Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Idea approval/modification?

Posts

Idea approval/modification?

#1

Idea approval/modification?

Terry Alexander

>I am building my new house in West Texas. We will have 2 supports in the front facing east and 5 support posts on the back porch facing west. I am thinking about.....

Using 2 2/8" oil field pipe. Wrap this pipe in a "square" in 3/4" plywood. Wrap the plywood with 1/4" mahogany wood. Stain the wood and then cover with a marine varnish.

Ideas and modifications appreciated. I only want to do this once.

As always...thanks in advance.

Terry Alexander

Re: Idea approval/modification?

#2

Re: Idea approval/modification?

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>The plywood/mahogany seems like a good idea. I don't have a clue about the pipe. That strikes me as very structural, and I would think you should use whatever the AHJ (authority having jusrisdiction—whoever interprets your local building code) specifies for such structural elements. I know from my experience with large antenna arrays and support masts that what once seemed like a good idea for a mast (schedule 40 water pipe) turns out not to have any structural rating at all. That oil field pipe you reference may not have any, either. I suggest you make some inquiries about that aspect.

Rod

Re: Idea approval/modification?

#3

Re: Idea approval/modification?

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Consider using 5/4 ipe instead of the ply/mahogany combo. It takes stain and spar varnish well, but doesn't need either, and it'll last forever, even in West Tejas.

Clint

Re: Idea approval/modification?

#4

Re: Idea approval/modification?

Barry Irby

>You did not tell us what these posts will support. A porch roof? One story above? Two?

Is west Texas Arid? Very dry? I ask because such posts here in Virginia would rot in a few years, unless the "inside" wood were at least as decay resistant as the mahogany. Wrapping rot prone wood inside good wood is like wrapping a fish in a newspaper.

I have no doubt the Ipe suggested above will hold almost any thing you want to stack on it and not decay for a long long time.

I know nothing about the pipe. Not many oil fields in these parts.

Use the metal column bases to help keep the bottoms dry and rot free.

Re: Idea approval/modification?

#5

Re: Idea approval/modification?

GalenV

>I assume these pipe columns are 96" tall. Not sure how much load you expect each to carry. If columns are supporting wood roof structure the compressive load on wood is about 625 lbs/ sq. in. so a metal cap plate needs to be of sufficient size and thickness to distribute the weight over the wood beam. A base plate is needed to anchor at the bottom concrete base.

Not sure what oil field pipe thickness is but maybe it is 2" standard pipe that is 2 3/8" OD. The pipe is probably API rated for pressure and not as a structural support. Water pipe is typically A120 and it too is only pressure rated. A53 Grade B is a structural pipe similar to A36 structural steel for calc purposes. Normal home support jacks are 3" OD structural tube. The 2 3/8 OD could bow and not be as stable as it should be (roof sag) Even if you used 2 1/2 pipe that is 2 7/8" OD it would probably support 1700 pounds for the 96" height.

Retired and don't have my AISC Structural steel manual anymore to do the real math. Beside manual has load tables for columns so no need to calc most.

Try to keep the slenderness ratio under 120 for column kl/r=120.

K is end fixture and would be 1.0 if anchored both ends.

l is length of column in inches.

r is raduis of gyration of the pipe column. Probably close to 0.95 for 2 1/2" pipe.

2 1/2 std weight pipe has an area of around 1.7 sq. in.

if you keep slederness ratio around 120 you can use about 1000 pounds per sq in of column area. That is why I say 1700 pounds or 1.7 x 1000

Probably more than you wanted to know but your pipe columns are too slender in my mind. The pipe probably has a bow in it to start with.

Re: Idea approval/modification?

#6

Re: Idea approval/modification?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Terry, don't know how much you would save using the oil pipe vs standard jack posts. When I remodeled my front porch on my 120+ year old home, I used the standard jack posts. I set them on 2 stacked, square sections of 3/4" thick plywood and also have the same plywood on the top of the posts. Then I covered them with 3/4 thick western red cedar, with 45 degree miters on the edge of the cedar. The plywood gave me a good nailing area at the top and bottom, and the mitered edges gave a full size beam appearance. I nailed the miters with finishing nails - as the cedar is the "rough sawn" I didn't have to fill the holes. The jack posts have the real advantage of adjusting the heights to level whatever you are supporting. I did this work 10 - 15 years ago and have had no issues yet. If you wanted you could use IPE, locust etc. for the outside covering. I would be hesitant to use a plywood "veneer" construction outside.

Re: Idea approval/modification?

#7

Terry again - more info on oil field pipe

Terry Alexander

>I really appreciate all the responses.

I did go look at floor jack posts and one gave the properties as:

11 gauge, wall thickness at .120, OD 3"

So, I got out my trusty calipers and measured the pipe.

OD is 2.365 and thickness is .20.

For those of you not familiar with drilling, this pipe is used to drill as deep as 6,000 ft.

Having said/typed all of that, does it sound structural (is that a word?) enough?

TIA

Terry Alexander

Re: Idea approval/modification?

#8

Re: Terry again - more info on oil field pipe

Dan Donaldson

>The main question is what your local building inspector thinks.

Re: Idea approval/modification?

#9

Re: Terry again - more info on oil field pipe

Curly Smith

>Are you going to x-ray and inspect the pipe? I'm assuming that it's used, otherwise there wouldn't be any significant price differential since you buy steel by weight, but you don't know how it's been used. You don't know if it's been over-stressed, which is why you need to x-ray it, or if it has any deep internal corrosion or erosion pits, which is why you need to have it internally inspected.

Used oil field tubing is good for fences, gates, pole barns, and other non-load bearing applications. It should not be used for structural steel.

Re: Idea approval/modification?

#10

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Barking up the wrong tree...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Terry, I have to agree with a few of the others here. I bet that oil-field pipe, if used to drill to 6,000' feet is plenty strong for that application, and would work fine. But that's not the point. The point is that your local inspector likely doesn't know squat about metallurgy or structural engineering. All he knows is what is acceptable from his books and tables. The question for you is: is it worth it in terms of time and money to prove to him that oil-field pipe would work as structural supports? Considering that a standard lally column isn't all that expensive, and the hourly rate of a structural engineer is pretty high, I doubt this is a battle you really want to choose, and it may cause the inspector to dig deeper and get picky in other areas.

I've seen plenty of inspectors that don't know what they're doing, but they do know they have the authority to halt your project...

Jason

Re: Idea approval/modification?

#11

I agree...

John in NM

>The State of New Mexico required me to get engineering approval for a stone stem wall foundation. If I'd used cinder block I wouldn't have needed engineering. Had nothing to do with structural capabilities, had everything to do with what inspectors were "used" to seeing.

I've used jack poles, but I don't believe they are intended for perminent installation. Check your codes before installing them, it may have just been a local thing.

If you want to pass with no trouble from the local AHJ, use pressure treated posts and leave it at that, its what they're accostomed to dealing with and they won't give it a second glance.