Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Waterlox and/or chair finishing query

Posts

Waterlox and/or chair finishing query

#1

Waterlox and/or chair finishing query

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have 4 ladder back chairs to finish. It seems that durable and easy to repair are mutually exclusive finish attributes. I wondered about going for easy to repair for the chairs that will suffer abuse, like people putting feet on rungs and rubbing the finish off.

I asked before and Waterlox was recommended for chairs. I borrowed some and I am unimpressed with its properties. Maybe it is a shortcoming of my experience using it, or maybe it is just a poor finish. First misconcepton was its appearance was more a varnish than an oil. First disappointment was it took 4 coats ragged-on to build a bright finish on the cherry. It went on, and looked, more like thin varnish than oil, but it did dry quickly. It has very poor abrasion resistance. It is the least hard film I have ever experienced. The web site talks about using it for a floor where I don't see it would provide much more protection than a coat of wax.

Clearly I am missing something about this product. Why would one use it instead of varnish which builds quicker and is more durable?

I am inclined to spray the chairs with varnish or conversion varnish unless someone has a better suggestion.

Re: Waterlox and/or chair finishing query

#2

Re: Waterlox and/or chair finishing query

Bob Barkto

>I can't tell you if it's the right product for you but I'll pass along my observations having used it a bit.

It will take a week to cure hard in optimal conditions.

Add time if it's cool/humid or if ventilation is poor.

Once cured it's pretty durable. Certainly not as hard as conversion varnish, but it can be repaired/renewed much like an oil finish.

3-4 coats is about right to build a decent thin film.

As to appearance qualities.. I usually find it more appealing than a straight varnish since it is "oily" and gets into the wood a bit more than varnish does. But it still builds a film like varnish so it's not going to look like a pure oil finish would.

Hope that helps a little.

Re: Waterlox and/or chair finishing query

#3

spray them

John in NM

>In all honesty Bill, I think your expectations are going to be best satisfied by using conversion varnish or lacquer (I can't remember what you usually use) and your spray gun. Based on your complaints with Waterlox, I can't imagine any oil is going to work for you.

Re: Waterlox and/or chair finishing query

#4

Ellis Walentine

Perceptions and expectations

Ellis Walentine

>Bill, FWIW, I have used Waterlox extensively for several decades now and still admire its properties and ease of use. I agree that it is not abrasion resistant, and for that reason I would never recommend it for chair rungs that were likely to be subjected to abuse from shoes.

If, by bright, you mean that the film has fully developed to a consistent gloss, you got away easily. It usually takes me 8 or 10 coats for that. Tedious, perhaps, but relatively quick, easy, and dust free, and you can apply a couple coats per day. No wiping varnish will ever match the drying time of a sprayed conversion varnish or lacquer.

Waterlox is an excellent (IMO) coating when you want the look of a straight oil (dull, satiny sheen, smooth feel, low build) with the protection of a varnish (because that is what it is). You can get a low-luster, water-resistant finish in just a couple coats or build several more for depth and film thickness, but in no case will it ever have scratch resistance. It's kind of a homey, lived-in sort of finish rather than a hard-film, glassy looking finish like lacquer.

I think the confusion here may have to do with our definitions of "finish." If what you want is a hard coating, this one isn't for you. If you can get comfortable with a closer-to-the-wood look and feel, give it another look.

Ellis

Re: Waterlox and/or chair finishing query

#5

Ellis Walentine

One more thing

Ellis Walentine

>I usually rub out a Waterlox finish. It is a relatively high gloss from the can and the more you add, the more it needs a final rub of 0000 steel wool to tone down the sheen. Saturate the dull-looking steel wool scratches with a cotton rag slightly moistened with just a little Waterlox and wrung out. Extend it until the rag will deposit no more with continued rubbing.

It works for me, but we all have different expectations.

Ellis

Re: Waterlox and/or chair finishing query

#6

Similar results...

John in NM

>8-10 coats easily. Thats with the original sealer/finish though, I've tried the gloss product too, and it is slightly more viscous, lighter in color, and does build in about 4 coats. The marine varnish is very thick, and much more like spar varnish in every way.

Re: Waterlox and/or chair finishing query

#7

Re: Waterlox and/or chair finishing query

Howard Acheson

>What Waterlox product are you using? Waterlox is a brand name for a family of finishing products. Their non-poly products are their "Original" line of three finishes. Under this brand are their Gloss, Satin and their Sealer/Finish. Their Gloss used to be called "Gym Floor Finish" and the Satin is a very close formulation. The "Sealer/Finish" is primarily intended for as pre-coat underneath their Gloss or Satin. However, it is a much thinner and less durable and abrasion resistant finish if used alone. It would not be a choice for me for something like chair rails. However the other two products are phenolic resin/tung oil varnishes that are quite tough and were originally intended for floors. I have used both for high abrasion applications and found them quite satisfactory as a substitute for poly varnish.

Re: Waterlox and/or chair finishing query

#8

Waterlox sealer-finish, and a question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>First, let me thank you and others for the helpful information based on experience.

I was evaluating Waterlox "original" sealer finish. I was under the mistaken impression that this stuff would apply and look like linseed oil except it would dry faster.

Now that I am enlightened that these products are varnish of one sort or another, how are they different from either a urethane or alkyd varnish in terms of performance properties? Or to ask the question in an alternative way, if I have on hand both urethane and alkyd varnish and know how to successfully apply them, is there any reason to investigate Waterlox products? (I spray varnish and get a glass-smooth moderately close to the wood finish in two steps- thinned sealer coat and one top coat)

As far as the sometimes desirable "close to the wood" look I could not tell a difference in appearance between this Waterlox product and a thinned alkyd varnish.

Re: Waterlox and/or chair finishing query

#9

Ellis Walentine

Sealer/finish

Ellis Walentine

>Howard,

I use the term Waterlox to mean their sealer/finish, which is the newfangled name for their old "Transparent" product (IINM, perhaps reformulated by now for VOC compliance), in the old orange and white cans that we used twenty and thirty years ago. It was never chosen for its hardness or abrasion resistance, rather for its ease of handling and application and its similarities in thickness and appearance to pure long oil finishes like linseed oil and tung oil, which took forever to dry and which were not able to develop more than a modest build, poor abrasion resistance and a dull sheen. If you want to topcoat Waterlox sealer/finish with their own or another "finish" finish (to me, they all lie on the same continuum -- more resins, different properties), that's up to you, but if I want to develop hard film finishes, I start with them in the first place.

Regarding the reformulated product, I just stumbled upon a few baby food jars of the original "Transparent" that my dad sealed up in the mid '80s before he became incapacitated. When I get a chance, I will open one of these time capsules and try to discern differences in consistency, drying, working characteristics and finish film properties between that product and the finish/sealer they are selling now (for about eight times more money). Remind me.

Ellis

Re: Waterlox and/or chair finishing query

#10

Ellis Walentine

The difference...

Ellis Walentine

>...is that Waterlox handles better as a wipe-on finish, either with or without thinning, than other varnishes I've tried. My friend David Marks uses a product very similar to Waterlox in handling properties--General Finishes Seal-A-Cell--on much of his high-end custom work and has for years.

Handling is a subjective term. To me, it means the way the finish grabs after you apply it. Some varnishes grab so quickly that you can't smooth them or rub them evenly into/onto the wood before they start tacking up and becoming unworkable. Thinning often has no advantage.

Film properties are probably similar, mil for mil, to any alkyd varnish you might try, but I'm sure it depends on specific percentages and compositions of the resins and other components in them.

Ellis