Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

PC cordless tools

Posts

PC cordless tools

#1

PC cordless tools

David Lykins -Dallas GA - guitardude

>I'm in the market for a new cordless drill, but I've noticed that the combo' kits are pretty reasonalbe in price for the type of use I'll need. Does anyone have any experience with the PC 18 Volt tools. I'm interested in the kit pictured below.

Lowes list it as the following:

Porter Cable

4-Piece 18-Volt NiCad Cordless Combo Kit

Item #: 36099 Model: PC418C-2

Any input and suggestions are very welcome.

Thanks!


img

Re: PC cordless tools

#2

No more NiCAD for me

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I'm done with NiCAD batteries >:|

If it doesn't have Lithium, I'm not buying it.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: PC cordless tools

#3

No more cordless for me!

Tony - Memphis

>Tired of 'em. Just not worth the money or the hassle. I've got a Dewalt 18v ( I think) that is less than a year old and doesn't hold a charge worth a flip. The last one was a Ryobi and the replacement batteries or a rebuild was close to the price of a new drill. I hate to keep throwing things away. I'll stick with my trusty old DeWalt corded for $69 that will twist your arm off. Its many years old and keeps on ticking. I deal with batteries in my day job (we have at least 100K batteries out there), so I'm a but biased by that too!

Tony

Re: PC cordless tools

#4

different experience

John K Jordan

>For a different view, I get pretty good use out of the cordless. I've been using Dewalt 12v and 18v for many years. I did finally lose a couple of older 12v batteries and it was cheaper to buy a new drill on sale with two batteries and throw the drill away than it was to buy batteries. I am still using some batteries that are probably close to 15 years old.

The combo deals are usually far better than buying the single tools. The 18v Dewalt combo I bought has the circular saw, reciprocal saw, and drill (and stupid light). I get a huge amount of use from all of these around the farm (except the stupid light).

Since I use these tools a lot the batteries get cycled properly. Nicads and other nickel-based batteries do have a limited number of charge cycles, but they tend to die prematurely if 1) they are not drawn down before recharging, and 2) if they are drawn down TOO much.

I've seen people prop up a drill on it's trigger to drain every last joule out of a battery before recharging. They were told this would ward off the dreaded memory effect. This is a misunderstanding: draining a battery with nickel chemistry until it is dead dead is a bad thing and can damage the battery. The proper thing to do is to use it until you feel a loss of power then stop and put it on the charger. IMHO. Based on research.

JKJ

Re: PC cordless tools

#5

Me too

Larry Marker

>I've had good experience with Makita 9 and 14v drills. I finally had to buy a new 9v battery (which I rarely use) and I've had both 14v batteries rebuilt at a local Batteries Plus store.

The guy at the Batteries Plus store told me to NOT leave the battery sitting in the charger -- the Makita charger is not smart enough to shut off after the battery is charged and the small trickle charge will ultimately shorten the battery life.

Larry

Re: PC cordless tools

#6

Not the Porter Cable you may think

Mike Circ

>Be extremely cautious with the "new" Porter Cable stuff.

Since the purchase by Black-&-Decker/DeWalt, the PC line has been relegated to the low end name in their lineup.

That Porter-Cable kit you picture is really an old Black and Decker "home handiman" kit just dressed up in PC colors. If a low usage, low price, lower quality kit is all you need, then keep that in mind. But if you see the name "Porter Cable" and think that this is like the old durable, continous use stuff of past years, you will be disappointed. That kit is NOT the Porter Cable of old.

Sad to see another good name ruined.