Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

out of square

Posts

out of square

#1

out of square

Bob in Green Bay

>I am building a TV stand that is essentially a box, more of a giant night stand really.

All is well, but now that I am in the preglue and drill stage, I can't quite achieve squareness. Its racked out of square by about 1/4" (checking for square bottom to top) which is enough to make me want to solve it since at a later time I will put front doors on it.

Basic construction is two sides about 17" wide and 28" tall. There is a dado in each side about 3" up from the bottom to receive the solid bottom - that is 36" across. I am using 1 1/4" stringers across the top at front and back that will be screwed, and plugged. A solid top will be affixed with cleats for more support.

Once flaw I will admit is that I used a cheap "wobbler" to cut the dado. Boy I hate that thing. The bottom and sides did not meet my expectation. I cleaned it up with a chisel best I could but in the end, hand planed down the thickness a bit(only at the ends) of the insert that goes into the dado to optimize the fit as it was a little tight. I fear this is where the problem lies but can not prove it to myself. I am thinking I could use one of those nice little router planes, but I am tooled up for the year.

Dimensions across the top and bottom measure the same by 1/32" and that is close enough I believe, just out of square at preglue

Any ideas to help me get this thing put together this weekend is greatly appreciated.

Bob in Green Bay - snow pending next week

Re: out of square

#2

short and long term fix

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Editorial: This is an example of case construction. It was decided 300 years ago how to do it best so that it will last and self square. If anyone is serious about wood working learn to make cases the best way, described in 3. and 4. It is not hard to do once you practice some. It can be done entirely with a saw and chisel with a bit more practice, or a router if you want to get one with the program.

1. put a back in it and use the tight fitting back to square it.

2. A simple dadoed shelf will not self-square a piece, nor is it an ideal joint for this application. Next best would be to make a rabbit on the end of the horizontal piece(bottom) and a dado on the vertical to accommodate the "tongue" of the bottom's rabbit. The shoulder of the rabbit will press against the side and provide self squaring.You must have a shoulder to self-square.

3. Best would be a sliding dovetail for the bottom. If you are serious about woodworking, and you seem to be from your questions, you need to learn to make this joint for it is the joint to use for fastening cases together. It really is easy to make with a router and not beyond most people's ability to make it by hand.The joint is especially easy to construct if you use a half tail (dovetail on one side of piece and leave board as is on the other). Then fitting can be easily accomplished by planing the flat side to loosen the joint. In any case there is so much glueing surface that this joint does not have to be highly precisely fit. I watched a profession cabinet maker adjust fit with a hand held router and nibble away at tight parts till the joint slid together with hand pressure, the ideal fit before gluing. (I used a chisel and angled guide block clamped to the cabinet side for nibbling the female part of the joint)

4. For the top, dovetailed rails set in from the top is best. Again the fit does not have to be all that precise because the joint gets covered up. The rails provide something to screw the top to.

Re: out of square

#3

Re: out of square

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>Bob -

It sounds like you're using a square to check for square. That's a recipe for frustration. Irregularities in the case parts, plus possible distortion from clamping, will give you false readings. Instead, measure the diagonals. If they're equal +/- 1/32 you're good. If they're not equal, move your clamps so they are closer to parallel with the long diagonal. Also, try to get the same clamping pressure on each clamp. That can make a big difference. Try a little experiment: put a square in one corner of the box and watch the reading as you vary clamping force on one clamp.

Ed

Re: out of square

#4

Carpenter's square

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Your case is an instance where you need to use a carpenter's square that you know to be a true 90. You can disassemble the shelf in the dado with a hammer and a block of wood and hit the block of wood all along the joint line above and below the shelf.

The crosspieces at the top of your cabinet may not be square on the ends, which would cause your cabinet to measure the same top and bottom but still not be square. The key to square cabinets is making square cuts on components in addition to good design. If you haven't already done so, true up your table saw. FOr a few dollars you can get highly accurate drafting triangles at most office supply stores that will help set your miter guage fence 90 degrees to your blade.

Lee

Re: out of square

#5

Agree!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I find a square useless for squaring cabinetry cases or drawers. The square technique assumes each side is perfectly straight, rarely the case with my projects. Every professional shop I have experienced uses measuring diagonals to determine squareness of a case.

The square has its utility in determining that the ends of components are square. What I find is if my ends are square and I used the best case construction techniques (dovetails) the cases are square when they are assembled and no diddling is required.

That said, assembly clamps can pull a case out (or into) square, so checking diagonals after clamping is a must. Of course with dovetail construction there is little clamping needed.

Re: out of square

#6

Ellis Walentine

About clamps, cauls and blocks

Ellis Walentine

>One of the reasons that Bessey-style cabinet clamps were invented was because their jaws stay square to their bars, so when you tighten them, the tip of the jaws don't pull the sides of the cabinet inward. I don't know what kind of clamps you're using, but pipe clamps are famous for this problem.

Here's where clamping cauls come in. In the old days, I used to have several bins under my assembly table for clamp cauls and blocks, with different sizes and shapes for every clamping occasion. I waxed them with paste wax to keep glue from sticking to them.

The idea of using cauls is to concentrate the clamping pressure only in a direct line with the joint. In other words, if you're making your carcase of 3/4" material, you want cauls that present just a 3/4" edge to the work, directly over the rabbet or whatever. That way, even a crooked clamp will only be applying pressure to the joint itself and not the surrounding area. Cauls also distribute the pressure longitudinally along the joint line, although you need to use some common sense to position enough clamps on the caul to distribute the pressure uniformly.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: out of square

#7

Beware....

Tony - Memphis

>It's very easy to get the Bessey out of alignment with the work and pull the pieces out of square. Don't assume that the squaring is automatic. Can't tell you how many times I've done this. I try and eyeball the bar against an edge of the pieces being clamped to make sure it is reasonably aligned.

Tony

Re: out of square

#8

Re: short and long term fix

Bob in Green Bay

>I thought of the back.....but this project is solid cherry. I am torn. I hate the thought of burning cherry for the back. It should probably be a nice plywood - but that seems sinful.

Other notes added - agreed.

My curse is not enough wood time so I fall out of practice all too soon.

Bob

Re: out of square

#9

back problems

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>One can get birch, as well as soft maple, stained to resemble cherry . Consider 1/4" birch plywood for a back. You said it will get drawers someday and then what ever is back there won't be seen. Should you want/need to use cherry it can be resawed from 4/4 lumber to double coverage. Or it can be resawed 1/16" and veneered on plywood for a back. I have done all the above kinds of backs and they have been successful.

Re: out of square

#10

YUP, that's What I Do

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>