Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Help removing pen "dents" from table top?

Posts

Help removing pen "dents" from table top?

#1

Help removing pen "dents" from table top?

Doug in Denver

>So I just completed a cherry dining room table. My brother was visting and wanted directions, so I grabbed a single sheet of paper and a BIC pen and drew a map. Of course now the map impression is in the table top. The top has no stain or dye, and has multiple coats of wipe on oil/poly mix - the General Finishes stuff Rockler sells.

The table has been finshed long enough - a month - that the top has started to turn darker. So if I sand out that section it will be forever lighter. I really don't want to start over on the whole top. Any tricks I can try? Steam would be great on bare wood, but I assume useless on finshed wood?? I had rubbed out the finish, so I can lightly sand and re-rub that spot, but I'm worried the dents, no matter how shallow, are deeper than the finish. Any suggestions?

Re: Help removing pen "dents" from table top?

#2

Re: Help removing pen "dents" from table top?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Doug,

I'd wet a soft cloth and pass a steam iron over the "map". It may help, and you have nothing to lose. You well may have to strip the top, sand and refinish. Its inconvenient, but you won't have to live with a light area.

George

Re: Help removing pen "dents" from table top?

#3

Try transparent filler?

Alex Grigoriev

>

Re: Help removing pen "dents" from table top?

#4

a sad tale indeed

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>This experience is why I advocate finishing "working tables" with a hard finish like the best urethanes. Properly applied and rubbed out they can be made to look like any less robust finish. If you can readily dent the cured finish with a fingernail it is too soft to use on a table.

Re: Help removing pen "dents" from table top?

#5

Re: Help removing pen "dents" from table top?

pecker

>Wait a year. It will have so many more dings and scratches that you'll hardly notice the "map" anymore.

Re: Help removing pen "dents" from table top?

#6

What are you referring to?

Doug in Denver

>What are the "best" urethanes?

Re: Help removing pen "dents" from table top?

#7

all urethanes are not created equal

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Of the products readily available to the home finisher, when I am looking for durability, I consider a urethane varnish as it will have the greatest likelihood of being hard . However, "urethane" just describes one part of one component of the stuff in the can. The rest of the components have a great influence on the properties of the finish.

Most sources of finish have test pieces in the store. I will test their hardness by seeing if I can dent the finish with my thumb nail. I always have been able to find some product that doesn't dent, meaning it will be hard when cured- good for a table top that will be used for a work or eating surface.

I have a urethane finished dining table that we have used for 30 years and it looks as good as the day it was rubbed out. One can avoid the "plastic look" by thinning the material such that the final film thickness approximates what one would get with lacquer or shellac. I doubt most woodworkers could tell that the dining table was urethane varnish and not shellac or lacquer.