Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Wood expansion in blanket chest

Posts

Wood expansion in blanket chest

#1

Wood expansion in blanket chest

Stephen

>I purchased a blanket chest kit off of the internet. It measures about 40 by 19 by 19, and is made of cherry on all sides except the bottom. The bottom is made of cedar. Looking through some websites, it looks as if different types of wood expand differently, and I am worried that this will lead to a problem in my chest.

Is this worry unfounded? If not, would a plywood panel in the bottom solve the issue? Thanks for any advice.

Re: Wood expansion in blanket chest

#2

Re: Wood expansion in blanket chest

doug f, san clemente, ca

>If it's a worry for you, make the bottom out of a good plywood, i.e. Baltic Birch, and line it with cedar planks. That will just about eliminated the guesswork.

Have fun with your project.

Doug

Re: Wood expansion in blanket chest

#3

Re: Wood expansion in blanket chest

Frank Mutchler

>Stephen, the builder should have allowed for expansion of the wood when he/she built the chest. If so, no problem. If not, there isn't much you can do about it now.....just wait & see.

If it's frame & panel the panels should be loose enough for you to mover them within their frames. It just depends on how it's constructed and if space was left for the wood to expand.

Re: Wood expansion in blanket chest

#4

Re: Wood expansion in blanket chest

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Stephen,

I'd certainly use plywood as the bottom, and line it with cedar slats applied with pin nails. The ply is stable and can be dadoed into the front, back and sides without worry. Mine is now several years old and no problems at all with that method.

George

Re: Wood expansion in blanket chest

#5

Re: Wood expansion in blanket chest

Jim Dillon

>Stephen,

Is there anyway you can dry assemble the kit and see if there is a small gap between the bottom and the inside edge of the rabbit, dado, whatever. If so, then the manufacturer probably allowed for expansion. Or, measure the width of the bottom, then measure the inside width of the dry assembled four sides to see if there is a small size difference. That would also indicate to me that the manufacturer allowed for expansion. If there is no difference, then I would be worried and follow the advice of others. You could also just trim off a slight bit of the bottom width to allow for expansion. Hope this helps and have a good holiday!

Jim

Re: Wood expansion in blanket chest

#6

Re: Wood expansion in blanket chest

John McGaw

>You say you purchased a "kit". Is this some sort of pre-cut set of parts or is it just a box of raw wood and some instructions? You also don't say how the assembly is done. Is it frame and panel or is it something like an old-style five-board chest? And most importantly, how is the bottom attached to the body of the chest? If it was designed properly then the differential wood expansion will mean nothing at all but if it is done badly it could be an invitation to disaster.

I've made several blanket boxes/chests and all have had cedar bottoms, at least in the main compartment, and none have had wood movement problems. That is because I allowed for substantial movement with seasonal changes.

Re: Wood expansion in blanket chest

#7

Additional details regarding chest

Stephen

>Many thanks to all for their comments. John asked for some details on the chest construction, and I wonder if these will alter anyone's thoughts. The front, back, and sides of the chest are dovetailed. According to the kit instructions, this rectangle is designed to be placed on top of the cedar bottom, and nailed in place - I think that's called a butt joint, but I'm not certain. Is this a doomed design?

It's easy enough to cut a dado in the panels to fit a plywood bottom, which seems more structurally sound than the kit plan.

Re: Wood expansion in blanket chest

#8

Re: Additional details regarding chest

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Stephen,

As you have outlined the dove tail joinery, it seems to me that the cherry front, back and sides would sit atop the cedar bottom which is attached by a nailed butt joint. If so, you would see the cedar end grain beneath the face grain of the cherry. I'd much rather use the plywood bottom dadoed into the front, back and sides. I would not want to see the end grain of the cedar. Are you planning to use legs?

George

Re: Wood expansion in blanket chest

#9

Re: Additional details regarding chest

Jim Dillon

>Stephen,

First, thanks to all of you for not embarrassing me once again for my misuse of "rabbit" vs "rabbet" in my earlier post. I really do know the difference between a woodworking rabbet and the furry, warm kind. Really, I do! I just have some sort of mental defect that kicks in when I type that word. I wish that was the only defect I have 8-).

Anyway, I agree with George. In addition to looking ugly, nailing the bottom directly to the bottom of the box in the manner the company suggests is asking for trouble. If you have the tools, setting the bottom in either a rabbEt, or dado with a bit of room for expansion would be the way to go. Another way is to fasten a ledger strip around the inside of the box bottom, place the bottom on the ledger and then fasten the bottom in place with decorative molding or something. Again allow room for expansion. Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: Wood expansion in blanket chest

#10

It's a kit

Howard Acheson

>