking community. (Ellis and Tim did a fine job of teaching me how to do on-location stories. After more than a decade, it's still the best part of my job.)

That's it for now. Have a great New Year.

Sincerely,

Joe Hurst-Wajszczuk

Senior Editor, Woodcraft Magazine

Re: Strugglin' here with mags...

#14

Ellis Walentine

You're doing a good job, Joe

Ellis Walentine

>I must say that I like many of the articles you guys are producing nowadays. Keep up the good work.

Ellis

Re: Strugglin' here with mags...

#15

Re: Strugglin' here with mags...

Dick Coers

>Funny story, I lost a part-time job when I answered a question about this over 10 years ago. I was the designer/builder for Woodworker's Journal before you know who bought it. Primedia Corp. closed the magazine due to low profit numbers, still profit, just not enough. You know who bought the title and subscription list and folded it into their Todays Woodworker staff. I was retained as a contributing editor, but was on a don't call us, we'll call you status. I made a comment about the new format and guess what? I haven't read one of their magazines since, so can't comment. I love the inspiration of Woodwork, but have never liked their mix of articles. Still get more info from old Fine Woodworking mags than any others.

Re: Strugglin' here with mags...

#16

Re: Woodcraft Magazine - I beg to disagree

North of the Border

>that 2008 was a building year for Woodcraft; it was in my view a thriving year, in terms of offering a refreshing perspective on woodworking. If I could only take three magazines to an island and got stranded there, they'd be (not in order of preference):

1) Fine Woodworking - for new design inspiration (their projects are hard to build as usually details (required less experienced woodworkers)are lacking

2) American Woodworker - great variety of projects / techniques / reader's tips

3) Woodcraft - great variety and interesting personal stories (about shops and woodworkers)

Shopnotes and Woodsmith have the best reader's tips we can find and are first runners.

What I'd like to see is, as someone has commented, less repeating projects unless the design is unique or much different. There's little point of offering a rocker project unless it's something the Maloof style or quality. Cheap copies tarnish the magazine. I'd like to see some non-woodworking but woodworking techniques covered such as upholstery skill or techniques with metals (e.g. handmade wrought iron hinges), stone and other materials used in woodworking prjects.

My personal experience seems to be the grass on the other side of the fence is greener: the magazine I stop subscribing to seems to be the better one!