Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Second best species for toys?

Posts

Second best species for toys?

#1

Second best species for toys?

Wayland

>I know hard maple is the universally accepted best species for toys, and for good reason. But I want to whip up some toys for xmas and I don't have any maple. What I do have is red oak, sycamore, ash, and pine. Any thoughts on which, if any, of those would work?

And I have to admit, this would be for small children who could not be trusted not to put things in their mouths.

Thanks

Wayland

Re: Second best species for toys?

#2

Re: Second best species for toys?

Barry Irby

>Any of them are OK, but I think I would choose Sycamore out of that group. It's in the maple family and is tight grained. Might tend to pick up less crud in the grain. (Crud being a technical term for the stuff that gets on kids toys.)

Re: Second best species for toys?

#3

what is the concern?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I don't see that there is any additional consideration of what to use just because it is a toy. The woods you listed look different and some are harder than others, but all that is obvious. Use the harder woods where durability is important and choose by appearance for all else.

Re: Second best species for toys?

#4

Re: what is the concern?

Chris Friesen

>The concern is for safety. Some woods can cause allergic reactions, others taste bad.

To the original poster, I'd probably go with the sycamore. Pine can be sappy and is fairly soft. Red oak has big pores and can be a bit splintery, although may be okay if sanded well. Ash would probably be okay, but has a more distinctly "layered" grain then the sycamore, and can "flake" when damaged (think old baseball bats).

Re: Second best species for toys?

#5

Re: what is the concern?

Wayland

>Well, my concern was, mainly, splintering, I suppose. It seems that if a kid chews on oak or ash, a few little splinters might flake off, as the saliva lifted the grain. Maple is supposed not to do that and is used for cutting boards and salad bowls. Actually, I think I've decided to go with birch, which I had but neglected to put on my original list. It's not as waterproof as maple, but it has a tight grain.

As far as appearance is concerned, it's secondary. Any toy that gets used gets dirty and scratched up pretty quickly.

Thanks for your help.

Wayland