Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Solid wood panel construction *LINK*

Posts

Solid wood panel construction *LINK*

#1

Solid wood panel construction *LINK*

Sgian Dubh

>Some visitors to the forum may find my discussion on solid wood panel construction useful or helpful in their work. Here is a link to it.

What you will find is an edited and truncated version of a larger illustrated text I have created that is intended for print publication at some point in the future. Slainte.


Solid wood panel construction

Re: Solid wood panel construction *LINK*

#2

A comprehensive disucssion of the topic

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I found the balanced discussion more comprehensive than what is covered in most woodworking books. I have never seen the important topic of chatoyance discussed in relation to panel assembly, though the lesson presents itself, for better or worse, the first time a book matched panel is made!

Re: Solid wood panel construction *LINK*

#3

Re: Solid wood panel construction

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>It's a well written and presented discussion, and no offense intended, but I take exception to the requirement to "spring" the joint. The technique may not be harmful, but I believe, based on personal experience, that it's unnecessary. The tendency for a joint to open would only occur if the panel were laid up with wood that was too wet that then dried out and shrunk. Maybe that was a problem with poorly air dried wood that was made into furniture taken into warm dry conditions, but not today. With properly dried wood and modern glues, like PVA, the likelihood of joint ends opening is nil. Differential wood movement due to transient changes in relative humidity is further inhibited by any finish. I doubt that commercial factories spring joints.

Regardless of joint length, I look for a continuous tight dry fit, aligned with biscuits, clamped up with only moderate pressure. I try to run a narrow bead of glue on one edge that hardly, if at all, squeezes out, letting the clamping pressure do the glue spreading. Maybe I've just been lucky, but I've never had a joint fail.

Clint

Re: Solid wood panel construction *LINK*

#4

Re: Solid wood panel construction

Sgian Dubh

> "I take exception to the requirement to "spring" the joint"

Hi Clint, no offense taken here, but I'm guessing you probably meant that you 'disagree' with the 'requirement' to create a spung joint. I didn't say it was a requirement; I did say that most workers "aim for a �sprung� joint".

I then went on to discuss some of the reasons why the sprung joint has advantages over other forms of the joint, eg, joining two convex edges, and some discussion of moisture uptake and loss at the end of a panel, and how the sprung joint has some advantages over non-sprung joints here.

My experience is somewhat different to yours. Over the last thirty five years or so in many busy industrial workshops, and similar, I have seen lots of edge joints executed in dry wood using a variety of glues that have opened up, many within weeks or months after the joint was executed. It is my experience after observing these failures, in probably three or four hundred cases, that the plain edge joints most likely to fail are those that were not sprung. There may be other reasons that caused the failure, eg, insufficient cramping pressure, or too little time in the cramps, or poorly prepared joints etc, but those failures happened. Slainte.

Re: Solid wood panel construction *LINK*

#5

furniture factory practice.....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I too question the utility of a sprung joint that provides so little tension the joint can be closed by hand pressure(if I understood correctly). I haven't seen sprung joints practiced in local cabinet shops or furniture factories. They aim for a perfect straight joint. And they make millions of such joints that seem to last in a wide variety of US conditions. They use wood dried to US standards of 7 % so perhaps this difference is significant.

If the observation is that the joint is opening up then there has been an adhesive failure as the adhesive should make a joint stronger than the wood. The split should not always be located at the glue line if moisture loss from the panel end is the only issue. I more suspect the sprung joint compensates for improper clamp pressure leading to a poor bond at the ends of the panel joints. Many amateur woodworkers would be in awe at the pressure applied to clamps in a furniture factory.

Re: Solid wood panel construction *LINK*

#6

Re: furniture factory practice.....

Sgian Dubh

>Okay Bill, and Clint. I decided to import a bit more text from my original manuscript that might satisfy your points. I don't want to bring any more text and images into this web page as I believe it is large enough now.

There are probably about another 2000 or 3000 words on related topics I might have included, along with additional images. But I think I'll hang on to discussions of joint failure due to tensile and compressive stress on panel joint lines, and long term moisture cycling as a possible cause of cupping in panels for the print version, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Solid wood panel construction *LINK*

#7

I didn't mean to be picky.....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>One of my concerns is that woodworking can be made to sound so complicated that novices are afraid to try it. Panel assembly can fall into this category. It doesn't take much instruction to teach assembly of a panel that will last. It takes considerably more instruction to assemble a panel that looks its best and your instructions were exceptional on this topic. I was most pleased you didn't advocate ripping wide boards or orienting growth rings to promote the insignificant benefit of "panel stability" while sacrificing panel appearance.

Sprung joints are certainly nice if you are skilled enough, and have the time to make them. But at the risk of scaring off beginners from panel construction sprung joints should not be considered an essential ingredient for robust panels.

Re: Solid wood panel construction *LINK*

#8

Re: I didn't mean to be picky.....

Sgian Dubh

>Bill, your comments encouraged me to make fairly small refinements to the web page I created by importing more text from my original manuscript.

Whilst I agree that it perfectly possible to make satisfactory edge joints without using a sprung joint, I take learners straight into executing them at their first attempt at creating wider panels, and give them the reasons why it is done. In my experience the only learners that don't eventually master the technique nor really understand why it is done are those that aren't hungry enough.

You will have noticed that my text does not say that it is imperative that all edge joinery must be done with a sprung joint. I think, from memory, it says something like "most workers aim for a sprung joint". Slainte.