Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

OT- (sort of) Rockefeller Christmas Tree *LINK*

Posts

OT- (sort of) Rockefeller Christmas Tree *LINK*

#1

OT- (sort of) Rockefeller Christmas Tree *LINK*

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>As much as I hate to see a perfectly healthy, majestic, one of a kind tree cut down, this story hits close to home. Literally!

While I'm not one to feel indifferent towards those that like real trees or those that prefer artificials, the tree in New York this year will add some history to a Town I was born and raised in. I live only moments away from where this mighty giant once stood.

It also has a personal note because my Brother-in-Law served on a special task force with the local police dept. (he's police officer in Hamilton) to gaurd the tree against those who might view the felling of such a tree as a waste.

I have mixed feelings about live trees for Christmas. I've always had artificial, my wife always had a real one. We actually need to get a tree this year after 10 years of the fake one. It saw better days and went to the trash. We may get a real one because the cost of a new artificial is out of the budget. We can get a real tree for around $50-60. It's a no brainer with the economy this year.

A small part of me feels proud though, to see this particular tree in New York this year and I can't explain it.....

The Carson family will make an effort to visit this mighty giant during the next few weeks. I think my kids will hold onto this memory for years to come. That makes me feel good. That's what the season means to me most....family and memories.

Ray


Rockefeller Christmas Tree

Re: OT- (sort of) Rockefeller Christmas Tree *LINK*

#2

Sprucing Up The Neighborhood

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Ray,

The person we bought this house from had a real Christmas Tree one year and planted it. It grew up to the stars, dropped pine cones for my grandkids to gather, and provided grace and green to our back yard. My next door neighbor planted one at the same time in her backyard, very close to mine. Good decision. The two trees grew tall together, and looked wonderful. It was their charm which pursuaded us to buy the house. Unfortunately, our neighbor became convinced that her tree was going to fall on her roof, and had it cut down. It was healthy and in its prime. I got sick when they took it down. My neighbor is an elderly lady and is not open to reason anymore. What a pity. If possible, plant trees. Don't cut them down.

George

Re: OT- (sort of) Rockefeller Christmas Tree *LINK*

#3

How about Boston's Christmas tree?

Charles R. Smith

>How about the Boston Christmas tree? It�s a sign of friendship between two countries.

For many years, the Province of Nova Scotia has donated a giant evergreen each year to the people of Boston as a thank you for their assistance following the 1917 Halifax Explosion.

The tree comes from a private land owner, is selected by the Nova Scotia Department of Natural Resources, and is transported to Boston by the Province of Nova Scotia. It�s delivered to the Boston Common, to serve as the focal point of the city's annual tree lighting ceremony.

It�s quite an honour to have your tree chosen for Boston. This year, the tree is a 14-metre (about 45 foot) white spruce that was cut on Craig and Marina Cook's property in Clementsvale, Annapolis County, on November 17.

(As an aside, the Halifax explosion was probably the greatest non-nuclear explosion to occur in history. Two ships collided in the Halifax harbour on the morning of 6 December 1917, one of which was a French ship with 2,300 tons of wet and dry picric acid, 200 tons of TNT, 10 tons of gun cotton and 35 tons of benzol � a rather explosive mixture. The death toll was just over 1,900, with 9,000 injured and 1,630 homes being completely destroyed; the ensuing fires added to the toll. When Boston learned of the disaster, that night they sent a train loaded with supplies, along with medical personnel as well as its Public Safety Committee.)

Charles (who thinks that Christmas trees, though perhaps politically incorrect, are wonderful tools for bring friends together)

Re: OT- (sort of) Rockefeller Christmas Tree *LINK*

#4

Re: Sprucing Up

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>George,

I couldn't agree with your last statement more. Like I said, I have mixed feelings about cutting down trees for Christmas or for any reason if it's a perfectly good tree and poses no saftey concern. It does seem like a big waste, I agree. You drive to work the weeks after the holidays and see the dried up things laying on the side of the road.

The tough part for me is being a woodworker. If it weren't for the trees then where would you and I be? I know how they get wood for you and I but still....

I was upset when we moved from our last house, we planted 3 pear trees and couldn't take them with us. Luckily, the house we live in now has a woods directly in back of my back yard. AND !! it's green acres protected / wetlands so.....NO developments going up anytime soon.

I hear ya George....it's still kind of neat about this tree. I respect your thoughts though.

Ray

Re: OT- (sort of) Rockefeller Christmas Tree *LINK*

#5

Thanks..Great Story

Tony - Memphis

>I'm alwasy torn about cutting down a tree. Not an issue in my suburbian 'hood, but...I have planted my fair share on our small lot. I even feel guilty about ripping up all the oak and maple babies we get. I have planted some in the woods around our neighborhood. We have an artificial. I was torn about that too! I always wanted real, but we vist family every other year and the tree is really dry by the time we get back. Plus, there are two heat vents that blow directly onto the tree, drying it out before Christmas. One year, I was afraid to turn the lights on it was so dry. So, we keep using the artificial. Rather have real though. Nothing beats a Noble fir. I wonder which is really harder on the environment? maybe we should all grow our own.

Tony

Re: OT- (sort of) Rockefeller Christmas Tree *LINK*

#7

Re: OT- (sort of) Rockefeller Christmas Tree

Pete LaBelle

>Fear not of using a real tree from a dealer or farm. Christmas trees are a crop. If you have reservations about a tree from one of these sources, do you have reservations about eating corn, or eating a chicken? All these items, when managed, are not putting their numbers at risk.

Problem with Christmas trees is that they take 10-20 years to mature, thus trends in tree habits take a long time to respond to. Ironically though, so many people are buying plastic trees, that many farms have quit cutting and the trees are left to grow wild.

Now, if you sneak out to someone's forest and cut down a tree, that woods is probably not managed, and you are then having an impact on the ecology of the area.

Pete from Michigan, one of the bigger Christmas tree supplier states in the Union.

Re: OT- (sort of) Rockefeller Christmas Tree *LINK*

#8

Best of both worlds ...

Larry Marker

>Buy a live tree in a pot/tub. Decorate it and after Christmas, plant it in your yard (or somebody else's if you don't have room.) That way you have a real tree and don't have to kill it to enjoy it.

We have done that several times and it's a treat.

Larry