Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Miter gauges - which to "request"?

Posts

Miter gauges - which to "request"?

#1

JL

Miter gauges - which to "request"?

JL

>I've looked at the Osborne miter gauge.

http://www.woodcraft.com/product.aspx?ProductID=148941&FamilyID=20957

And the Incra 1000SE.

http://www.woodcraft.com/family.aspx?familyid=4385

I was impressed by the looks of the Osborne, but I haven't had a chance to use one. Incra is a known product - but I haven't used one of them either. Price wise, there is a $40-50 difference, depending on where you order one. As SWMBO is requesting a list, I figured I get opinions.

So, what do ya'll think? Which would you prefer and why? TIA.

Re: Miter gauges - which to "request"?

#2

Re: Miter gauges - which to "request"?

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Consider saving bo-coo dollars by making an adjustable sled that'll be just as accurate as the alternatives mentioned. If your projects entail repetitive same-angle cuts, a fixed angle jig is easy to set up.

Clint

Re: Miter gauges - which to "request"?

#3

Re: Miter gauges - which to "request"?

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>My vote is for the Osborne. I took it out of the box and cut a perfect octogon. t is very ridgid and stable. 3 years and the only adjustment was to fit the miter slot.

Re: Miter gauges - which to "request"?

#4

Re: Miter gauges - which to "request"?

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>I'd vote for the Incra, based solely on their superior slop-eliminating fit adjuster.

Re: Miter gauges - which to "request"?

#5

Re: Miter gauges - which to "request"?

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I've been very impressed with my Kreg miter gauge which has proved to be very accurate and repeatable. The flip down stop is very useful for repeat cuts, easily gets out of the way for different cut length without losing the original set up if it is still needed.

Lee


img

Re: Miter gauges - which to "request"?

#6

Re: Miter gauges - which to "request"?

Tony - Memphis

>I have an Incra (2000?). I've using it for several years. I have been real happy with it. I really appreciate the consitency and being able to switch from one angle to another and back without fussing. The initial adjustment is a little fussy. I don't like the stop that came with mine at all. I haven't researched, but I think they have a new and improved stop. I have thought about upgrading mine someday. I think they sell a new fence and stop for it. Anyway, I would buy another one. Very well made - nice and heavy.

Tony

Re: Miter gauges - which to "request"?

#7

Re: Miter gauges - which to "request"?

Chuck in ND

>Personally I don't get why people spend so much money on miter gauges. I do almost all my crosscuts on a miter saw unless the board is too wide to cut in a single cut, or it involves a angled dado cut. I think a miter saw is more accurate, easier to line the cut up on, and I have better control of the board. But thats just my opinion, everyone has their own beliefs I guess.

Re: Miter gauges - which to "request"?

#8

Re: Miter gauges - which to "request"? *LINK*

charlie belden

>What Veritas has done with hand planes - JoinTech has done with router tables and table saws - make improvements to existing Tried and True things - and added precision.

When mitering corners you need both precise angles cut AND precise, repeatable lengths. OK - so it's also important to firmly hold the stock in place. Cutting the right angle on ONE end of a part is easy. And even cutting that angle - on BOTH ends isn't enough - if the end result is a part that's too long - or too short.

Stops are good to have. Micro adjustable stops - which work on both "inside" and "outside" cuts is even better to have.

Look at the second and third photos on the attached page - and read the text - to see

and understand the SmartFence's valuable little features - the ones you'd overlook - initially.


JoinTech's Smart Miter

Re: Miter gauges - which to "request"?

#9

A few reasons

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>In my case there are a couple of reason why I don't use a miter saw. They are:

1. I don't own one and getting a good one would cost more than the $139 I paid for a good miter gauge.

2. My shop doesn't have room for another fixed location power tool needing workspace on either side.

3. I would still need the good miter gauge for the other cuts you listed.

Just my 2 cents worth.

Lee

Re: Miter gauges - which to "request"?

#10

Re: A few reasons NOT

Chuck in ND

>A miter saw isn't hardly what I would call a stationary tool. There are also a few more advantages to a miter saw that I forgot to list. You can buy crown stops, which makes cutting crown molding simpler, and the length of a miter gauge fence limits the length to which you can set the stop for repetitive cuts. I'll agree that I miter gauge does have it's uses, but for anyone to think that it replaces a good miter saw is I think fooling themselves. Go to a few highend jobsites and tell me how many professional trim carpenters are useing the table saw more than a miter saw for crosscuts, I'll bet none.

Re: Miter gauges - which to "request"?

#11

Re: A few reasons NOT

Fred Davis

>And you would be right.

wouldn't trade my 14" Makita mitre saw for anything else, for what I use it for.

Only way to fly cutting Crown mould.

FredD ( old Carpenter)

Re: Miter gauges - which to "request"?

#12

Get the Incra 3000SE, and never look back.

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>