Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

Posts

Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

#1

Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

Ken Platt (granby, CT)

>Folks -

I came across a need to cut a groove that is .21 or so inches wide. I know I can use my regular table saw blade and make two passes, but was wondering if one could use a dado set with just one outside blade and one chipper since that'd be a bit quicker and, if it works, easier. I would assume that I'd get a rough edge on the side of the groove that just had the chipper, which would be ok for this cut as that side will be hidden. But, is it dangerous? Or would it damage the chipper?

I wouldn't think I'm the first for this question, but I couldn't find an answer in searching archives or googling around. Of course, I may not have come up with the magic words.

I appreciate the help...and feel free to explain to me why I'm being a moron with this.

Ken

Re: Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

#2

Re: Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

Fred Davis

>Ken.

you would get the cleanest cut by using both outside blades ganged together, if that is a tad large , there is no problem using one chipper and one blade.

FredD

Re: Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

#3

Re: Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

Thomas S Stockton

>I wouldn't do it I have no solid proof that it is unsafe except gut instinct, but it sounds like a great way to get hurt plus with just a hogger on the outside your cut qaulity is going to be pretty bad. Two cuts with a regular blade is not that much more work and is way safer.

Tom

Re: Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

#4

WARNING - this is dangerous... *LINK*

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>I don't know why Fred would even suggest this, but dado manufacturers specifically warn AGAINST using a single blade with chippers. I would like to see even one manufacturer's literature where they say this practice is allowed or even considered marginally safe.

The link below is to Freud's literature on the use of the dado. Look at the red warning under "Set Includes". It clearly warns against the use of this practice. Other manufacturers have similar warnings.

Do NOT attempt to use only one blade with chippers on a dado.


Freud Warning

Re: Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

#5

Re: WARNING - this is dangerous...

Fred Davis

>Fred read the caveat on the link, Tim and he noted it is the smallest print on the page.

Since Fred has many times run the blades ganged together and alone ,occasionally just a chipper if I wanted a particular size groove, ( note I said groove) without a mishap of any sort , One has to wonder if Freud isn't erring on the size of caution which is fine.

My Dado is a Freud Pro set and as far as dados are concerned , using chippers alone or along side of a blade could never have the potential for mishaps that say a "wobble dado set has"

So to be absolutely safe, if one is uncomfortable with doing that , don't do it , the fear factor is the thing to be feared . I

Instead of wondering if a solid piece of steel designed for Table saw work will blow up , melt down or what ever you think would happen because the manufactuer is in a "cover your ass approach in his advertising"

FredD

Re: Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

#6

What is so dangerous?

Tom Dunlap

>When I read instructions like this I wonder why it isn't proper to run a setup with only one outside blade.

What might happen that is so dangerous?

Has this happened?

Some rules are made just as CYA. Others are made to solve a problem that doesn't even exist. I'm going to be that this is a valid safety issue. But what is the issue?

Re: Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

#7

Dont know but why risk it

Chris Knob

>As someone with less than the full compliment of originally installed parts on my hands thanks to a table saw...why would you do this? Personally, I hate blade changes anyway so I'd be much more apt to do multiple passes.

Re: Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

#8

Re: What is so dangerous?

Yonak

>Note that the literature cited doesn't say it's dangerous. It just says don't do it. It could be that the user may be unhappy with the results and blame Freud for it, or it could be that a thin chipper used alone could flex and not give a consistent groove.

Re: Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

#9

Jesper, Denmark

Re: The chipper blade is....

Jesper, Denmark

>It only have two teeth set almost 180 degrees apart, so with normal feed rate, the chipper teeth take a much larger bite and they are also not designed to cross-cut. They will normally only have to clean out the short cross grain between the two other blades, which are designed to cross-cut.

I suppose the risk is binding and stopping the blade and also not cutting a smooth side.

Re: Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

#10

Ill advised

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I wouldn't run a single blade and just a chipper for the sole reason that the cut is most likely going to be really terrible. Tear out by the chipper blade would probably be pretty bad since it only has two teeth in a single revolution.

The other problems of bind, kickback etc may also be real, but I thin you will ruin your piece of wood 9 times out of 10.

Lee

Re: Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

#11

Not sure

Ralph Turney

>Someone with a stock feeder on their table saw aught to give this a try and report back on the results...if they're still alive. :-)

Of course, since it looks like the people who have done this don't see it as a problem and the people who haven't tried it, don't want to and probably never will, no matter the empirical evidence, maybe it's would be a waste of time anyway.

I'm not sure if I'd try it either, only because I also hate to change blades and would just do it in a series of cuts instead. On the other hand, I hate the way companies are forced to bow down to the lawyers on some of the most ridiculous things these days and maybe they don't have any evidence that it's dangerous either.

So...on second thought, someone with a stock feeder on their table saw aught to give this a try and report back on the results.

Re: Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

#12

Re: Not sure *LINK*

Fred Davis

>Here you go Ralph ,

for those of you who are unsure and those of you who are , even though you have never tried it and have only a passing acquaintance with Table Saw operation and all of it's aspects.

In my opinion based on years of doing it , cutting grooves with a lone dado blade or lone chipper , or ganged together is safe.

I am not in any way suggesting that those of you who have not tried it and are uncomfortable with the concept should try it.

The pictures clearly show the operation results with a Freud dado set in Hard Maple and there is no discernible difference in the noise of cutting or ease of feeding the stock by hand then any other ripping or grooving operation with a dado set.

One last comment about this particular Freud dado set claiming chip free crosscutting in Veneered stock.... Total BS.

FredD


http://picasaweb.google.com/lh/photo/3HpZVl5KK3RbzyPSgCsv_Q?authkey=XiZllmFd7IA&feat=directlink

Re: Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

#13

CYA answers are rarely adequate

Tom Dunlap

>I make my living working and teaching as an arborist, one of the most dangerous professions [something that I try to change in every class]. If the owner's manual for any chainsaw is read you'll find that the manufacturers state that chainsaws should never be used above the cutter's head or off the ground...yeah, right :) That makes using chainsaws in a professional manner kind of indefensible in the case of an injury. A better admonition is to not advise a practice and give reasons for not using the practice. Or...get proper instructions.

The chance of me ever using this dado setup is negligible. Even so, I like to know the 'why' of safe practices.

Thanks for the insights!

Re: Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

#14

chainsaw safety and why

John K Jordan

>>A better admonition is to not advise a practice and give reasons for

>not using the practice. ...I like to know the 'why' of safe practices.

That is very well said.

This is my biggest gripe with owner's manuals for many things, tools, electronics, tractors, etc. They say "do this, don't do that" but seldom explain why. Besides the liability issues, they assume all customers lack minds.

When my boys were little I didn't just tell them to stay out of the street. I told them what would happen if they ran into the street - "a car could come very fast and run over you and crush your skull and squish your brains out onto the road and your blood would run down the gutter and the crows would come and peck at your eyeballs and everybody would cry as we put your coffin in a hole in the ground and covered it up with dirt..." (I introduced them to my radial arm saw the same way.) Never saw them in the street.

BTW, my favorite book concerning chainsaw use is "The Good Woodcutter's Guide" by Dave Johnson. Dave is good with the 'why' and added considerably to my expanding list of ways to be maimed and killed. If you can't imagine a hazard, you can't possibly protect against it.

JKJ

Re: Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

#15

Re: CYA answers are rarely adequate

Thomas S Stockton

>Tom

I agree with you, but sometimes a light goes off in my head and says this really isn't a smart thing to do. I can't tell you exactly why it is unsafe but it just seems like it isn't a good idea to use a dado like this. I saw a guy at work stick his thumb in a dado and it was pretty chewed up not a clean cut at all, since then I only used dado blades if nothing else would work and my current saw won't take one at all.

Tom

Re: Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

#16

death by tree

John K Jordan

>Our newspaper this weekend showed picture of an oak tree that fell through the cab of a truck. The driver was at the wheel. The paper didn't explain what went wrong other than to say several men were trying to guide the fall of the tree with a rope tied to the truck. Maybe they needed a longer rope.

JKJ

Re: Usie dado set with just one outside blade?

#17

Thanks all

Ken Platt (granby, CT)

>Well, given the amount of discussion, I guess I wasn't being such a moron, at least not with this question.

I ended up not trying because the groove was going to be in a fairly narrow and thin workpiece, so if something went awry I didn't have a good safety margin since my grip was somewhat close to the blade. I'd have been more willing to try on a wider workpiece.

Good thread. Thanks to all.

Ken