>First, I must apologize for asking these OT questions. I have tried a couple of the DIY forums, but they are not near as competent as the folks here.
I am building a house in Anson, Texas (near Abilene). The only "code" that applies to us is the EPA....but, we are building the house to "code"...we just don't have to have inspections, etc.
My question is this:
Is there any benefit to insulating the underside of the roof? (I think that's called between the rafters ;-)
Pitch is 7/12, waferboard underlayment (7/16"), and final roof will be metal installed by "certified" installers.
If so, is there a "special" type of insulation to buy and any "special" installation instructions?
Again, I apologize for the OT...but...believe me, I WILL have some WW questions.....hopefully soon!
Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6
Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6
Guest
Re: OT - Insulating the under side of the roof?
Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6
>Terry, There is a OSB roof deck material called Solar-Board, which has foil on the underside, which is well worth the little extra cost of using.
The shinny face of foil will not radiate heat into the attic, so the heat build-up from the Sun on the shingles goes back up into the atmosphere above the house.
>.... but the only insulation I've seen and considered for the underside of the roof, are those plastic thingies that fit between the raters and sit a few inches below the roof sheathing. Think the idea is to create pocket of air from the bottom to the top to circulate the air and keep the sheathing (and therefore shingles) cooler.
Ah, heck..... I don't know what I'm talkign about. I just saw them in the store and thought they looked like a good idea. But I need to insulate with regular insulation in the attic first before I start messing with these extra methods :)
>Insulating the underside of the roof is only needed if the ceilings are not insulated in the rooms inside under that area of the roof. Insulating the roof still requires air flow under the roof sheating to prevent premature shingle failure. The palstig inserts Mark referred to are designed to space the fiberglass batt insualtion away from the under side of the roof sheating. Adding adequate ride and soffet opeingins to let the heat out will do far more good for your A/C bills and shingle life than insulating the roof sheating.
If the attic space under the roof is to be temperature controlled then you need to insulate the underside of the sheating.
>At least use the roof decking with the foil on the inside/attic face.
You can't have too much insulation, especialy in Texas. Start with a good R50 on the attic floor. If the foil reduces the attic temp by even 5 degrees, that means that here is less of a temperature difference between the attic and your air conditioned space. Less temp difference means less heat flow. Less heat flow means your A/C will not work as hard in the summer. The foil coated decking is an inexpensive option.
Make sure you have good attic ventilation. I used the ridge vents and accompanying ventilated soffits. DO NOT close up your attic in the winter time. There is always going to be some moisture in your attic, mostly from your living area. If you don't vent the attic the moisture will compromise your insulation thus reducing its effectiveness.
This a good question to address and you have some well made points from Mark and Ken, but they didn't go far enough.
In Texas I seriously doubt that 50 R in the attic space is as cost effective as a powered gable vent in one end of the attic and a standard gable vent in the opposite end.
In Texas , as here in Kansas , it is harder to get rid of heat buildup then it is to heat the same space in winter, plus air conditioning costs more then heating there.
In addition a enclosed soffit with enough soffit venting coupled with a continuous ridge vent or Turtle vents spaced 8 to 10 feet apart on both sides of the roof will give you more then adequate venting together with R-30 fibreglas insulation the attice space.
Regarding the insulation do not completely bock the lower and upper ends of the rafter run, there will be a flow of air from the soffit upwards , instead of a dead air space.
>I hate to give your "bad" news but you'll need 3 inspections for your house.
Mandatory County Code Inspections Began September 1, 2008
"Big changes are in effect for all homebuilders and remodelers who build in the unincorporated areas of the state. As of September 1, 2008, all homes constructed in unincorporated areas, or areas not subject to municipal inspections, must undergo a minimum of three inspections to ensure building code compliance.
It is imperative that you understand the new requirements and meet the mandated inspections. These new rules apply to any construction begun after September 1, 2008 that is located in an unincorporated area or other area not subject to municipal inspections."
More info can be found here, although it's rather slim info: http://www.texasbuilders.org/site/publisher/files/Mandatory%2520County%2520Code%2520by%2520Bill%2520Little.pdf
>I've had two recommendations for spray type radiant barrier insulation. One from the company that installed a new heat pump / air conditioner and one from a contractor that did a garage conversion for me. Neither does that type of work and neither gave a specific company as a recommendation. This makes me trust their opinion a bit more.
>Terry, as others have said, insulate above the ceilings of the rooms. During construction is your one chance to install the radiant barrier roof decking with thermal foil on the underside. Install continuous ridge vents on roof peaks combined with adequate soffit vents to allow for air flow. Do not allow insulation installers to obstruct the soffit vents. This system will give you significant energy savings as well as air flow through the attic.
>Some good advice here. As a Home Inspector I confront this situation all the time, however, I am in Virginia and you are in Texas. We have a mixed climate here and dominated by heating. I have not looked up your climate, but I suspect you are seriously Air Conditioning dominated. It is more important for you to reject summer heat gain than to save heat in the winter. (???)
The foil backed OSB is a good idea. But, the foil only works as long as it stays clean and shiny. It literally reflects the infra red wave length. If dirt settles on it, the effect is seriously cut. Therefore, the underside of the roof is a good location.
Next, you want to understand how the heat gets from the underside of the sheathing to the inside of your house. It radiates downward like a broiler. Therefore, the temperature of the air in between does not matter. (The sun broils us pretty effectively through millions of miles of vacuum that is very cold.) To significantly reduce your AC bill you need to lower the temperature of the surface on the bottom of the roof.
The fiberglass insulation on the ceiling is not as effective as it might be. The infra-red radiates deeply into the insulation. (Hold a piece of it to the sun. You can see through a fairly thick piece. So can the infra-red.)
The gable fans mentioned above have a problem. Many are fairly small and underpowered. Many are labeled something like 25,000 BTU. They can remove 25,000 BTU's an hour. The sun can deliver 1000 per SF. If you have a 1,000SF of roof, that's a million and hour. The fan is sucking wind. No wonder they run all day until after sundown when the roof cools off on it's own. Also, they do almost nothing to cool the underside of the sheeting. The rafters create "troughs" and are and the air flows under them, leaving the air next to the sheathing undisturbed. Tests show that the cooling effect on the sheathing is a degree or two at best. Thus the fans do nothing to reduce air conditioning or protect the roofing.
You mentioned metal roofing, so it should not be temperature sensitive.
What I would do is use the foil backed OSB. (Cheap) Be sure it is thick enough to provide the "nail holding" ability required by the roofing. Some metal roofing is prone to blow off.
I would install foil face foam sheets on the underside of the rafters and have soffit and ridge vents. That way air could circulate below the sweating and rise and escape out of the ridge. Then you could have gable vents to tent the attic space. This should keep the underside of the foil board in the attic much cooler and lower you AC bills.
You might be able to install the metal roofing on battens and create a ventilated air space above the sheathing, but this seems more difficult.
If you feel you must have fans, Put collar ties across the attic and create a fairly small triangular space at the peak and put fans in that, above the foam board.
If you decide to use the foam board, fasten it well to keep the wind from blowing it off in the attic.
They make a "bubble wrap" material that has foil in it. (Seen at the Borgs) The bubble wrap keeps the dirt off the foil and it should remain effective over time. Its expensive per square foot but might work for you. Probably tougher to handle than the sheets of foil faced foam.
>I have to disagree with Barry , I have had powered gable fans in every house I have lived in and they remove a tremendous amount of hot air from the attic space.
Of course like other approaches to this problem , one needs to use a little common sense when the fans are installed.
The venting fan is installed on the sunny side of the roof , mine is on the west for instance. The standard gable vent is on the opposite end of the roof in the shade , and cool air relatively speaking is drawn from that side thru the attic and is vented as hot air , a heat exchanger if you will.
Cooler air from under the eves also is pulled , rather then slowly rising which is the case without the fan.
All you need to understand how this works is be in front of one of these fans when it kicks on .
The fans on and off are controlled by the temperature preset for coming on and going off, they do not run all day as a rule unless you set the temp to low, just like a air conditioner.
The fans I have used over the years are not rated by BTU's , but by cubic feet per minute that is moved.
In hot weather country , like CA , Texas , Arizona , here in Kansas , they are relatively inexpensive to buy and install and run , they reduce the load on the house cooling system as do whole house fans which has not been mentioned here.
Any HVAC contractor can tell you what you need for your specific needs, in your area, which is much better , less mistake prone , then relying on untutored observations from different parts of the country and different climates.
Also in my shop I use one of these with a off/on switch to vent unwanted vapors from finishing , I just open the door slightly , turn on the fan which will open the door as far as is needed for makeup air.
The ceiling is my shop rises to a peak since I used scissors trusses , so the fan is placed high , about thirteen feet above the floor.
Once you have a chance to see a installation work like this , you may be tempted to get one. ;-))