Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

OT- flooring

Posts

OT- flooring

#1

OT- flooring

Claudia Hayward

>I'm planning on putting some new flooring in my bathroom . I have a small office with a door between that and the bathroom and want to run the flooring straight through. It's only a powder room so there is no shower/bath to worry about. Currently I have lino down over K3 board and I'm trying to decide between hardwood, laminate (quality stuff) or engineered hardwood. As long as I can lay the new floor directly over the old I don't mind which type I choose. It will need to be able to stand up to a rolling office chair. What do you think would be the best choice?

Re: OT- flooring

#2

JL

Re: OT- flooring

JL

>Personally, I think whatever fits your style and pocketbook should work - with the following caveat. Thou shalt not roll rolling chairs on any sort of hardwood flooring. At least the domestic sort of hardwood. I'm not sure about some of the tropicals like ipe or brazilian cherry.

I would have a chair mat on the floor.

My $0.02.

Re: OT- flooring

#3

Re: OT- flooring

John K Jordan

>>I would have a chair mat on the floor.

And don't use one with the little points on the bottom intended to grip carpet. Unless you want little holes in your floor.

BTW, I love the Pergo type floating flooring (and clones), especially the slate and stone patterns. Goes down easy and looks great. The Pergo seems impervious to everything. A friend put a piece in a bucket of water outside over the winter and it still looked new after the freeze and thaw cycles. After years of "heavy" traffic (his large frame in an extremely heavy motorized wheelchair) the floor still looks like new as well.

JKJ

Re: OT- flooring

#4

Re: OT- flooring

paul in AZ

>Agree with John as far as 'Pergo type'.

I did a floor in one of the clones [German made Witex, I think it was] and tested a whole bunch of them with water and hammer.

Most are OK with moisture but Pergo did delaminate when wet. Not a strong consideration for your application but turned out to be a disaster in a friend's Pergo kitchen.

I also used a hammer test and found that most of them took a fairly heavy whack with a hammer to make a dent. They are tough, some more dent resistant than others.

I put it in a cottage sunporch that occasionally had people entering with golf shoe spikes and nothing bad happened.

Worth getting some samples and testing dent and scratch resistance.

Be aware that Pergo and it's clones will never sound or feel like real wood underfoot.

They may have improved the T&G now but I found that they are not as trouble free to assemble as the salesmen say. there was a fine line between a hair too loose [leaving a crack] and too tight [with subsequent tenting].

don't get Pergo. I think the competing products have improved a lot and there are now better ones out there.

Re: OT- flooring

#5

Re: OT- flooring

Barry Irby

>As a Home Inspector, I see a lot of the Pergo type flooring. While I like some of it, I am not a total fan. The quality varies dramatically. Some of it fails quickly with a water spill. Some of it "tents" or raises along the edges and when it does, the surface scuffs off. If you use it, I would be very careful and test a piece in water for a few days. Some holds up well and some swells up and falls apart.

Re: OT- flooring

#6

Re: OT- flooring

Claudia Hayward

>Thanks everyone. I think I'm going to take a closer look at real hardwood - and buy a floor protector for my chair!