Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

blade deflection on a 10" versus 12" miter saw?

Posts

blade deflection on a 10" versus 12" miter saw?

#1

blade deflection on a 10" versus 12" miter saw?

Scott in Montana

>I am currently looking to upgrade my shop miter saw and was considering stepping up to a 12" blade capacity. A woodworking friend of mine pointed out that I may experience significantly more deflection on the larger blade. I have seldom noticed any deflection on my current Milwaukee 10" compound miter saw, but I always take my time when cutting.

Anyhow, I am considering one of the new Milwaukee miter saws but not if I won't get a quality cut. I would consider saving a bit longer and getting the Festool Kapex if the larger arbor yields less deflection.

Any and all input would be greatly appreciated. I may be overlooking the obvious, but at these prices I can't afford to make a mistake. Big bucks for a saw... let alone the price of a new quality 12" blade.

Thanks and happy holidays,

Scott in Montana

Re: blade deflection on a 10" versus 12" miter saw?

#2

Re: blade deflection on a 10" versus 12" miter saw

Stuart Hough

>Scott, you can control deflection by always keeping the workpiece immobile during the cut (i.e. using the supplied hold-downs or clamps) and by using good technique. This means allowing the blade to reach full speed before plunging, and feeding slowly enough to cut cleanly, but not so slowly that you burn the wood at the kerf. JMHO.

Re: blade deflection on a 10" versus 12" miter saw?

#3

Re: blade deflection on a 10" versus 12" miter saw

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I think "blade deflection" is meaningless. How does it manifest itself? I have a 10" Makita SCMS and a 12" Hitachi SCMS, neither of which exhibits anything out of sorts.

I notice on heavy or wide stock or where there's a short cutoff that a full through ploughing cut tends to bind the trailing edge of the blade. I overcome that tendency by running the plough cut about three-quarters through the thickness of the piece and finishing with a full width climbing cut. No bind, no burn.

Clint

Re: blade deflection on a 10" versus 12" miter saw?

#4

my experience...bad then good

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I got a LOT of deflection on the "piece of crap" 12" blade that came on my early DeWalt saw, so much so that it had a significant incident while cutting a 4 x 4. After completing the warranty repairs I installed a quality Freud 12" blade and never saw any evidence of deflection again.

Re: blade deflection on a 10" versus 12" miter saw?

#5

Re: my experience...bad then good

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Bill, how did the deflection show up? Burning? Rough cut?

Clint

Re: blade deflection on a 10" versus 12" miter saw?

#6

Oh no, way worse!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I bought the DeWalt 12" when it first came out. It had an exceptionally thin blade on it (no idea what is on them now). I could feel the blade quiver on a cut through 1" oak and of course the cut was rough. One day I tried to cut a 4 x 4. The blade flexed so bad it hit the guard. Tore the guard up and removed several teeth from the blade. When I called Tech service for DeWalt (a bright spot in customer service) I got somebody who allowed that there was some discussion within DeWalt as to whether the thin blade supplied would be suitable. In any case, I was sent a new blade (thin as the first) and repair parts for the guard.

I have had no problem with the thicker Freud blade. It cuts smoothly. I see a lot of 12" DeWalts on job sites (with after market blades) so one can presume they work as intended for trim work.

Re: blade deflection on a 10" versus 12" miter saw?

#7

Thanks all for the valued input!

Scott in Montana

>