dovetail jigs
walt
>I am looking to buy a either a Leigh or OmniJig 24" dovetail jig. I am sure that this question has been asked before but which one better? Before I spend the money I would like to hear some input...pros or cons.
Thank you
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
dovetail jigs
walt
>I am looking to buy a either a Leigh or OmniJig 24" dovetail jig. I am sure that this question has been asked before but which one better? Before I spend the money I would like to hear some input...pros or cons.
Thank you
Re: dovetail jigs
Chris Knob
>I've owned the D-4 for 9 years. I'll tell you what I love about it and what I hate about it.
The adjustability. Love it. No other jig gives you the through and half blind flexibility this jig does.
The adjustability. Hate it. So much to keep track of. If I don't use it for a couple of months, I have to learn how to use it all over again.
Aircraft industry quality milling of parts. Love it. A beautiful, high quality, highly accurate piece of precision machinery.
Aircraft industry quality milling of parts. Hate it. Great machine as long as you don't bang it or leave it out where it can fall off a bench, or drop a screwdriver on it...you know...places like a woodshop.
Pride of ownership. Love it. I have one of the best dovetail jigs ever produced and the envy of most woodworkers.
Pride of ownership. Hate it. I'm an arrogant, hand tool hater who will never become proficient in cutting a hand cut dovetail.
Cant think of anything else!!!
Re: dovetail jigs
Bill White
>Man!!! Opinions and noses are VERY prevelent on this subject. I think I'm gonna stand back and watch.
Following in small type:
I own a PC common blind jig that can be enhanced for thrus, mini DTs,
and box joints.
Bill
Don't overlook the 24" Akeda Jig... Love mine!
Scott in Montana
>
Re: dovetail jigs
Ken Krawford
>I'm with Chris. My biggest complaint is having to re-learn everything if I haven't used the jig in a while. In the past I have cut some beautiful dovetails with it. My last project I just gave up after many hours of not getting joints to fit properly.
Re: dovetail jigs
Dan Donaldson
>I have the Leigh somewhere out in the shop. I think the last time I used or saw it was about 3 or 4 years ago. It is well made and not hard to adjust once you figure out how it works. That said, For most tasks, it is quicker and easier to just hand cut them rather than find the jig and router, plus the bits then add in the setup time. If I were doing a full kitchen or something, I would use one, but not for regular smaller projects.
Keller
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>It is versatile, easy to learn, set up and use.
Re: Keller
Fred Davis
>Dave Kellers product is simple , straight forward, has very soft learning curve, foolproof.
I keep their Pro version set up on 4" angle iron ready to go , no fuss or muss ,or memory loss involved.
FredD
AKEDA
Greg
>Easy, fast setup. Accurate and repeatable joints every time.
dovetail jig
del schisler
>http://www.gifkins.com.au/ This is the one i use on a weekly and some time each day Depends of course what i am doing in the shop I make lot's of jewelry box's You can get this jig from japan wood worker It is easy to set up one set up takes care of both pin's and tails
Keller gets my vote too.
Michael Dresdner
>
Re: Keller
Dick Coers
>Keller will always be my favorite. Set it once and you will never fiddle with it again unless you drop it. It basically doesn't care about stock accuracy since the fixture doesn't have the wood inside the fixture. You clamp it to the wood. You set the bits to the fixture. Moving the bit in the router will not change the fit. It is highly underated in general woodworking circles.
Re: Keller
Fred Davis
>Dick,
since your a Keller fan as I am ,if your doing any serious dovetailing , like say a drawer set for a Kitchen cabinet job , look into Kellers cam clamp system.
Very inexpensive , you do the assembley and furnish the cauls and angle iron .
I have it permenently set up on a table edge so I have pin and tail seperate jigs , along with using two routers and your good to go for a drawer box every minute or so. ;-))
FredD
Re: dovetail jigs *LINK*
charlie belden
>AKEDA.
But if you like jigs that have levers and fingers sticking out all over the place and find aligning a reference line to a specific fine line and enjoy having, and maybe reading, or even studying, a 130 to 150 page manual go for the LEIGH or the Omni.
Figured out where you're going to put this thing - and any attachments you need - when it's not in use? How are you going to protect those exposed "fingers" and what about those levers sticking out? Easy to lose if taken off the unit, easy to damage if left on?
Unlike the other DT jigs, which evolved over time to correct shortcomings of earlier versions, the AKEDA started with a blank piece of paper and a set of well thought design criteria along with a thorough knowledge of modern manufacturing methods and materials.
The AKEDA body is built like a tank, with everyting that can be damaged nicely tucked inside the tank. The little fingers fit in a small box you probably will enjoy making.
Why AKEDA vs the others
Re: dovetail jigs
Alexander Grigoriev
>Charlie, I'm sure your jig is very decent one, but your webpage is Pain In The Rear to read. Wild CAPITALIZATION, a lot of emotion, etc. It's like you're jumping and shouting, foaming at the mouth. I just could not finish it. Of course. that could be just me.
A very, very complete review of the Akeda dovetail
Scott in Montana
>I found the review very helpful and filled with information. Now, I own a 24" Akeda, but still found the site very useful and interesting.
Obviously a heck of a lot of work went into the site's construction. And being an engineer myself, maybe I appreciated some of the information more than others... we engineers can be a bit goofy.
Scott
Re: dovetail jigs
Fred Davis
>Alex,
I made it to the bottom of the first page, seems obvious that he has not used a Keller jig, but that's ok , ;-))
FredD