Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

staining african mahogany

Posts

staining african mahogany

#1

staining african mahogany

al hillier

>Help!

After several months I have completed building a large armoire for my daughter. It is made from african mahogany, both hardwood and veneer. It has quite a bit of detail, trying to make it look oriental to match her other furniture. She wants it to be a dark reddish brown, more red than brown.

We get a different answer every time we visit a local wood working store.

They told us to coat it with benite to even out the stain. I did that. There were some areas lighter than others; they told us to give it a second coat of benite. I did that.

We're having a terrible time getting the reddish color she wants. On scraps we have tried water based stains and a gel stain. The benite seems to be yellowing the stains.

Now the wood store is telling us "the benite is doing what it is supposed to do - blocking variations but it is also blocking the stain". Their solution now is to sand everything with 150 grit; that would be really difficult with all the detail - not to mention a pain in the neck.

What should I do? We have not tried using a dye yet, I am afraid of lap marks with the amount of detail we have.

Re: staining african mahogany

#2

Re: staining african mahogany

Jim Dillon

>Al,

I'm far, far from a finishing expert, but I recently finished two small tables in African mahogany. FWIW, here is what I used.

On one table, I followed the easy recipe given by Bob Lang in the December 2007, Popular Woodworking. Two coats of Dark Walnut Danish oil, each applied for with a Scotch-Brite white pad and allowed to set for 10 minutes, then wiped off. Bob then followed with coats of natural Watco Danish oil. I used Tried and True varnish/oil blend because I had it on hand and have had good luck with it. When fully dry, I applied Mylands Dark Mahogany wax with 0000 steel wool. My table turned out more red than brown and I liked the look.

On the second table, I wanted a more brown look, with just a hint of red. So I started experimenting with toning the finish directly. I made up two solutions of T&T Danish oil. One solution contained medium-brown TransTint aniline dye (2 oz/qt), and the second solution contained red-brown TransTint dye (2 oz/qt). I ended up mixing the two solutions 50:50, but having the two solutions made experimentation on scrap wood easy. I applied one coat and allowed it to set for 10-13 minutes, then wiped off. I let it dry several days, then applied two coats of Tried and True Varnish/oil. Finally, when very dry, I applied Mylands Dark Mahogany wax with 0000 steel wool. Incorporating the dye directly into the oil sure made it easy to apply a nice even coat. Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: staining african mahogany

#3

Re: staining african mahogany

Fred Davis

>Sounds to me like you would have been better off by far to have checked with Jim instead of the Woodstore, hard to beat experience.

Well you say, "I didn't know Jim", so post the question here first.

Anyway you look at it , after you go to all of the work necessary to get down to wood, experiment before you try the next time.

FredD

Re: staining african mahogany

#4

Bart Goldberg

Re: staining african mahogany

Bart Goldberg

>Hi Jim,

If I were in this situation - I would call Jeff Jewitt at Homestead Finishing. He is a true finishing expert, and is amazingly accessible given his notoriety. He can be reached via his web site at www.homesteadfinishing.com.

Good Luck

Bart

Re: staining african mahogany

#5

Re: staining african mahogany

Steve Schoene

>By the way, the advise you were given shows clearly that the "guys" at the store know very little about finishing. Benite is a "conditioner" sometimes used under a stain to prevent "blotching" on diffuse porous woods such as maple and cherry. It would never be needed on mahogany, African or Honduran. Mahogany accepts stain well and evenly without the conditioner.

To decide where to go from here, the first step is to prepare a good sized scrap or two from the project just to the point where you are now, to work out what works and what doesn't before you touch the project itself.

One possibility is to use a gel stain over the benite, essentially, as a glaze. Gel stain doesn't penetrate much anyway, mostly working by creating the color on the surface.

Re: staining african mahogany

#6

Re: staining african mahogany

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>too late to give you a detailed response, but that is th elook I wanted recently. Have to get up at 4 AM to go deer hunting. Search recent posts for my post on "French Footed federal wall cabinet. If you like that finish, it is traditional and used by many reproduction furniture makers, email me and I will provide schedule.

Re: staining african mahogany

#7

Re: staining african mahogany

Jim Dillon

>Al,

Minor correction to my original post. I used Mylands Antique Mahogany wax, not a Dark Mahogany which I don't even know if they make.

Barts suggestion is a good one. Jeff's site is an excellent source of info and they have an active finishing forum. Actually, the use of TransTint dyes directly in the finish came from Jeff's site (with a nod to Rob Millard - a Federal-style furniture builder).

From the TransTint instructions for use.

To Use as a Finish Toner:

"One of the most unique features of TransTint Dyes is their compatibility with a wide range of finishing mediums. They can be added directly to shellac, water-based finishes, solvent lacquers, as well as catalyzed varnishes and lacquers to make toners and shaders."

To Use in Oil Finishes:

"TransTint Dyes may be added to "some" oil-based products. Before adding, the dye shuld be mixed with acetone or methyl-ketone (MEK) in the ration of one part dye to 4 parts acetone or MEK. This solution can then be added directly to linseed oil, pure tung oil and oil-based varnishes. It cannot be added to most "Danish oil" or other finishes thinned with a high ratio of mineral spirits. Shake solution thoroughly before applying to wood. TransTint can be added directly to Tried & True Danish Oil or Bartley's Gel Varnish and used as a wiping stain. There is no need to mix the dye with acetone when using these products".

Jeff Jewett had an article in FWW No. 157, August 2002 regarding use of TransTint dyes to finish mahogany.

Hope this helps. If you can find a color that you all like, I think using a toned finish would make finishing a complex surface like you have would be easier.

As suggested by others, try scraps of final sanded wood to see the final color.

Got to go walk the dogs, they are going crazy. Good luck.

Jim

Re: staining african mahogany

#8

Re: staining african mahogany

Paul Woolson

>Here's a little trick we (guitar builders) use when trying to achieve that red antique patina.

1 table spoon baking soda to one cup water.

Wipe it on and watch it turn red.

It's probably too late for you as you've got it sealed up already but maybe it will help for the next project.

Re: staining african mahogany

#9

Re: staining african mahogany

Fred Davis

>one should "stir finish" especially Varnish rather then "shake it". to prevent bubbles forming in the can of finish.

FredD

Re: staining african mahogany

#10

Re: staining african mahogany

Jim Dillon

>Fred,

Good point! I was careful to gently stir the TransTinted oil while I was waiting for it to dissolve. Takes awhile. At first it looks like one is making an oil/vinegar salad dressing with the two immiscible components. I probably gently stirred every couple of hours and then just let the jar set over night and stirred the next day and just before any use. The 2 oz/quart is the MAXIMUM concentration recommended by the instructions. As theTransTint dye solution is so concentrated, one could probably use less.

Jim

Re: staining african mahogany

#11

Re: staining african mahogany

Tony - Memphis

>I always use the Lockwood water based dye stain (from Lockwood direct or from Lee Valley). I use a combination of Colonial Red? and a brown that I can't recall. The red is a very nice red/brown color, but too much for my taste. The brown cancels some of the red. Nice thing about the dye is that you can start very weak and work up to what you want. I've never had any issues with streaking. Keep a wet edge and it works out fine. You can also apply it with a brush or a spray bottle. Make sure you test with finish. Dye stains look much different under a finish. They look terrible when they dry! Makes you think you really messed up, but then the top coat brings it back to life. Good luck with your project.

Tony