Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Belt sander questions

Posts

Belt sander questions

#1

Belt sander questions

Bill Houghton, sunny in Sebastopol, CA

>I'm a hybrid hand/power tool user with a very small shop (11 feet square). Lots of carpentry on our 115-year-old house, hopes for some furniture making soon. I have a little Bosch belt sander (the one with the inline motor) that is dying (the quick release handle is plastic, and snapped off), and am thinking about whether to buy a replacement. So, some questions:

1. Do I need one at all? I use hand planes a lot for flattening and smoothing, and I own a random orbit sander that works pretty well for smoothing duties where a plane's not workable and a power planer for rough stock reduction when I need speed. Am I missing some capacity that a hand held belt sander could provide?

2. If I do buy, I'm considering the DeWalt 432 belt sander that Woodworker.com on which Woodworker's Supply is currently offering a free sanding frame that also serves as a support to use the sander as a benchtop sander. This belt sander has had some good reviews. Does anyone have experience, positive or negative, with it?

Re: Belt sander questions

#2

Re: Belt sander questions

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>You're the best and final judge of what it can do for you. Was it worth what you've used it for in the past? If you get a new one and it doesn't come in handy, it can be souped up and made into a racer.

Clint

Re: Belt sander questions

#3

Re: Belt sander questions

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>Bill -

I use my belt sander upside down in a jig for sharpening my axe, also preliminary shaping of carving gouges. Also for back-beveling the occasional laminate countertop. Other than that, it doesn't see much action. I have a Festool 150 for doing the kinds of wood sanding chores the belt sander might be tasked for. The 150 does a much better job. Like you, I use planes, scrapers and sometimes a power plane for most wood flatteningf work.

Ed

Re: Belt sander questions

#4

Re: Belt sander questions

Barry Irby

>I have to agree with clint and Ed on this. You be the judge. I have had a blet sander for about forty years. It gets less use now than ever. It sits upside down in a jig I made for that purpose. I use it in that position occasionally, but I can't remember the last time I used it right side up as a sander. My ROS gets much more use.

Re: Belt sander questions

#5

Re: Belt sander questions

Bill Spievak

>I have a DeWalt belt sander, 3 inch by 21 inch, I purchased 8 years ago. I wouldn't buy it again because the dust collection port isn't round and therefore, required much improvision to hook up to the vac. Also, it is a bit finiky when it comes to belt tracking. That said, it still works and gets used to sand wood about once per month. There is nothing like a belt sander to take off material fast. It can screw up a job very fast as well. I have a Festool ros with the duel mode and that get used more frequently. However, if my current belt sander became unusable I would purchase a replacement. I would make sure it could be attached to the vac first!

Re: Belt sander questions

#6

Re: Belt sander questions

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I don't use mine a lot - but when I do need it, I sure don't regret the purchase. I use mine to clean raw (dry) lumber that has a lot of debris embedded in the surface. I buy quite a bit of my wood from auctions - some has been stored in barns etc for years. I know some will say you shouldn't sand before planing as it leaves grit - but I've never seen any problems with my joiner or planer (both have carbide insert spiral heads). I occasionally use it to quickly flatten a panel or cutting board before I put it through the planer. I also use it for rough refinishing work - like my porch floor as prep for repainting. I have the Porter Cable Whisper 3" X 24" variable speed model, not cheap but works very well and does a pretty good job of containing the major dust.

Re: Belt sander questions

#7

Re: Belt sander questions

del schisler

>I have the Porter Cable 3" X 24" variable speed model Not the wisper model Very noisey I also have the Porter Cable Whisper 4" X 24" variable speed mode it is real quite sounding I use them probly each day They have held up very good The 4x24 is very heavy But it will take the wood off fast The 3x24 does a good job but if it is not the wisper model get the ear muffs out thanks for reading my 2 pennies worth