Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

Posts

I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#1

I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

Don in Northern Arizona

>I received a DVD from George Vondriska's Woodworking Guild of America in the mail today. It says I must pay for the DVD or return it. Hey, I didn't ask for it! They provide a postage free envelope for the return, but they did not include my $20.00 minimum fee to insert a DVD, lick an envelope, walk to my mailbox, and lift its flag.

I find this more annoying than I probably should, but I consider this to be the worst sort of snail mail spam.

Has anybody received this? If I don't send back something I didn't ask for am I liable for the $12.95? Will I receive endless notices dunning me for it?

Don

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#2

Call or visit your

Gil Jones...Georgia

>local postmaster (with the DVD in hand), and ask their opinion.

Gil

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#3

Re: Call or visit your

Steve in Denver

>I rec'd the same thing. Completely pissed me off. Thought about snapping it in half and returning it. Ended up just sticking it in their prepaid envelope with a nasty note.

Reminded me of the days when I made the mistake of joining Handyman Club, I think that was the name. Couple months into it I started receiving books and DVD's unsolicitied.

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#4

Re: Call or visit your

Thomas S Stockton

>Don

Don't waste your time you don't have to send back unsolicited stuff. There's some fine print in their blurb someplace. I have no idea why they want them back seems like if there copying them in bulk the return shipping is about the cost of making them.

Tom

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#5

Steven Antonucci

Pretty sure you can thank them for the gift

steve antonucci

>They know it's yours the minute that they do it. If it comes through US mail, you are under no obligation to buy it even if you decide to keep it.

If you want to really hose them, watch it and keep it, but fill the return envelope with lead shot and send it out. They have no way that I am aware of to trace it back to you, and it will cost them a lot more than the stamp...

I don't personally view this as being that offensive, but it all comes down to how clearly they represent your obligations. It's a marketing ploy, and I guess that they can mail them out cheaper than the cost of a magazine...

Steve

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#6

Right On, Steve

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Steve,

When I feel especially devilish I always try to send a fully filled pre-paid envelope back to the sender of unsolicited mail. I like to include other junk mail received that day, old newspapers, plastic lids, and flattened tin cans especially fragrant unrinsed sardine cans, and, most recently, political flyers. It makes me feel better.

George

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#7

Keep it. The included instructions on the...

Craig Daymon

>return envelope say that you are welcome to keep it. It requests that you send it back if you are not interested so they can send it on to someone that might.

You had me all fired up because receiving unsolicited products in the mail with the expectation of payment is one thing that makes me quite mad. (And I have recently received the DVD, but hadn't read the material yet.) Time-Life did this to me with their books and I told them I was keeping it and they wouldn't get a penny.

George does a reasonably nice job of requesting that you send it back and does provide you the mechanism to do so, but he also says you are welcome to keep it.

From the return envelope instructions:

"Because you didn't ask for this special DVD, you're under no obligation to do anything and could consider it a free gift, but returning it will give another craftsman the same opportunity to increase their success in the shop!"

He seems to have fairly done what was required. I think it's unfair to bash him in this case. (Had he insisted on payment without saying that I could keep it, I would be there right with you.)

-Craig

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#8

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the ma

Fred Davis

>Reply to George ,

that this was unsolicited mail , you have no legal obligation to him or his scam AND you will forward the particulars to your state Attorney Generals Fraud Squad located most likely in the Department of Consumer Affairs.

That's one of the beauties of WoodCentral, it gets around fast.

FredD

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#9

Re: Right On, Steve

Fred Davis

>Dany it George, you and my wife are on the same wavelength ;-))

FredD

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#10

Re: Keep it. The included instructions on the...

Fred Davis

>Craig ,

Since I have not recieved one of these "it will give another Craftsman the same opportunity to increase their success in the shop" chance of a lifetime , if you order right away offers, sniff, I can't understand why it is a free unconditional offer , when Don said they wanted 12.95.

But I guess it falls under some guy's contention on this list some time ago , that it is only a carefully worded claim ;-))

FredD

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#11

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the ma

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>I received this DVD, but it said that I didn't have to return it even if I chose not to pay for it. Actually, I thought it was a great tutorial on cabinet making, and I could be interested in getting more, but I couldn't tell what the next ones would cost. If they would have simply told me that I would be getting more offers at such and such a price for each one, I may have signed up.

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#12

Moses Yoder

you can keep it, but

Moses Yoder

>Keeping something I didn't pay for just didn't seem right to me. I sent mine back. I just deducted that time from my usual time spent watching television, so I actually profited from the exchange.

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#13

Jesper, Denmark

Re: you can keep it, but

Jesper, Denmark

>Moses, You are a saint.

This type of stuff and unsolicited annoying sales call by telephone - especially when they dont't introduce themselves in a manner you can actually understand - automatically are open to whatever irrevent replies that happen to surface on that day.

Phone calls that start with a question automatically get the fast click.

Our paper recycle bin is VERY close to the mailbox!

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#14

the fast click

John K Jordan

>All of my unsolicited material goes into the trash. I'm also a proponent of the "fast click" which I also execute if upon answering there is a pause which usually precedes a recorded message. If it's a an actual person who doesn't respond quick enough, they'll call back. Or not.

JKJ

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#15

As Emily Litella says, "Never mind." Sorry George.

Don in Northern Arizona

>Typically, I did not read enough of the letter attached to the envelope. It says, "Because you didn't ask for this special DVD, you're under no obligation to do anything, and could consider it a free gift, but returning it will give another craftsman the same opportunity to increase their success in the shop." I'll keep it and watch it.

I apologize to George V. and WWGOA, for misreading their solicitation.

Don

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#16

Reminds me ...

Mike Farinella

>of that American Woodworker book sent to me unsolicited a few years ago. I kept the book (quite nice actually), canceled my subscription and boycotted Rockler. I also remember someone from AW got on this forum and proclaimed the invoice sent with the book was not an invoice. Somehow, I think they learned a lesson.

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#17

Nice Touch!

Joe Pack

>I LOVE the sardine can idea. Thanks for the tip!

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#18

Hmmm, I wonder

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I used to do the same thing, but I would leave my name on the stuff I sent back. It got me off a lot of mailing lists.

I wonder if you could tape their postage paid envelope to a large box, filled with sawdust and send it back to them. The postage would kill them and you could get rid of excess sawdust. I'd love to hear the discussion in the mail room when they open a large box of sawdust. Heee Hee Hee! ;)

lee

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#19

Ric Taylor

Send Him My Address... I Want a Free DVD

Ric Taylor

>

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#20

Ellis Walentine

That was Woodworker's Journal

Ellis Walentine

>American Woodworker was never affiliated with Rockler.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#21

Wow, people's reactions to this are fascinating

Kelby

>The original question is an easy one -- you don't owe the guy anything, apart from whatever moral obligations you may feel.

But the fascinating thing is how viscerally people react to a guy who is sending out free woodworking DVDs with a polite request that, if you want to keep it, send him $20. (Which you obviously don't have to do.)

I don't like people who waste my time with telemarking and spam. But I probably wouldn't put a woodworking DVD in the same category.

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#22

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the ma

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

>I keep anything sent unsolicited. And I love junk mail that has a prepaid postage return envelope. I cram them so full of everything including somone elses junk mail and send it back. Hits them in the pocketbook. And yes I know "What I Have In My Wallet".

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#23

You owe no apology to anyone.

Joe Pack

>The sender of the DVD is playing on YOUR sense of obligation. He did NOT send the DVD to you with the intent of sharing wisdom with you, but to make a profit. Even though the message indicates that you could "...consider it a gift..," the sender plays on your sense of obligation and morality because "...returning it will give another craftsman the same opportunity to increase their success in the shop." This message implies that if you don't do the "honorable" and return something you never asked for, someone else will not be given the opportunity to do the receive the same "honor bound" solicitation.

The DVD may be very good and worth every dime. If it is, and if you would have ordered it anyhow given a chance to preview it, then send in the cash. If it is good, but you would NOT have ordered it even after previewing, keep it as the gift it was stated to be. I would NOT simply return it. Returning the DVD would only encourage the same person to continue the same kind of advertising...making people feel guilty if they don't buy the DVD and/or putting the onus on them to hassle with something they did not ask for.

Maybe I'm just too cynical, but I despise this kind of advertising. I keep the nickel sent by Acme Charities. I keep the dime sent by Acme Childrens' Hospital. I keep the $2.50 check sent by the Acme Cancer Research Foundation. I keep the free calendars, Christmas cards, recipe books and any other "free" stuff sent in solicitations from any source, regardless of the charity, because their "lay on the guilt" solicitations are inappropriate.

I do send a nice "Thank you" back to them in their postage paid envelope, with a polite note that I do not like their methods.

Keep the DVD. Send a "Thank you. Throw away the guilt the sender tried to lay on you.

Re: I got an unsolicited woodworking DVD in the mail.

#24

What other sites have to say...

Joe Pack

>Check out what other sites say about this advertisement wor WWGA...

http://lumberjocks.com/topics/4941

http://www.sawmillcreek.org/showthread.php?t=93737

I'm retired and bored, so sign me "Don Quixote, Tilter of Windmills and Occupied Outhouses."