Hard question to answer. What's the
Forrest Addy
>Hard question to answer. What's the size of the joined members? How much strees and strain does the joint have to withstand? "The best" of anything depends on many factors.
According to Roy Underhill, he reccommends tenon thickness to be no less than a third and no more than half of the stock thickness. Sounds like a workable rule of thumb to me.
How are these chisels you're considering proportioned? I've cut a few mortices with home made chisels comprized of pre-ground Starrett stock, hardened and sharpened but left a near perfect rectangular section excepr for the edge bevel. I found most of them less than perfect. While they held a good edge they were hard to work with and most difficult to extract as the mortice got deeper. The parallel side bound in the mortice. They needed a certain amount of taper going slightly smaller from the cutting edge in both directions.
I suggest heavy morticing chisels be made with at least 0.008" back taper in a 6" length and 0.005" from the cutting edge to the top of the chisel. These are only suggestions. If the morticing chisels you're looking at have this taper, chance are they will be fine regardless of size.
However, we still need a bit more info. the 1/4" chisel will be suited for 5/8" thick stock (a bit more or less) and the 3/8" for 7/8" stock (a bit more or less). If I had my druthers, I'd prefer a 5/16" mortice chisel to make mortices to accept tenons from the all too common 3/4" thick finsihed size stock.
Anyway look at the thickness of the stock that you will cut the tenons on. Make your selection from that cranking in Roy Underhills rule. k