workbench top
mel_llama
>I was wondering if anyone has used padauk for a workbench top. I want to do use it, but I am unsure of any long term problems that may arise.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
workbench top
mel_llama
>I was wondering if anyone has used padauk for a workbench top. I want to do use it, but I am unsure of any long term problems that may arise.
Re: workbench top
Fred Davis
>The dust from sanding Paduk is a known irritant, aside from that I think just for myself , that using a beautiful wood like Paduk for a workbench top is kinda like making railroad ties from it .
FredD
Re: workbench top
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>Having done only one project with paduak, only involving ripping a couple boards, I'll never work with it again. The sawing created enoush fine red dust to blanket Mars and get up my nose. Also it changes to an inky purple-red over time.
Clint
Sounds beautiful and impractical
Chris Knob
>...for all the reasons mentioned.
I've built several workbenches over the years. There's nothing like a laminated maple top but I will tell you, my current bench top made of laminated spruce 2x4s of all things, is the best top I've ever used. It's heavy and I don't give a crap what I do to it. It's fill of stains, dings, paint, etc and some day, I'll take 15 minutes and hand plane it down to a fresh surface.
Ellis, with his new plane, is not that fast!
Art Silva
>
Nope, not with a block plane, Art :-)
Ellis Walentine
>
Re: workbench top
Michael O'Docharty
>Actually I am just completing construction of my workbench which measures 93" long by 36" wide with a top made of padouk and banded by purpleheart. I got a good deal on 200 board ft. of 8/4 padauk ($1 per ft.) some time back and it sat in storage for several years until I had a use for some of it. The top is a full 5 1/2" thick. I laminated 3 1/2" of Southern Yellow Pine first and decided after completing that lamination process that it was just to soft to act as a workbench. Following that I laid on the 8/4 planks of padauk. Faced the whole thing and created 4" endcaps of purpleheart. The base is made of SYP faced in purpleheart. I estimate weight of the workbench at around 700 lbs. It is strong as they come now; you could probably park a locomotive on it without any problem. Drilling the dogholes was an exercise in patience and I burned out a drill in the process. I would agree with the previous posters about the problems with sanding dust. In anticipation of this I rolled my bench outside on a windy day to do the sanding and wore a full respirator. Blew it off with compressed air before returning it to the shop and avoided all the problems of turning the shop orange. It is visually stunning, however I am considering using a sacrificial layer of hardboard attached by a little hotglue for day to day use.
Thanks,
Michael O'Docharty
Raleigh, NC
Would love a picture!
Jim Dillon
>
Ditto...need pics!!!
Ralph Turney in Huntington Beach
>
the sacrificial top
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>I have used a piece of 1/8 light colored hard Masonite like stuff on my bench and except for one problem it worked out well. I attached it with a few tiny brads so it could be replaced as needed....turns out about every 5 years.
It seems to be a moisture barrier and when my shop got very dry in the winter the top bowed from moisture loss on the bottom more than the top. I did not have this problem when I used uncoated Masonite.
Re: the sacrificial top
Virgil J
>I used 8/4 white oak for the sacrificial top on the work bench I made nearly twenty years ago .It has held up really well.:-)
Re: the sacrificial top
Chris Knob
>I don't get it. Why would you make a bench out of exotic beautiful wood and then be forced to cover it up to avoid damaging it? Benches should be practical.
Amen
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>
Re: Amen and an Idea
Brian in Brighton
>I would make a sacrificial top and only put in on to do any finishing or gluing. That way you could keep a good top in good shape. Use it to do everything else, plane, cut, assemble. When you go to finish you can either use a masonite top or butcher paper to cover up the top to keep it from getting stained or covered in glue.
Best of both worlds.
Brian in Brighton
Re: Amen and an Idea
Fred Davis
>The Butcher paper works well as a temporary cover , I use a 42" wide roll of 20 LB. to catch glue drips and stain and the roll has lasted about 8 years. I need another one soon.
FredD
Re: workbench top
bill crommett
>I have usd a piece of white surfaced tileboard, but I am having trouble finding a replacement.Eight years have taken its toll.
In defense of the sacrificial top
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>There are a number of reasons why I found a top covering beneficial. To list a few:
1. My bench serves my woodworking hobby and the farm. So the oily chainsaw gets sharpened on it, stuff gets stained and painted on it, stuff gets glued on it, as well as a woodworking bench's traditional uses.
2. I'm sloppy. So I am prone to spilling/leaking oil and paint, glue and stain, and normally the bench is cluttered with stuff left over from what has been done and what is going to be done. This fact makes addition of something sacrificial necessary and the clutter makes adding and removing as needed inconvenient (I tried that approach)
3. A light colored bench top improved illumination at the work surface from 150 ft cd. to 200 ft cd, a substantial improvement in my quest to be able to see scribe lines on walnut.
Addition of an off-white coated piece of Masonite provided a sacrificial, easy to wipe, durable surface that suited my needs, except for the moisture problem.
that may be what I am using
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>I found it on a bottom shelf in that section of stuff at Lowe's.
1/2" Homosote board. Cheap & rugged
Art Silva
>
Re: workbench top
Michael O'Docharty
>Some folks may wonder why make the effort to create a beautiful but impractical top on a workbench, which can be expected to receive a considerable beating over a lifetime of use.
I would respond to that by saying why put fine upholstery on a living room sofa which will bear the abuse of people sitting on it while watching TV, eating on it, sleeping on it, and couples having romantic interludes. Kids use it as gym equipment, dogs use it as a chew toy and cats as a scratching post? Would it not be more practical just cover it in vinyl?
Go to a NASCAR race and notice the over-the-top paint schemes. Why not just shoot the cars in gray primer since the vast majority will be all banged up in short order anyway?
Bottom line is we make that fancy workbench for the sake of art. Woodworkers are all about the expression of beauty whether it be a finely crafted dovetail or joining two planks with a near invisible glue line. That desire to create beauty carries over into the tools we make as well.
Michael O'Docharty
Raleigh, NC
Construction of the workbench is complete however I have not yet begun the finishing process. I will try to post a picture or two next week.
Re: workbench top
Chris Knob
>I wouldn't challenge any woodworker who wants to make a statement by creating a beautiful workbench...all I was saying was I would be restricted in what I would use my bench for if I worried about keeping it pristine. As for the furniture analogy...a sofa is not a working tool. I wouldn't paint a backhoe in beautiful metalic blue and clearcoat.
For those of you who want to display the beauty of wood in a bench, go ahead. I for one could never slather stain on a chair sitting on a tiger maple bench.
Re: workbench top
Stuart Hough
>Not wanting (necessarily) to sound like a throwback to the 60's....if it akes you feel good...do it, man!