Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

How would you eliminate dowel-spacing error?

Posts

How would you eliminate dowel-spacing error?

#1

How would you eliminate dowel-spacing error?

Nathan

>Hello to all, back in the shop (and on Woodcentral) after a rather long hiatus.

I'm joining two pine boards together at right angles using a butt joint reinforced with dowels.

The joint is over 6' long. I'm drilling the dowels 11" apart. I start on one end, drill a hole, move the board 11" by inserting a dowel in the hole and pushing the dowel up against a stop. Then I drill another hole, put a dowel in it, re-register, etc. etc. until the end of the board. I do that on both boards I'm joining. When I finish and go to dry fit the two boards together, the holes on the opposite end of the board are at least 1/4" off. I can deal with something like 1/16" but 1/4" is too much and I have to go back and redrill several holes.

What is happening is this: as I re-register and re-drill, the registering error adds up. I'd like to figure out how to eliminate the registering error. I think it's caused by two things: (1) the dowels are not perfectly dimensioned - some are a little thicker, some a little thinner. (2) The dowel could be tilting a little in the hole.

I have two ideas. First, I could start drilling in the middle of the boards instead of at the ends - that might solve the problem, except the way I have my machine set up, I can only set the stop on one side of the bit. So, I'd rather just eliminate the registering error. Perhaps I could get a steel dowel made to exactly the same dimension as my drill bit and use that instead of the wooden dowel to register?

Any other ideas?

P.S. I know I could use a biscuit joiner or a spline instead of dowels, but right now dowels are what I'm set up to do and I'd like to get to the bottom of this.

Re: How would you eliminate dowel-spacing error?

#2

Re: How would you eliminate dowel-spacing error?

Barry Irby

>Now I remember why I stopped using dowels.

First, if you are joining the boards edge to edge, you don't need dowels or biscuits at all, just use glue like Titebond.

Back to the dowels. Are you starting at opposite ends of the boards? It seems the error should be sort of self correcting if you start at the same end and your setup is consistent. That is, if it creeps off a 1/32" or whatever each time, it should be about the same on each board. So, Either your jig is really "sloppy" and you are not consistent in how you use it or you are starting at opposite ends.

Do you have a spare drill bit of the same diameter? You could use the shank as your "steel dowel".

Make sure the holes in your jig are really snug to eliminate "slop".

Or drill a pattern piece that is the same length and the boards and drill all the holes in it. Then register it on each piece you wish to dowel and drill through the holes in it. That way, even if the holes are somewhat random, they will be the same in each piece. Be careful to register it off the same end and edge of the the piece you wish to line up.

Or, Put the two boards side by side, edges up, and use a knife or sharp pencil to draw a line across both where the dowels should be. Then center the marks on each board and drill them. The knife cut works for this because the bit may center up on it.

Re: How would you eliminate dowel-spacing error?

#3

Re: How would you eliminate dowel-spacing error?

Tom MacGregor

>Layout your spacing with a tape or rule, square & a sharp pencil or marking knife on one piece and then transfer the spacing to the other board. There are fairly inexpensive doweling jigs that will guide a drill for 90 degree joints that can be indexed on the marks. Veritas makes a "saddle square" that's handy for this type layout, also.

Re: How would you eliminate dowel-spacing error?

#4

Ellis Walentine

Try the Krenov method

Ellis Walentine

>For doweling accuracy, I've never found a better method than this one: Make a hardwood strip -- about 1 1/2" square is fine for most apps -- the full length of the joint you are trying to dowel together. Drill holes at whatever spacing you want. Attach tabs to the sides, ends or edges of your strip to index on whatever edges of the workpieces are most logical. Hold or clamp the strip to each piece in turn and drill your holes. You can't go wrong. I used to use this all the time for oddball furniture that needed dowels for reinforcement +/- registration.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: How would you eliminate dowel-spacing error?

#5

OK, I'll bite *LINK*

Nathan

>Thanks for the reply, Ellis. Being ignorant, I had to look up James Krenov to find out who he is.

Hijacking my own thread, I'll ask this: Mr. Krenov's website says all four of his books are indispensable. If you could only choose two, which would they be and why?


http://jameskrenov.com/

Re: How would you eliminate dowel-spacing error?

#6

probably all three

Nathan

>> Either your jig is really "sloppy" and you are not consistent

> in how you use it or you are starting at opposite ends.

Actually, I was starting at opposite ends because, just because of how I have this set up on my machine, I could only index by moving the workpiece to the right. Yeah, pretty lame.

I can't dispense with the dowels entirely, much as I would like to, because that would open a veritable Pandora's box of troubles at glue-up time. The dowels, I've found, keep the board edges relatively even. Along the six-foot length there might be a couple minor discrepancies but a little scraping and sanding takes care of them quickly.

Like I said, I know biscuits or a full-length spline would be more elegant solutions but for, uh, . . . practical reasons I can't do those with the tools at hand so I'm trying to get the dowels to work.

I've only got three more of these joints to do, but I think the pattern strip is definitely the way to go. Thanks - I knew you guys would come up with something!

Re: How would you eliminate dowel-spacing error?

#7

Re: OK, I'll bite

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>I'd say get 'em all. Start with your local library, then buy copies of the ones that appeal to you.

Re: How would you eliminate dowel-spacing error?

#8

Re: How would you eliminate dowel-spacing error?

J. Roberts

>If Im reading your problem correctly I use dowel points. They work great. Its little brass thingys that go into one side of the board, join the other board to it and the points that protrude from the brass thingy make their point on the adjoining board. Thats where you drill your adjoining dowel hole.

Re: How would you eliminate dowel-spacing error?

#9

One more vote...

doug f, san clemente, ca

>Buy 'em all; one of the best investments you can make in woodworking "tools". Not only useful, but fun reading, too.

Happy New Year!

Doug

Re: How would you eliminate dowel-spacing error?

#10

Eliminate the dowels

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>If on-edge board is =>3/4, a glue joint is gonna be plenty strong. 6 or 8 penny finish nails for reinforcement or just alignment.

If you really need dowels, drill and install after glueup. Then they'll be automatically registered.

Clint

Re: How would you eliminate dowel-spacing error?

#11

Ellis Walentine

Try it without them sometime

Ellis Walentine

>To me, dowels are not worth the effort for alignment. First of all, most dowels that you buy nowadays are some non-descript Indonesian quasi-hardwood and the diameters are metric, so they never fit really well in holes you've drilled. Furniture factories use pre-grooved and chamfered dowel studs, which are a better fit but still by no means a guarantee of perfect alignment. And if you need to even up the joints afterward anyhow, why go to all the trouble?

I've found that a careful glue up, using a neoprene dead-blow mallet to align the surfaces of adjacent boards and tightening the clamps by degrees as you get things aligned, is pretty darn effective -- but also not perfect.

It's your choice, but I try to go for the least labor-intensive approach whenever possible.

Ellis Walentine, Host

PS A Cabinetmaker's Notebook and The Fine Art of Cabinetmaking would probably be the two Krenov books I would start with. With Wakened Hands is his last book, mostly showcasing some of the incredible work his students have accomplished over the years. I'm fond of that one because I wrote the Foreword. :-)

Re: How would you eliminate dowel-spacing error?

#12

agreed

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>simple and fool proof

Re: How would you eliminate dowel-spacing error?

#13

Re: How would you eliminate dowel-spacing error?

Jerry Marshall

>Ever heard of the Dowelmax? This little Canadian-made gem will make all of your dowlleling tasks routine. Its accuracy is dead-on and it's virtually idiot proof. You can perform a nearly endless variety of joinery operations, including angle joints, face, joints , and many others far more quickly and with as much strength as a mortise-tenon joint. Edge-joining long boards is laughablly simple. Registration is automatic. Go to Dowelmax.com and check out this bad boy. The site has an owner's blog and you may be able to find someone in your area who'd be willing to demonstrate it for you. It'll revolutioniize the way you build stuff.