Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Home Depot creating a health hazard

Posts

Home Depot creating a health hazard

#1

Home Depot creating a health hazard

Mqalcolm Timbers

>I have been researching the problem of fibromyalgia and I have found that it is caused by an exposure to silicone compounds that are found in many building products and cosmetic surgery products. Because women are the largest consumers of cosmetic surgery, the most incidences of fibromyalgia occurs in women.

Being highly sensitive to these silicone products mysely, but don't have fibromyalgia because my allergy to them makes me keep away from them, I have noticed that Home Depot is creating a serious health hazard with their marketing products that contain high levels of this hazardous silicone compound here in Canada. They don't seem to be selling these hazardous products in the USA, only to us naive Canadians.

The last time I visited the Home Depot in Langley, B.C., I wound up with a reaction to silicone in the air, which causes my eyes to become itchy almost immediately, folowed by joint and tendon pain several houre later. They have a huge pile of Roxul insulation which is treated with silicone to make it water repellant. I found this out after having purchased some Roxull insulation and got an allergic reaction as soon as I opened the package.

Only a small percent of the population is highly sensitive to these silicone compounds, but they represent a serious health hazard because they can cripple a genetically predisposed individual for life. These products are partly responsible for the so-calld sick building syndrome.

Malcolm

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#2

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

John K Jordan

>Yikes. I haven't heard of silicone sensitivity. What percentage of the population is affected?

I wonder if corporate would pay attention if a dozen people suddenly threatened their image by wearing full respirators while shopping. Especially if some pictures showed up on the news.

JKJ

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#3

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard *LINK*

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Malcolm - have you advised Health Canada and WorkSafe BC?

I'd suggest that would be your first (and primary) course of action and if nothing else, you'll learn whether or not these organisations agree with you on your presentation that silicone is a public health hazard.

Curious - with the insulation that you got a reaction from - you claim it contains silicone. Is this based on your reaction or is this based on an MSDS? I looked at the MSDS (link below) and didn't find mention of silicone in it. In fact Roxul contains two ingredients - mineral wool and a phenolic binder that contains trace amounts of Formaldehyde. In fact, OSHA lists the product as inert.

I don't doubt you suffered a reaction as you claim. But to 1) claim that Roxul is a health hazard and 2) that home Depot is creating a health hazard is a bit conclusive, particularly when two minutes of research on my part provided evidence that disputed your findings.

Rob


Roxul MSDS

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#4

JL

Possibly formaldehyde

JL

>It does contain an "urea extended phenolic formaldehyde binder". Many people have formaldehyde sensitivity. Formaldehyde is also one of the substances implicated in sick building syndrome. Witness all of the FEMA trailers also.

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#5

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>I get sick just looking at the quality of most the the junk they sell.

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#6

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

Bill Howatt

>I find the first paragraph a bit silly unless I see some supporting documentation other than internet folklore. Women are indeed most likely to suffer from fibromyalga but it has nothing to do with cosmetic surgery products.

Many in the medical profession are still reluctant to even consider it an illness but it certainly is very real to anyone who suffers from it.

My wife finds that 1000mg a day of vitamin D supplement seems to have helped hers immensely. She didn't take it for fibro but since she started it, the fibro is much better. Scientific, no, but...

Bill

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#7

oh please!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The alarming title is hardly supported by the unsupported opinions provided in the rest of the post. There are likely better Forums on which to fret about these things.

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#8

Re: oh please!

Charlie Self

>Let's include the simple fact that proably 90% of the top quality caulks in the U.S. contain silicone. There are other products, but those are in just about all houses in the country.

It's possible it does cause something like fibromylagia, but this is the first I've heard about, even as the illness becomes better publicized. Some supporting cites from the OP's "research" might help.

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#9

(snicker-snicker) . . .

steve mackay

>While I'm sworn of HD and would'nt care if they burned in the pits of Hades I'd think you would need to demonize EVERY home improvement and hardware store, contractor, builder and electrician there is over this issue. Lets drive some more pepole out of bussiness. At the moment silicon is a fact of life.

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#10

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

Fred Davis

>About the MSDS report.

1. if your looking for Silicone Allergic Reaction , none is listed.

2. If your looking for Allergic Reactions per se , several are mentioned in the toxicological report section and two sound like his reported red and itching eyes.

3. Mineral wool which is what the insulation is made of is listed on 1990 Clean air Act , Hazardous Air Pollutants list, so the MSDS says.

4. Who knows , certainly this forum doesn't .

FredD

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#11

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

Jim Dillon

>Malcom,

MSDS can be very misleading for what you are trying to pursue. Like many consumer used products that are topically used, consumed, or surgically implanted, government regulations/listing requirements usually have concentration limits BELOW which nothing needs to be listed or described - unless the chemical/ingredient is a known or suspected carcinogen. Such is the case with the MSDS. The MSDS regulation requires only that hazardous chemicals GREATER than 1% of the total product listed in the hazardous chemical section of the MSDS, unless the chemical is a carcinogen and is present GREATER than 0.1% of the product. While these reporting requirements generally serve us well, they are less useful for chemical induced sensitivities where the lower threshold can be much smaller, especially for inhalation over the long-term.

In listening to hundreds and hundreds of consumers testify before regulatory advisory panels, my conclusion is that folks can be divided into two groups: those that have had a problem that MIGHT be related to the product, and those that have never had a problem. Trying to weigh the benefit versus risk of the product thus becomes difficult despite reams of data on both sides of the issue.

I suggest you spend more time researching this issue and drawing your own conclusions. Although you are dealing primarily with an inhalation issue, in the US there are consumer-oriented groups that have followed some aspects of this issue (fibromyalgia), especially in the silicone breast implant area. And be aware that Canadian law may be different from US law. Broadly speaking, Canadian law is more consumer-oriented - at least that has been my experience. As you can see from the limited responses your post illicited, feelings run strong on this topic. Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#12

Re: oh please!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>There are a lot of women out there wearing silicone on their chests and I haven't heard of any studies about them having a higher rate of fibromyalgia.

Just a thought?

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#13

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

john lucas

>We have fibromyalgia and Polymyalgia in my family so I've been following it. I haven't read anywhere so far where silicone causes this. If it did I'd probably have it by now because I've spread about a mile of silicone caulking.

You can complain all you want about Home Depot but we only have a Lowes in our town and I sure would appreciate having a Home Depot. When I visit them in Atlanta they seem to have a better selection of the things I buy than Lowes. Of course it could be the manager and how they run the store.

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#14

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

Bill White

>My alergic reaction comes from dealing with numbnutz staffers who don't know beans, and the fact that if ya want anything other than plain vanilla, ya gotta go elsewhere. Now let me see....Where did I find the silicone caulk last week. They have reset the store again.

Bill

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#15

Re: oh please!

Jim Dillon

>Jennifer,

I was trying to guide Malcom towards an area of silicone usage in humans where a LOT of research has been done. Some researchers and consumer-oriented organizations believe that there is an association between fibromyalgia symptoms and silicone breast implants. This is not saying that silicone containing breast implants cause fibromyalgia, or that the rate of fibromyalgia is greater in silicone breast implant patients - nor do I think I said that in my previous post.

Jim

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#16

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

Jim Dillon

>John,

There is a world of difference between the chemistry and intended use of silicone caulk, and other silicone products whether used in personal care items or surgical implants.

Jim

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#17

solvents?

John K Jordan

>Perhaps the problem is related to the solvents used in silicone in caulk and other applications. I don't know what all is used, but the RTV silicone sealer we used to used smelled a bit like acetic acid until cured. (We discovered the hard way that until cured, this stuff was highly conductive to 110V AC!)

But regardless of WHAT is causing the problem and regardless of the true medical diagnosis, from the Malcom's original post it seems like something at HD is affecting him and perhaps other Canadian shoppers.

JKJ

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#18

Re: oh please!

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Hmmmm... I have an implant, it's also silicon, no issues have I ever read about them.

take it easy,

Jim

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#19

Re: oh please!

Jim Dillon

>Jim,

Did you mean silicone, and not silicon? Common mistake. I assume you are talking about a preformed silicone implant like a finger joint, toe joint, testicular implant, male chest implant, tendons, metacarpals, etc. These are usually made from two-part silicones at the factory and are ready to use. Transition-metal or platinum catalyst problems aside, these implants are generally inert and well tolerated by the body. They are all relatively small in size thus minimizing the dose to the body of any residual cyclic monomer. The testicular implant is like a very tiny breast implant filled with silicone gel surrounded by a cross-linked silicone shell. Or used to be, I am not up on the current product line. Probably more than you wanted to know. 8-) The last I remember, you had had a hip resurfacing prosthesis done.

Jim

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#20

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I think anyone who takes this thread in any of its opinions seriously, deserves the consequences.

Clint

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#21

Implants for $500

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Hi Jim

You are a welcome wealth of information. I did have hip resurfacing just over a year ago, I had testicular and abdominal cancer 21 years ago. I have a testicular implant from back then, your information is correct.

Thank God for our health care system up here...

Take it easy,

Jim

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#22

Re: solvents?

Jim Dillon

>Hi John,

You got a good nose! Indeed, that was acetic acid you probably smelled as it is a byproduct of the RTV curing process for single-part silicones (as they are known). Moisture in the air sets off the chemical reaction, aka hydroysis, to cleave off the acetoxy group leaving a reactive hydroxyl group. This reactive hydroxyl group can then attack another acetoxy group (instead of moisture) in a separate silicone polymer chain and cause what is known as cross-linking. Eventually you end up with cured silicone. The residual acetic acid, which also acts as a catalyst in promoting the hydroysis, evaporates over a long period of time. Sorry you ever asked? 8-) 8-)

Now for the problems with silicones that are implanted in humans. I'll try to make this short, but it is complicated chemical-wise. Most polysiloxanes (polymers with a O-Si-O repeat unit) that we are familar with (Mobile 1 aside) are based on polydimethylsiloxane. These polymers are prepared by ring-opening polymerizations of cyclic siloxanes (the "monomer"). As with many other polymer monomers, [think vinyl chloride (used to make PVC), BPA (bis-phenol-A) used to make polycarbonate], it is the usually residual monomer that is the cause of any problem. Thus with polysiloxanes, even fully cured ones, residual monomer (those siloxane cyclics) may still be present. Here the plot thickens. Unlike some polymers which are made from a single monomer, the tank-car of cyclic siloxanes consists of a large number of different cyclics, anywhere from a D-3 (three membered ring) to say D-15. Some of these have been studied a lot for toxicity, while others have not. Some, especially the smaller cyclics are toxic. Whether or not they are associated with or causing the problems is more difficult to answer. Both the fully cross-linked shell of the breast prosthesis and the polysiloxane gel (partially cross-linked) have residual cyclics in them prior to implantation.

I don't have a clue what is on the stuff that Malcom feels is giving him the problem. If it is a polysiloxane, then it likely is something cheap, i.e. a polydimethyl siloxane or derivative. Hence there is the possibility of residual cyclics being inhaled; the lower molecular weight cyclics are very volatile. Then again, maybe it really is residual solvent they used to apply the coating and then flashed off. Who knows. Hey, all this and I didn't consult Wikipedia once 8-)!

Jim

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#23

Re: solvents?

John K Jordan

>Hey, I'll know who to ask about chemistry! I have no problem with physics and math since given a few basics you can figure out almost anything, but I found chemistry needed so much memorization it made my poor head hurt.

KJ

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#24

I'll drink to that!

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

#25

Re: Home Depot creating a health hazard

Malcolm Timbers

>Its not formaldehyde. I've been around that stuff and it doesn't cause me big problems. It is definitely a silicone compound, the stuff that makes their product water repellent. Once the silicone is washed out in soapy water, the rock wool readily absorbs water. Wearing a gas mask, I washed out a piece of Roxul and after that it soaked up water like a thirsty cow.

There is definitely a silicone compound in that stuff.