Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Manual arts in high schools

Posts

Manual arts in high schools

#1

Manual arts in high schools

Fred Davis

>I was pleased no end to read this week the State of Kansas has stopped funding high school work in what used to be the woodshop/metal shop / ag shop /welding /cabinet making and had replaced it with "circuit board design and flight simulators".

They are now insisting that the old tried and true Industrial Arts programs be re instituted.

I never thought I would see that day again and was glad that the local high school in Abilene and Chapman had kept most of the Industrial Arts , tho they down graded them .

Abilene still kept the house building /carpentry program.

Once again I see a light at the end of tunnel in education Industrial Arts wise.

I wonder why it took so long for them to recognize how dumb it was to have discontinued them in the first place?

FredD

Re: Manual arts in high schools

#2

Re: Manual arts in high schools

Barry Irby

>I am a little unclear on your post. Are you saying you are in favor of what we used to call "shop" class?

I am. I date a teacher and grew up in a house full of teachers. The system is lost in the PC world of dealing with all the problems the kids bring with them to school. It's hard to describe, but I am sometimes astounded at how she spends her day dealing with things that have little or nothing to do with educating the kids. They have a "counselor" because the parents can't or won't deal with mental health issues and don't have insurance that covers it. They have a policeman in the school at all times. (Not just this one, but all of them, I think) She is teaching in a program for Learning Disabled kids. Because they are LD, they are entitled to an education. They have disciplinary problems and get suspended from school. But they are entitled and so the school runs a program for them after school hours. They must have a Math teacher, English and so on until the have at least "one of each" discipline on the staff of the program. so now they have more teachers in the program than students. I think some kids act out to get into the program.

As a home inspector I constantly run into people that can't do anything and have no idea how their house works. I have had them ask me where the stuff goes when they flush. I said, into the sewer. Sewer? Yes, pipes buried in the streets. Where did they come from? What makes them go? They looked at me as if I were making it up.

So, on the one hand I think the system needs to get tough and teach reading', written and rithmetic, I also think they need to teach a class on "life". Every student should take it. How to write a check, what a lease looks like, what insurance to carry, how to make a cutting board or napkin holder, how to make an omelet or roast a chicken, what the engine in a car looks like, how to change a tire, and on and on. You know, all that stuff your mom and dad were supposed to teach you.

Re: Manual arts in high schools

#3

Chet Kloss

Are you trying to be sarcastic?

Chet Kloss

>

Re: Manual arts in high schools

#4

Re: Manual arts in high schools

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

>Barry, I started saying the very same thing about 35years ago.

College education is NOT for everyone, and the 'mechanical arts' still will be needed in tomorrows societies. A BA and MA will not have the knowledge of how to fix anything mechanical or electrical.

And another thing I have ongoing thoughts on.... those TV shows that show people being their own contractors and trying to do the work needed on their homes, not understanding how it should be done, etc, are just plain stupid. They still have to have inspections, and when the work does not come up to the societal standards and is rejected, then they whine and say 'woe is me'. Any building project should have a professional in charge...irregardless of the home-owners thoughts on savings and doing the work themselves. I watched an office worker spend about a year building his own house, had hos pregnant wife doing cleanup, etc, and getting rejected by the building inspector for his faulty shower inspection. That man was just not qualified to do anything of that nature and should not have attempted it in the beginning.

Re: Manual arts in high schools

#5

Re: Manual arts in high schools

Bill White

>My former machine shop instructor (Jr. college level) used to bemoan the fact that many prospective students were sent into "industrial arts" without the foggiest idea of the tech issues and math requirements required. Ever tried to get someone to comprehend the concept of tolerances in the .00005" range when they can't even read or at best, read a tape measure.

I hope to see a resurgence of "trade skill" classes.

Bill

Re: Manual arts in high schools

#6

Re: Manual arts in high schools

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtnc

>Who needs vocational schools when all the skilled manufacturing is done offshore and all the construction workers are named Jose and Miguel?

Clint

Re: Manual arts in high schools

#7

Historically,

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

>I find this very interesting. About 120 years ago these same arguments,not quite identical, were being made for the same reason. Manual training then had not the same meaning as today. Then it meant introducing manual (hand) training to complement eye and mind training. The industrial education movement, as exemplified by the National Society for the Promotion of Industrial Education, advocated broadening manual training to include what we today call shop class. And they succeeded. Why? Because there was a need for trained artisans. Unfortunately, during the 1920s and later training was taken over by the factories and shop classes became a place for non college bound youngsters. Education no longer meant a combination of book learning and skills. As one person, German I believe and I've forgotten his name, said, One trains a horse and educates a man. Unfortunate!!

Re: Manual arts in high schools

#8

Re: Manual arts in high schools

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>I'm All For It, Fred,

As a boy in the parochial school system in Philadelphia, shop courses were not in the curiculum. Kids like me were educated as colleger prep students. Those of us who were not as bright, were ill prepared to join the work force, and acquired essential skills with further manual trades education, or working their way up, or both. Each "group" seemed to have survived pretty well, based on my observations during my 50th High School reunion.. .

I'd love to have had at least an introduction to manual arts. It may have set a different life direction. Who knows? It seems to me that every kid deserves a balanced exposure. It also seems that educators ought to realize that manual arts and college prep courses are not mutually exclusive.

George

Re: Manual arts in high schools

#9

Dale Lenz

Re: Agree, Col. Balance is the key

Dale Lenz

>

Re: Manual arts in high schools

#10

Re: Manual arts in high schools

Fred Davis

>Yes Barry,

I am very much in favor of Industrial Arts.

I had a Major in that at Abilene High School when they had it in the curriculum and Eugene Carlile the shop teacher is the guy who started me on a long career in wood working.

I can't stress enough how much this backasswards approach to education in making a living with your hands and mind in concert has damaged our once proud leadership in the world in all things Mechanical.

You date a Teacher , I am married to a retired Art and Science teacher with a Eagel eye and a very talented Artist in her own right I might add.

So ,,,, do this clear up my unclear rant ??

FredD

Re: Manual arts in high schools

#11

Re: Manual arts in high schools

Fred Davis

>George,

on the subject of a balanced approach to a well rounded high school experience , I have noticed in about the last ten or fifteen years or so , that Girls have been permitted to take "shop".

That was away overdue and another insight to the lack of common sense "Educators" and school boards have suffered from.

I taught for several years a Furniture making and Refinishing course in the Adult Education night school program in Newark , California for six weeks each year.

The class of which there had to be at least fifteen in order to form one, was always composed of nearly all housewife types who had a desire to make something with their hands and never had a chance or instruction to show them how.

The look and delight of a Woman making a pair of night stand tables with a drawer with dovetail joints was priceless.

FredD

Re: Manual arts in high schools

#12

"Any building project should have..."

Bill Houghton, sun/cold in Sebastopol, CA

>"...a professional in charge..."

I agree that any large building project should have someone who knows what s/he's doing - but that person need not be a professional, just competent. There are plenty of people who don't know what they're doing; some of them are licensed contractors.

Some years back, my parents had a licensed plumber out to the house to do some repair on outside pipes. He or members of his crew:

1. cut into a live gas pipe and then ran around like headless chickens for a few minutes.

2. replaced galvanized pipe sections with copper, without a dielectric union between, outside in the weather.

3. did the worst soldering job on the copper pipe I've ever seen - it looked like it was covered with silver drool.

It cost about $800 to redo the work.

On the other hand, my dad, although slow, always exceeded building code in doubling the size of our house (in fact, one city inspector attempted to reject a job because it exceeded code - my parents won the argument).

And, yes, there are plenty of homeowners who think they know more than they do - but disparaging all weekend worriers because some are ignorant is like disparaging all police officers because some are corrupt. There are plenty of people, not all of them tradesworkers during the week, who have done high quality building.

I'll climb off my soapbox now.

Re: Manual arts in high schools

#13

Ranting a bit

Bill Houghton, sun/cold in Sebastopol, CA

>In the best of worlds, we'd rethink American education altogether. Joseph Mulherin, above, commented that college is not for everyone. I've heard people say that with an undertone of, "some people just aren't good enough for college" (I am NOT accusing Mr. Mulherin of saying that!). Our younger son, who reads more difficult works of literature than I am ever likely to, learns through his hands at a level that awes me, and found college classes boring. We need to recognize that there are myriad ways of learning and myriad things to know in the world.

Unfortunately, American culture as a whole has been oriented toward head learning, to the detriment of head-and-hands learning, for quite a while now - as a result of which, every tradesworker over the age of 50 comments that you can't find young people who know how to DO anything anymore.

In some ways, "manual" skills are more complex than "intellectual" skills, because you have to use both head and hands.

I'm pleased that both my sons learned how to use tools and solve physical problems growing up (and, had I had a daughter, I'd have been taking her into the shop as well).

Bill, college educated and worked as a human resources manager, but appreciates head-and-hands work too.

Re: Manual arts in high schools

#14

Re: Ranting a bit

Fred Davis

>Bill I agree with much of what you say , but......the comment of "Americans being oriented toward head learning" while it may true, is not the result.

While I lived in California , there was one failed experiment with new ideas after another .

I am sure you must have heard of "Social Promotion" how about the "Eubonics course in the Oakland schools being touted as the "new approach for black kids use of the language"?

Wnen I my Daughter was in Middle school in Brentwood , a school of about three hundred at the time , there was at least 250 on the honor roll every year, regardless whether they could understand what they read.

Jack England , the Principal, after a visit from me ,explained that though they did have "soft A's they didn't discuss them them in public.

After all he said , it wasn't realistic to expect every child to meet the same traditional standards I was used to , so rather then spend some extra time with the "slow ones" , they lowered the grade standards.

This Bill , was a direct result of "oriented to head learning" and it drives employers nuts trying to fill entry level jobs with the product turned out by our forward looking school boards and Administators.

Should every kid have a opportunity to advance to college level,ask any college head coach , damn right , if they can pass the running and catching test.

FredD

Re: Manual arts in high schools

#15

Re: Ranting a bit

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

>Bill, I can understand what you said, and in some cases I agree. But, the school mentoring systems have seemed to me to have turned away from the primary thing about education....how to make a living in today's society. I have advocated that seniors spend the last six weeks of high school receiving a total education on how to use a checking account, credit cards, mortgages, licenses, how to fill out applications, any myriad selection of topics to just know how to survive in society. Just studying education subjects for the mind developing and thinking that supposed college gives you is OK for some, but these people still do not have the knowledge of how to do manual arts, and rebuilding ones home and doing repairs without the proper knowledge is stupid and a competent person should be involved to make decisions before the project starts.

In my own case, I went to college, received an AA in busmgmt/acctng,

passed two computer programming courses, worked real estate mortgages for 4yrs, and spent 34yrs in const. because I chose to for the fulfillment it gave me on building something...as well as the higher salary. And my IQ was once rated at 168(not bragging, just stating the results of a test rating).

Re: Manual arts in high schools

#16

Re: Ranting a bit

Alexander Grigoriev

>And some people are surprised SA has to import skilled engineers...