Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

OT, Emergency room Proceedure? Long TIA

Posts

OT, Emergency room Proceedure? Long TIA

#1

OT, Emergency room Proceedure? Long TIA

Barry Irby

>My cousin, a young lady of 24 was helping her father on the family farm and fell off a tractor, face first onto a piece of equipment last Friday evening. (A long story and I am sparing you the details.) She ended up with a terrible cut right to the skull from her right eye up into her hair line and a branch of it out over her left eye. I met her family at the emergency room. They medivaced her in by chopper and I was closer than the family.

She spent hours in the emergency room and eventually they stitched her up. They asked us to leave the room at that point and a young lady spent two hours working on her. I told people the reason it took so long was that there are three layers in there they need to sew. (I learned this the hard way when a piece of wood flew off the lathe and gave me a third eye.)

Today, she went back to have the stitches out. The doctor said they had not stitched the two internal layers and had to open it up and stitch them and then redo the exterior, so it will be at least another week before the stitches can come out.

Does this seem acceptable to you? Why would they send her home for a week, allowing it to heal without having done the internal work? This was a teaching hospital and it was Friday night. I suspect the experienced doctors had the evening off and were not there to supervise.

Re: OT, Emergency room Proceedure? Long TIA

#2

Paul Kramer

Re: OT, Emergency room Proceedure? Long TIA

Paul Kramer

>Barry,

I don't usually respond to inquiries like this. But, this is an outrage. The family has plenty to be upset about. This was a facial wound in a young woman and should have been handled by a plastic surgeon, not a resident physician of questionable skills. There are instances where a resident in plastic surgery with plenty of experience under her belt could have done the job as well as a fully trained plastic surgeon. But this error was basic. The other layers of injury should not have been overlooked. At the minimum she is going to have to undergo another procedure at far greater cost and possibly have far more visible scarring. They should complain at the very least and see what can be done to correct the situation.

Paul

Re: OT, Emergency room Proceedure? Long TIA

#3

Re: OT, Emergency room Proceedure? Long TIA

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

>Sounds like a good trial lawyer needs to be hired. But it maybe an omen of what is to come in the future.

Re: OT, Emergency room Proceedure? Long TIA

#4

Re: OT, Emergency room Proceedure? Long TIA

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Barry,

First, I am so sorry to read about the girl's misfortune, and can imagine the grief and worry she and her family experience while all this is resolved. Its hard for me as a layman to make any rational judgment because I have not had the training and medical experienceas qualification.

I can tell a few first hand and uncomplimentary stories about emergency rooms in a couple local hospitals while I was on the tables. But, that wouldn't answer your concerns or be fair to all parties. Best thing to do now is get a few second opinions as to what must be done now to minimize physical scarring.

George

Re: OT, Emergency room Proceedure? Long TIA

#5

Thanks, and more

Barry Irby

>Let me add, she has first rate insurance and this is (at least I thought) the finest hospital in the area. No one on our side was in any hurry, she stayed here all night and was given any number of tests, incuding CAT scans etc.

What I did not mention was that her sister was also injured, but much less severely in the same accident. Their parents and I were there floating back and forth between the two girls when Dad disappeared. I inquired and learned that he had passed out standing next to the more seriously injered one. The ER staff scooped him up and ran an EKG and had him on an IV in no time. He was sheepish but uninjured. He had not had any supper and between the heat, the stress, and hunger got light headed and took an instant nap. So, at one point, we had three of them laid out in the ER.

Re: OT, Emergency room Proceedure? Long TIA

#6

Socialized medicine. . roll 'em in, push 'em out !

steve mackay

>

Re: OT, Emergency room Proceedure? Long TIA

#7

Re: OT, Emergency room Proceedure? Long TIA

John E in SC

>Barry,

First let me state this - please do not accept advice from ANYONE (me included) about medical problems over the internet. There are just too many complexities involved in medical care for anyone to give you appropriate advice on someone's medical care, particularly when they have not seen the patient. I'm an MD, and I could not even begin to tell you if the young lady's initial treatment was appropriate or not. If it wasn't, there likely won't be any permanent damage. But if she were my family member (or patient), I probably would see about getting her in with a plastic surgeon since she's a young woman with a large, visible problem. Going back through the ER will probably not give you the best results. She may well need an appointment with her family doctor to get a referral to a plastic surgeon, and that's a much better option that picking a name out of a phone book.

Just my 2 cents.

Good luck,

John

Re: OT, Emergency room Proceedure? Long TIA

#8

???

GolfSteve in Calgary

>How did you get "socialized" medicine out of Barry's story? IIRC Barry lives in Texas where, sterotypically, socialized medicine would not spring to mind as one of the causes of his niece's misfortune.

Re: OT, Emergency room Proceedure? Long TIA

#9

Re: OT, Emergency room Proceedure? Long TIA

Fred Davis

>Doctor John,

put a MD after your name , you earned it.

FredD

Re: OT, Emergency room Proceedure? Long TIA

#10

Re: OT, Emergency room Proceedure? Long TIA

Jim Follette in Fayetteville, NY

>Barry,

I read with interest your story and the concerns you expressed about the care your niece received. Although it is hard to piece this together without all of the facts, it is possible the care was appropriate: sometimes wounds that are "dirty" such as contaminated by dirt, manure?, etc. will not be closed completely so that if an infection develops it can easily drain outward rather that spread beneath tough layers like fascia (the layers under the skin you talked about). That may be why the under layers were not closed initially. Many times closures that require "plastic" type attention are deferred until they can be done in the operating room when the chance of infection has been reduced, and the results will be much better than if done "primarily". It is also possible that if the scarring is not significant your niece will not need plastic surgery at all, but scar revision of a well-healed wound would probably yield better results than plastic closure of a wound that might get infected. I hope that makes sense.

Jim Follette (retired anesthesiologist)