Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Staining poplar ?

Posts

Staining poplar ?

#1

Staining poplar ?

John_in_Az

>Hi All - My daughter-in-law has asked me to turn some bed legs for them. At this point I don't know what wood the bed is made of or if it has been stained. My question is, if I turn these out of glued up poplar will there be any problem staining the poplar to match the bed? My choice of poplar is one of expediency as I have a ton of it to get rid of and use up. Thanks, John

Re: Staining poplar ?

#2

Re: Staining poplar ?

mike@American Sycamore

>In my humble opinion....poplar is a paint grade lumber and should be painted or if for some reason one likes green purple brown streaks then ok stain it. Actual when you do want poplar to look like something it is not you are actually painting the wood with sheavy stain. Do not want to start a war but poplar is a secondary wood.

Re: Staining poplar ?

#3

Re: Staining poplar ?

Howard in Bethesda

>I�ve had very good luck staining poplar with artist�s oil pain dissolved in BLO. Mixing a couple of paint colors you should be able to get a good color match. Apply the BLO paint mix the same way you would finish with plain BLO.

Howard

Re: Staining poplar ?

#4

poplar or poplar

John K Jordan

>The name poplar means different things to different people in different parts of the country. To avoid confusing reports and opinions it would be best to be more specific. Do you mean Populus: Popple/aspen/cottenwood, or Liriodendron tulipfera: yellow poplar/tulip poplar?

I remember one very confusing thread on a sawmill forum that only made sense when people finally realized they were arguing about two entirely different woods that shared nothing but the name.

A FWW article on y.poplar mentions that perhaps due to the name confusion it is often misunderstood and undervalued. It is easily stained to look like other woods, especially cherry.

I like working with y.poplar and cut it often on my sawmill - it air dries quickly, warps very little, planes cleanly, turns cleanly, sands smooth, and finishes nicely. The only problem I've had is when I made some beehive boxes. It (the heartwood, at least) is considerably harder and more dense than the white pine usually used in beehives and the boxes were too heavy for comfort. Of course, remember that individual trees vary.

From my reading I understand the true poplars are nothing like tulip poplar but I haven't tried turning any.

JKJ

Re: Staining poplar ?

#5

Re: OT -- Outlook Express Problem

Wayne Carson

>I have made 5 quilt racks out of Poplar and stained them to look like Walnut. I found out to do it from "Charles Neil" he has a web site called "Antiques build daily" I used an Amber dye and followed with a Red Mahogony Gel Oil Stain and it really looks like Walnut.

Wayne

Re: Staining poplar ?

#6

JL

Re: Staining poplar ?

JL

>I've had reasonable luck staining poplar - after I've sanded it well and used a gel stain.

I personally wouldn't use it as I believe it is too soft of a lumber for a leg or post. YMMV.

Re: Staining poplar ?

#7

Re: Staining poplar ?

mike@American Sycamore

>if you want it to look like walnut why not just use walnut? If you want it to look like cherry why not use cherry? Lumber is so cheap compared to our time! I love the way cherry ages to that beautiful luster...you can not get that with poplar.

Mike

Re: Staining poplar ?

#8

Re: Staining poplar ?

David Yoho

>John,

Although there's a point to be made about poplar being a secondary wood, or one that's not seen on the "show" surfaces, I see no reason for you not using it for your stated purpose. Actually, I can think of a positive for your choice of woods. Besides cost, a good reason to use poplar is that it can be "stained" to look like a variety of other woods. Since you're not sure what the wood is, you can always sneak up on it once you've determined the species.

Earlier I used the term "stained" but I didn't mean using stain alone. I've had amazing success making poplar look like cherry, mahogany, and walnut with a process I use. Whether your poplar has some of the different darker colors running through the light wood or it's fairly light colored throughout, you can even things out by starting with a dye. I like using Behlen's Solar Lux - Light Brown Mahogany. I wipe it on with a cloth and let it dry. The Behlens is a non-grain-raising dye, so sanding is kept to a minimum (if at all). This dye tends to hide or even out the differences in coloration often found in poplar.

I continue with Minwax stains - sometimes using only one color but I might also use several and blend them to get the look I need. Like I said, I can sneak up on the color I'm after this way and it works. I'm sure there are other ways to achieve what you're after. This is what I've done that works but remember - test your process on scrap before committing to the real thing.

David

Re: Staining poplar ?

#9

Re: Staining poplar ?

David Yoho

>Mike, I agree with what you said and would probably go that route myself. However, in John's case, poplar might not be such a bad choice for several reasons.

First, it sounds like John has plenty of poplar and wants to use something he already has.

Second, using what he already has on hand saves him time and money.

Third, I've seen many beds with feet or "legs" that are short enough that they're hardly noticed or possibly not visible at all, especially if there's a dust skirt around the bed. If these "legs" are the short type that go beneath the bed frame, why not use poplar?

David

Re: Staining poplar ?

#10

Re: Staining poplar ?

Jesse Cloud

>When I'm trying to match a color, I'll set a small piece of glass on the colored wood that I'm trying to match, then experiment with different dyes or stains until the match looks good. Being able to compare through the glass is a big help.

Re: Staining poplar ?

#11

Re: Staining poplar ?

jerrym

>While you can make poplar the color of several other woods ,the grain is another matter.

Regards

Jerry

Re: Staining poplar ?

#12

Thank you for responses

John_in_Az

>Thanks to each of you that took the time to respond. The conclusion I have reached is to go ahead with the poplar. This is more of a utility application than beauty, but I don't want it to look tacky or real cheapo. The legs will be more like extended buns or feet about 8" high and won't be highly visible normally. Complicating the issue will be the fact that these will be turned out of glued up 4/4 stock which will involve a lot of differences from face grain and side grain. With thought I think it's doable so thanks for each opinion. John

Re: Staining poplar ?

#13

I used

Joanne in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>Bartley's Gel Stain--Pennsylvania Cherry on some poplar and it turned out to look very much like cherry. The grain on the particular boards I had was very cherry-like. But I wasn't trying to match anything else, so I thought it looked nice. These days, as someone else said, I would just go ahead and use cherry.

Re: Staining poplar ?

#14

staining poplar

Wayne Carson

>sometimes the proper size of the correct lumber isn't available. Here in West Texas we are sometimes lucky to get the poplar big enough. Woodworkers in the Midwest and Eastern shores are lucky with the availability of material. And I learned a lot about staining and what might be possible.