Re: Solid wood panel construction
Sgian Dubh
> "I take exception to the requirement to "spring" the joint"
Hi Clint, no offense taken here, but I'm guessing you probably meant that you 'disagree' with the 'requirement' to create a spung joint. I didn't say it was a requirement; I did say that most workers "aim for a �sprung� joint".
I then went on to discuss some of the reasons why the sprung joint has advantages over other forms of the joint, eg, joining two convex edges, and some discussion of moisture uptake and loss at the end of a panel, and how the sprung joint has some advantages over non-sprung joints here.
My experience is somewhat different to yours. Over the last thirty five years or so in many busy industrial workshops, and similar, I have seen lots of edge joints executed in dry wood using a variety of glues that have opened up, many within weeks or months after the joint was executed. It is my experience after observing these failures, in probably three or four hundred cases, that the plain edge joints most likely to fail are those that were not sprung. There may be other reasons that caused the failure, eg, insufficient cramping pressure, or too little time in the cramps, or poorly prepared joints etc, but those failures happened. Slainte.