Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

OT-3 way switch question

Posts

OT-3 way switch question

#1

OT-3 way switch question

Jim in Conowingo, MD

>Hi Guys,

I have an existing light circuit that I would like to add a new switch to. I can access the light box to add a new 14-3 for the new switch, but replacing the 14-2 wire from the old switch with 14-3 will probably require busting into a wall. So I'm wondering if I can use the existing 14-2 black and white wires as my runners and use the ground for the neutral? That's essentially how a 220 circuit gets wired. Any safety concerns with doing that? I really don't want to bust open that wall. TIA

Jim

Re: OT-3 way switch question

#2

No way no how!

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Your plan will work electrically, but it is completely wrong to do that. It is dangerous as the "ground will be live some times. Please don't do it! It may also void your homeowners insurance if there is ever a problem.

lee

Re: OT-3 way switch question

#3

Re: I agree with Lee

GalenV

>And 220 lines do not use the uninsulated ground wire as a nuetral. They are three wire system with ground. Only two wire 220 I know of may be some older submersible pumps where controls are submerged and they scare me.

Re: OT-3 way switch question

#4

Re: OT-3 way switch question

Bill Howatt

>As you have been told, it is not legal to use the ground wire in this manner. You would be breaking the ground continuity and using the bare wire to carry anything other than fault current is a violation.

There are a lot of inexpensive remote control gizmos on the market these days and perhaps you could find one that would do the job legally.

Bill

Re: OT-3 way switch question

#5

Not exactly…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> And 220 lines do not use the uninsulated ground wire as a nuetral.

This part is true. But not for the reason you think. Technically 240V systems do not use or need a neutral at all. Two conductors carry the current and the ground is for safety.

Modern ranges and clothes dryers, however, are frequently designed with 120V subsystems. Up until around 2000 (I don't know the exact year—could be earlier or later by two or three years), the NEC permitted the customary two conductor plus ground 240V connection and internally the appliances used the ground as a neutral for the 120V systems inside. That is no longer permitted for new work, and a four wire (three conductor plus ground) feed is required to supply them. New replacement ranges or dryers are still permitted to use older existing supplies (two wire conductor with ground), however, and instructions are provided to jumper the ground bus to the neutral bus in the appliance to use them.

> They are three wire system with ground.

In new work, yes. Since the date described previously. But primarily for ranges and dryers. Other 240V circuits may not require a neutral.

> Only two wire 220 I know of may be some older submersible pumps where controls are submerged…

Nope. Water heaters, for example, are permitted to be wired with a two conductor plus ground supply. I think most woodworkers wire their 240V machines with two conductor plus ground supplies, too.

> …and they scare me.

No reason to. The ground should provide the protection needed. Besides, they're just motors. What would a separate neutral do for them anyway?

Rod

Re: OT-3 way switch question

#6

Traffic

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>"...What would a separate neutral do for them anyway..."

It would let you sit idling in traffic without having to keep your foot on the clutch.....

No, wait a minute, wrong topic ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT-3 way switch question

#7

There may be another option.

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>If you could pick up a neutral somewhere else while you run your new switch, you could use the hot into the existing switch, into a new three way with the black and white out to the fixture.

The black and white, could then tie into the red and black of new 4 wire to the new switch, then the white back to the fixture would be the hot. But you would need to find another neutral somewhere up in the attic to tie into if there was something handy.

I am not an electrician, so I don't know if it would be legal, but it would keep you from having to tear out the old switch.

Re: OT-3 way switch question

#8

Re: OT-3 way switch question

Randy Johnson Connersville IN

>Sometimes, especially in some older installations where maybe a bedroom ceiling light switch was fed from a receptacle, there will be a neutral in a box where there is a light switch. If on the other hand, the switch is fed from the light there is no neutral. When discussing a three-way switch, there are two travelers and a common. A common and a neutral are not the same. The way I wire three way switches, one common, the one coming from the light, is ALWAYS energized. The common on the other switch is energized when the light is on. Using a bare ground to routinely conduct current is not just a code violation, it is a bad idea of major proportions.

Nonetheless�..

Years ago I was called to check out a building where the tenants were getting shocked when they turned the lights on. It was wired exactly the way being discussed here. 12-2 NM between three-way switches with the bare ground used as the common. Whoever did it DID tape the bare ground wire in the boxes the switches were in. He also stripped the jacket off past the point where it was in the box so the bare ground was touching the box. Since this guaranteed the switch box being ungrounded there was nothing to prevent it being �hot�.

Re: OT-3 way switch question

#9

sounds dangerous

John K Jordan

>>pick up a neutral somewhere else...don't know if it would be legal

Yikes, if I'm thinking clearly this early in the morning it seems like this would be dangerous, especially if the two circuits were on different breakers. Imagine someone flipping off the breaker for the circuit with the shared neutral to work on it while the circuit with the 3-way was still hot and the light turned on. Open a box, disconnect the neutral, zap - you're holding an energized return for a hot circuit elsewhere (the 3-way). Worse, the two circuits might be feed from the other size of the breaker box.

Of course I've seen worse in Mexico - bare wires tacked to walls in stores and houses - just be careful not to lean against the wall.

JKJ

Re: OT-3 way switch question

#10

Re: sounds dangerous

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Well, you may have found something there, but not if it was the neutral from the same circuit.

It may not be that hard to find and put it on the same circuit, like a closet light in the same on neighboring room, should have an un-switched neutral. Before doing the work, just find and switch off the breaker that kills the room where the new switch is going. While it is off, test the other lights to find one on the same circuit.

Then I see no danger running a new insulated conductor over to pick it up there. But then, I don't recall the OP saying whether this was between floors or in and attic.

Re: OT-3 way switch question

#11

Re: OT-3 way switch question

Jim in Conowingo, MD

>Thanks guys, looks like I'll try pulling a new line, although I have a bad feeling I have drywall work in my near future.

Re: OT-3 way switch question

#12

You don't need 3 conductor wire...

John in NM

>For ALL 3 way switch setups, though you do for some. It can be done with just regular romex as a loop circuit where the fixture is hooked up to the pole terminals of the two switches and the hot and common are hooked to the throw terminals. When the light is off, both switches are switched to the same conductor, be it hot or common. When the light is on, one switch is switched common, and one hot, creating a loop. This is an acceptable method per NEC, but a lot of DYI books don't mention seem to mention it. It may not work for your setup, you do have to have power at BOTH switch boxes.

Re: OT-3 way switch question

#13

Re: sounds dangerous

John K Jordan

>I think one big problem with non-standard wiring, even if done logically and safely, is what it does for the next guy. The next owner or electrician may experience confusion and language issues when trying to repair or modify the wiring.

It can be a real pain trying to figure out existing wiring. For example, the electrician who wired a 4-way circuit in the house we now live in evidently didn't quite understand 4-way wiring but somehow succeeded in making two of three switches work as long as the third switch was never touched. I had to scratch my head and make a logic table of the voltage readings on conductors in three different ganged boxes before I could sketch out a wiring diagram and fix the problem. There is another switch upstairs that does nothing and I've yet to figure out where and how it is connected.

JKJ

Re: OT-3 way switch question

#14

Clearly....

John in NM

>Your mystery switch is the fourth one on the newly invented 5 way switched lamp. Haven't you ever needed to turn on a light downstairs when you're upstairs?

Re: OT-3 way switch question

#15

Extra work is better than replacing your house

Bill Houghton, sunny in Sebastopol, CA

>I don't think it's worth dinking around with electrical circuitry and possibly endangering yourself or a future owner/worker. Do it clean and right. Some stuff can be faked - there are often about 18 different ways to resolve a structural problem - but with electrical work, you're bringing a dangerous genie into the house, and you want to keep it properly contained.

Re: OT-3 way switch question

#16

Re: Clearly....

John K Jordan

>I checked all light circuits, room outlets, and ceiling fans. There is power to the switch and a lead out of the box but what gets turned on when I flip it, who knows. Perhaps a neighbor in the next farm is cursing their spooky light that comes on by itself only once a year or so.

(That reminds me of a telephone jack I found in a spare bedroom at my last house. I hooked up a phone to see if it worked and started getting calls for a house four streets down the hill.)

BTW, you can use 5 or 6 or as many switches that you want on a circuit with 4-way switches. Use two 3-way switches (one on each end) and 4-way switches everywhere in between.

JKJ


img