>Hi - I'm considering ways to insulate the pull down stair of my attic. Given the high cost of heating my home, I'm trying to do everything I can to reduce my energy bill (and its the green thing to do!). I've seen some plans on the internet for building a box enclosure out of rigid foam insulating board. Has anyone tried this and has it worked for you. Has anyone come up with their own ingenious idea on how to do this.
>In most houses far more heat is lost through air infiltration than through direct radiation. The first thing to do is make sure it's weatherstripped well enough to seal tightly when closed. Tighten up the house first, then worry about adding insulation. A box with a drop-in piece of rigid foam over the hatch won't work well enough to pay back unless it also stops any air exchange.
>I put one of those stair units in my shop this past spring, and the only way I can see to insulate it would be to put the insulation on the room side. Depending on how much R value you're going for, that means the insulation panel would extend by whatever thickness down from the ceiling.
This said, here are a couple ideas for you. One would be to make a lightweight frame, say 1x4s on edge, around a foil-faced R-max panel of whatever thickness. I think standard 1" is about R-9, so three thicknesses would be three times that. You could cover the room side of the panel with upholstery fabric or you could veneer over the face of the insulation if you want to get fancy. Make the whole unit several inches wider and longer than the stairway opening so it seals against the ceiling. Hinge one end of the unit with butt hinges to the header and use some heavy rare-earth magnets to hold the other end closed against the ceiling. Pull it down and it would hang vertical while you are using the steps.
Or, maybe you could forget the frame and just make an upholstery cover for a stack of R-max panels and stick that to the ceiling with magnets.
>>...more heat is lost through air infiltration than through direct radiation.
I think this is true. But once the opening is sealed so there is no cold/warm air exchange, one way to take care of radiant heat loss in a thin space is with multiple layers of super-thin foil insulation.
A friend once worked at a magnetics company that produced superconducting magnets that worked at extremely cold liquid nitrogen and helium temperatures. To insulate equipment they used many layers of foil-backed mylar, each just 0.0001" thick (see thread below) - so thin you can see a light through it. This stuff is very much like the space blankets sold for emergency use, but not as thick and durable. He salvaged some 15' long bundles stripped from a big tank and we used it for years for insulation. Wrap a little around your arm and you can instantly feel the reflected heat. He once sewed some layers into a blanket but it was unusable - said it was so hot you couldn't stand it!
The point is, multiple layers of aluminized mylar make a very good radiant heat reflector. My stash is getting low after 20 years, but if you can find something a similar foil and sandwich a stack above the plywood and below the steps it may do the job. At the time Mark Goodall was looking for such foil and I wrote the message in the link I found a few possible sources with Google.
>The problem with trying to insulate a pull-down attic door, is that you can't put anything directly on top of the door as it will mess up the function of the folding ladder. In fact, the ceiling panel (door) isn't really a door at all, it's just a panel that is attached to the underside of the folded ladder.
However, you can put another plywood door hinged the opposite way (upward) with insulation on top of that.
While a picture is worth a 1000 words, I'm going to have to try text for now:
>The company I work for makes insulation blankets for cryogenic applications. They are made of multiple layers of aluminized mylar with remay (spun polyester) between them. An 80 layer blanket is under 3/8 inch thick. In a vacuum they are rated at an R value of 5000 per inch. I've managed to snag a few rejects. They made a dandy compact freezer chest for my buddy's boat. I'm sure the stuff would work very well on a hatch, but they're hard to come by unless you want to spend a lot more money than the heating fuel would cost.
>I have done several of these and showed a freind how and he has done several more.
The only problem I see with Elis' approach is the weight of the added insualtion may cause the door to droop open slightly. ANY crack around the door will negate the value of the insulation. Trying to weather strip these usually causes them to hang open also.
As mentioned above, this is a two part problem. Lack of insulation and air leakage. And, after a house is reasonbley well insulated, the main heat loss is from air leakage. Warm air rises and escapes through the ceiling and cold air comes in down low, through the floor to replaces it. (the stack effect)
The box idea shown in the link above is a good approach. Look at the idea of increasing the height of the framing around the opening. You may be able to install three sides permanently and make the end at the top of the steps hinged so it will lay down and give you easy access to the attic. Then put a hinged, insulated, weighted lid on the box or frame. The lid can be counter-balanced with a weight and pulley and there could be a prop behind it.
You can make the box "longer" and do not hinge the end. The extra length allows you to stand inside the box and then step over.
Or, space permitting, you can build the box on one piece and hinge it along one edge.
We also did version where it slide back inside a set of "rails".
The door panel may have enough space for 1/2" or 3/4" foam panel.
Think of this as a Hat.
My friend noticed his hall was distintly warmer and is sure it was worth the time and effort.