>I have tried both ways and had OK results, not great, just OK, but I need opinions. Do you cut with the cutoff toward the fence or away? I cut almost exclusively around 1/8" if that makes a difference.
>Doug, I'm certainly no expert, but I read a suggestion somewhere a suggestion to cut with the finished piece between the fence unless you have a micro-adjustable fence. Either way requires that you have checked and adjusted your fence for drift. Otherwise, it may be better to skip the fence completely and use a single-point or curved resaw guide and follow a line by eye.
When you say the results were OK but not great, what was the problem? Bowing, rough cut, inconsistent thickness?
More important may be the blade and proper tensioning. A good tension meter has improved my thick-stock bandsawing. I'm saving up for one of those carbide resaw blades.
A buddy once called me to see if I could resaw a board for him on my little 14" Delta with riser. He brought over a 2x12 doug fir "just" 12' long! Ack! I built a long and tall fence, adjusted carefully for drift, and the board into four pieces clean enough to just need a couple of light passes on the planer. However, it took an hour to make the three cuts! I cut with the offcut away from the fence (the finished thickness towards the fence).
>Are you saying the finished pc is between the blade and the fence? I always thought that was the way to go,don't have to move fence on each successive cut.BUT Doug or the other gent that wrote a book on the band saw,saw it the other way? If you were satisfied with that 2x12x12' cut,then I'm with you. Unless extremely hard,I find walnut and oak easier to cut than any type of pine.(I don't do wet resawing). pw
>The whole point of a fence is to determine the thickness of the desired piece. It is awkward at best to have to subtract the thickness of the blade and the remainder from the current thickness; and, if the original board is not flat and of uniform thickness, the finish piece will be irregular.
There are different schools of thought regarding bandsaw fences. Personally, I have almost always used a single point fence lined up with the teeth. Sometimes I gauge the line as a visual guide, but I have found that it is just as accurate to sort of cross your eyes and focus on the kerf at the back edge of the blade. If the blade is centered in the kerf, you're cutting straight. If it is rubbing on one side of the kerf, it means that the teeth are leading for some reason and you need to compensate by steering the board. The point fence allows you to do this. Mark Duginske used to use a long bowed fence with the high point of the bow aligned with the teeth of the blade. This is the same principle as the point fence concept, but it has a slight advantage in that it keeps you from reversing direction quite as severely because the bow supports the adjacent stock as you feed it.
>OK, I got out the books for a check. In "Bandsaw Handbook" Duginski mentions that while normal ripping will put the finished piece between the blade and the fence (for consistent sizes), "at other times, especially whey you are cutting thin pieces, the workpiece will be the piece on the side of the blade opposite the fence." However, most of his later resaw advice is around using a single point guide instead of a fence. He does say "If your saw is well-aligned and cuts straight, you can use a high fence." His one picture of cutting veneer shows the veneer falling off the outside. I think he has a new version of this book out which may have more info, but I don't have it.
The other book I have, "The Bandsaw Book" by Lonnie Bird, he doesn't address this directly but his pictures of cutting veneer show the veneer between the blade and the fence. His suggestion to use a single-point fence is under the discussion of resawing on a curve, say for a chair back.
You might give Iturra Design a call (866-883-8064) - Louis Iturra seems to have some experience and is always helpful on the phone.
>I was doing some resawing this weekend. I had everything setup for the "good" piece to be next to the fence. All went well for a couple of boards, then, all the sudden, I had one go awry. I still can't figure out what happened, but the cut was no longer parallel to the fence. I started over with the point fence and was able to get a good cut by following my line. I had been cutting teak, and I wondered if the blade got dull enough that it messed things up. No more teak in my shop. It wreaks havoc on every edge it touches. Normally, I resaw with a flat fence and the waste to the outside. That usually works. Practice with some scrap and see what feels best. Cutting with the point fence is really no that bad. I have gotten pretty good results.
>If you can't make straight flat cuts the question is moot. If you can, and you want to repeat the process, it's obviously better to set the fence once for your desired thickness. I sense the problem you're all having is that you can't follow any fence, much less a tall one. The reason for this is that your saws are not designed to resaw, you don't understand the blade dynamics necessary for deeper cutting, your fences don't line up with the blade, your fences don't support the workpiece, The fence is too long behind the blade, the fence is too short overall, you're not getting enough dynamic tension, and your blade guides are too expensive. I have a solution for all that. But I'm not going to tell you. What you need is a Slice Miester. Failing that, you're doomed. And don't bother looking up my website. It's not there yet.
>What pray tell,is a slice Meister?? A new type of beaver?
Now I'm really,really confused! It would seem sometimes its correct to have the veineer cut between the fence and blade,sometimes falling off other side, and sometimes between the single point fence and the blade. You mention variables such as blade type,tension,size of saw ad infinitum... This gent that raised the question,is going to experiment because he aint sure... I believe the depth of cut will matter too. I used to think a thick pc would be easier,since it would kinda hold against the blade,but that doesn't seem to pan out in my practice. As a former flat fence user,I'm leaning on going to a single point fence,and joint before ea cut to have one side smooth and flat. Lets just say what works best with you,saw and wood,is the best you can do.pw
>The answer turns out to be that cutting veneer involves a two-part fence. The primary fence needs to support the workpiece straightly into the blade and then release the off cut. The secondary fence needs to continue to guide the workpiece through the end of the cut on a new plane defined by the fresh cut. I found that a vestigial fence which can slip into the kerf right behind the blade will pick up the lateral trajectory of the workpiece and guide it, uninterrupted, through the rest of the cut - with no sniping at the end. Perfectly; every time.
>Yes. The short little vestigial fence keeps the workpiece running straight in line with the high fence so all you have to do is hold it against the high fence till the veneer falls off. There's zero snipe that way and you can back up to start another cut immediately. The problem with most saws is that the fence tends to push the workpiece away from a solid fence as the veneer curls and sawdust builds up along the fence's edge. Running along the little stainlees steel strip keeps the workpiece from accumulating dust. You can't see it but that whole quarter-panel is forward and back adjustable to line up with whatever blade you're using and there's a little gap through which the dust drops free to the underside of the tabletop. It's so solid I wasn't even watching as I fed the piece through. You can feel it running rock solid against both fences without variation or any tendency to drift away. It's the way bandsaws are *supposed* to work. I could make an aftermarket clamp-on for the regular saws out there if anyone shows an interest. It wouldn't have the benefit of my 72" table but would totally solve your veneer problems. And be a whole lot cheaper. I've already explained how to get perfectly flat fence cuts (I'm disappointed that so many here still go on about "drift") on a standard band saw so all you'd need is a modular fence and a second/clamp-on top with the SS shark fin. Let's all take a vote.