If I may........
Mark Goodall - ATL- tooljunkie
>Ken, you know me and you know I do this professionally and that I also have a web service that I sell to fellow woodworkers..... so you know I'm biased in what I'm going to say:
As bad as eBay is, I think there's some very good value, even today, with sticking with eBay. You use it to your advantage.
My recommendation is that you use both eBay and an independant website. Keep eBay and use it as a method of attracting new customers with your most popular items. But then also have a website that you can use to sell everything, both your popular items as well as the obscure. It's hard to beat the exposure that eBay gives you. And first time customers may feel more comfortable and safer with eBay protecting them. But as you attract people, they can be exposed to your website and may start buying direct once they have a relationship with you (I'm assuming that you'll likely have repeat buyers for your particular product).
I know that eBay frowns (putting it mildly) upon this, but I can tell you some real life examples of companies that started from scratch using eBay and came out of nowhere to become fairly sizeable vendors.
And with a website, you can expand your marketing to other very good areas. Again I can give you some concrete examples of people that have been very successful at that too.
So I say: Do both.
Happy Woodworking!