Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Planer [thicknesser] question

Posts

Planer [thicknesser] question

#1

Planer [thicknesser] question

Alex Yeilding

>I am fed up with my poor lunchbox planer. I could get a better lunchbox planer, but have the opportunity, for a little more, to get a used Delta DC380 15" planer or a Jet JWP 16 OS.

Anyone have experiences, good or bad, with either of these? What do I need to look out for on the used Delta?

One thing that struck me as odd comparing these units was the two speeds. On the Delta, they were 30fpm and 16fpm, which seems to make sense for rough "hogging off" work versus near finish work. But the Jet's speeds were 16fpm and 20fpm, which seems too subtle a difference. What am I missing here?

Re: Planer [thicknesser] question

#2

I think I would say the

Dustmaker Mike

>number of knives. Does the Delta have more or less blades then the Jet? I have not experience with either of these units so I am of no real help.

Sorry Have a Great Day.

Re: Planer [thicknesser] question

#3

Re: I think I would say the

Fred Davis

>quality of the planer cut rests on the number of cuts per inch which is directly connected to the number of knives and speed (fpm) the material is fed .

Obviously given the same approx. feed speed three knives give you more cuts per inch, some cheaper machines will try to make up the deficiency of two knives by increasing the feed speed , which is not good .

Look for the most cuts per inch ,all else being equal that machine has the potential of the smoothest cuts .

I once had a Makita 2040 planer I used for finish cuts because it had about 70-80 knife +cuts per inch, but it only had two knives which meant in that case that while the cut was the smoothest I ever got from a planer , you could only take off 1/32" to 1/16" max with one pass.

FredD

Re: Planer [thicknesser] question

#4

They were bid out of my price range :-(

Alex Yeilding

>Just to clarify, my question was about the relationship of high-speed to low speed on each machine, not comparison of speeds between machines. The delta had almost a 2:1 speed range, while the Jet had a 1.25:1 speed range.

And Fred, you said "some cheaper machines will try to make up the deficiency of two knives by increasing the feed speed". I think you meant either "decreasing the feed speed" or "increasing the cutterhead speed", either of which would increase cuts per inch.

Re: Planer [thicknesser] question

#5

Re: They were bid out of my price range :-(

Fred Davis

>Yes , Alex ,

your right as always.

I have this new fangled keyboard that interprets my typing for me and I was thinking cutter head speed and it came out feed speed , so you can readily see how this is frustrating to no end

FredD