>Am I the only one who can barely stand reading web sites which have white text on a black background? After about 45 seconds of viewing such a site, if I look around the room, I can STILL SEE the horizontal rows of white against black - like I had been staring at the sun through half-open mini-blinds! If I HAVE TO view such a site for more than a minute or 2, I override the site's color defaults in FF to black on white, which is a bit of a PITA. Seriously, does anyone else find these so annoying??? Maybe it's an age thing.
End of rant ;-/
Dan
Re: OT: REALLY hate white text on black background
Re: OT: REALLY hate white text on black background
John K Jordan
>You are not the only one. Unfortunately, the power to design a web site is not always accompanied by either common sense or an understanding of basic design principles. Same thing happened when desktop publishing and even word processors hit the public.
JKJ
Re: OT: REALLY hate white text on black background
>I use AutoCad a fair bit and at least there I much prefer a black background, maybe because I use a lot of colors for different layers. I never really though about white on black in plain text, so I guess it doesn't bother me. I just don't like any combination where there isn't much contrast.
glc
Re: OT: REALLY hate white text on black background
Re: OT: REALLY hate white text on black background
Fred Davis
>Myabe it's what your used to seeing, take Zebras for instance, what we see over here as either black on white stripes, or white on black, in Africa they see the opposite.
For me, not using contrast on things like drill bit sizes is not fair to us elders ;-))
FredD
Re: OT: REALLY hate white text on black background
Re: OT: REALLY hate black text on white background
GolfSteve in Calgary
>I'm the opposite. I HATE and cannot use sites that use white backgrounds for more than 5 to 10 minutes. The brilliance of a white background is very irritating to my eyes.
I much prefer black background with white text. The amount of radiation hitting your eyes is much reduced compared to the reverse.
With Windows I have to compromise and use a dark grey background with black text. This causes much less eye strain than the standard white background. I'm on a computer 8 hours a day at work.
Of course Woodcentral uses a white background as the default, which is completely HORRIBLE. Unfortunatley the content is so good that I'm forced to return here :-)
Re: OT: REALLY hate white text on black background
Re: OT: REALLY hate black text on white background *LINK*
Frank House
>There is lots of theory (which I am familiar with as I had to study physiology and was interested in visual matters) which says black on a white background should work best. I recently had a technical discussion of all this with a more knowledgeable friend - a summary would occupy a few hundred words, but the conclusion was the same.
When it comes to it, however, I mess around with colours for editors and terminals etc every time I install a new Linux distribution (about 4 times a year), and I always end up with a dark background and light lettering. You can see my favourite combination on my website (frankhouse.me.uk). I copied it from the old "Woodworking and Hiding in the Garage" site - grateful acknowledgment.
Perhaps it has to do with the fact I get frequent migraines and mostly seem on the verge of one. Large, bright surfaces do me no favours, and my flicker fusion frequency is high, so moving visual focus across a white area, even on a fast-refreshed LCD screen, is uncomfortable.
On my system, the current WC background is coloured at the top, shading to white. I find the top of the page more comfortable to read than the bottom.
I used Auto and other cads and modeling software for years and also used black background for a while. Early CRTs all had white text on black background and people got used to it. This changed when graphical interfaces went mainstream.
When 3D modeling software was going through infancy, there was much discussion among beta testers and users about the background. Autodesk/Kinetics/Discreet chose a neutral grey for the 3D Studio Max background. Tests found it easier on the eyes after long hours of use than either jet black or pure white. There was also the perception that fine lines were finer on a non-black or non-white background so detail was easier to distinguish and create. I bump mine a little more towards a darker gray which I find gives better contrast.
I personally have problems with either bright white OR jet black but black is far worse for me than white. The white can have a blinding background and the black creates blinding text. However, white on black is better than say, bright blue or yellow on black - if the text on black is a bright color, for me it is practically unreadable. What I find horrible is web page designs that use combinations of bright colors because they think it's cool. To me, they look like obnoxious neon advertising lights along a trashy urban commercial street. For me, reading text on a web site is easier if the background is a little off-white.
Neutral grey is also FAR better as a background when creating color graphics and editing photographs. If the background is color, the eyes will adapt to that color and the user's perception of all the colors in the image will be skewed. Photoshop and many other graphics editors use a grey background for this reason.
One big difference in viewer perception can be in the monitor adjustment. Some people have the monitor brightness and contrast turned up too high. This can be pretty bright, especially in a darkened room but the brightness may be needed in a brightly lit office. Most graphics shops have learned to have the room lights a little dimmer and use task lights where necessary. A darkened room with well-placed lighting also reduces glare on the monitor which can reduce contrast and cause eyestrain.
Since I work in a darkened room, I use a lower monitor brightness. I use several lights on dimmers which I brighten as needed. BTW, lowered brightness is better for the long-term health of monitors. CRTs were worse about this, but I understand a lower brightness can help slow the deterioration of the lamps in LCDs. For graphics work, if the brightness and color on a monitor is not properly calibrated it is difficult to produce quality work.
The color temperature of the room lighting is also important. Working under fluorescent or incandescent lights can change the color perception of what is on the monitor. This is one reason for using dimmed lighting.
Another issue is monitor gamma. There is a difference between the Mac and PC (Windows) world on this, with the Mac monitors (at least in the past) using a different gamma than the PC. This creates all kinds of problems when creating and sharing graphic content.
The attached image has some test patterns. The one on the bottom is a good test - if a monitor is adjusted properly you will be able to easily distinguish all the shades in both bars. I use a variation of the one on the top (double wide) spread over dual monitors to make sure each is the same. Other patterns are available in color. There are calibration web sites that can help - the link has one that looks pretty good. If you have any of the Adobe products they come with an Adobe Gamma program which will also help with basic calibration. I use a hardware device called the Spyder for calibration but it's kind of pricey for general use.
BTW, I also dislike the Woodcentral black text on a bright white page. In a perfect world, all these colors would be user-defined.
>Through my travels I've found that there are only two types of people:
1 - Those that like black on white backgrounds
2 - Those that like white on black backgrounds
3 - Those that don't notice the difference ;)
Seriously though, for everyone one person that likes something one way, I can find someone who likes it the another way. Personal taste, like in art, is, well, personal taste.
Additionally, there are people who find Atlanta too hot, and those that find it too cold. Those who like the Atlanta winters to get away from the hot humidity and those who prefer the hot humidity to the cold winters.
We humans are a difficult bunch ;)
Happy Woodworking!
Re: OT: REALLY hate white text on black background
>I actually find such sites uncomfortable, if not outright painful to view, regardless of their content or artistic merit. Again, to me it's almost like the effect of a camera flash going off in my eyes. I have seen a site or 2 which had the white on black as the default setting, but provided an option to switch to black on white if the visitor so desired, which suggests I may not be alone in not liking the stark contrast of white on black.
Re: OT: REALLY hate white text on black background
>For those of you who want to change WC's color from black text on white background to white text on black background just go to the top of your screen and click on Edit, Select All.
Re: OT: REALLY hate white text on black background
>One of the discussions I frequently have with a client when building a website is color palette. I don't much care if they want some odd (to me) combination, but if I find it garish or difficult to read, I'll counsel them strongly to make some other selections (sometimes just changing shades within the color family will do). Then I remind them of what their purpose in building a site is. Since most of the time it's for commercial reasons (marketing, although POS applies, as well), so a major raison d'etre it would seem a desirable goal would be to not drive the visitor away, and moreover, make it easy for the visitor to consume the product the site provides. That eliminates most of the choices discussed so far, as well as my personal worst, red text on black background.
Everyone's eyes are different, and in each individual they're not the same as they were twenty years ago. I can't process things as readily today as I did when I was 40 (incidentally, about the same time I started needing reading glasses). I can't tell you the number if times I've gone to a site where I needed to employ the trick of clicking and dragging to highlight text because the color combo was some ridiculous yellow on white. That may arguably be defensible as a design choice (esthetics)—but it's utterly indefensible as a usability choice.
Incidentally, I'd completely forgotten about all those green on black or yellow on black monitors we used back in the pre-DOS and DOS days. The world of color in modern computers has, at the same time, enabled enhanced usability, and egregious violation of good sense, as choices are made possible to those unworthy of the responsibility for good implementation.
Okay, I've gotten my rant off my chest.
Rod
Re: OT: REALLY hate white text on black background
>go to the link below & install the "Toggle Page Colors" button. Quickly toggles a page's color settings between the page defaults & your settings, in my case, black text with a white background. Reload page (F5) after each toggle to see the effect.
Dan
Re: OT: REALLY hate white text on black background
>real quick just hold left mouse button down and scroll over text Green back ground and white letters sometime i do that Also that is a way to copy the text Control C than past Control V into wordpad or email ?? ect.