Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Tall clock design options - opinions?

Posts

Tall clock design options - opinions?

#1

Tall clock design options - opinions?

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Hi, all -

Christmas is coming, and I want to make something special for my inlaws (I seem to make a lot of stuff for them, hmm...). About a year and a half ago, they remodeled their family room. Tore down the paneling they'd put up about 30 years ago - some old rough pine boards from a barn in Maine. Gave me the wood, which has been sitting stickered ever since. I want to make something for them, for Christmas, and to celebrate their 40th anniversary this year. I was originally thinking blanket chest, but they've got a bunch of nice antique ones already, and not much floor space left for one. Then I got to thinking... Clock.

So, after some googling, I found Norm's Tall Pine Clock. Definite possibility. Start in to thinkin' s'more, and remember a clock Steve Shanesy made years ago - a Curly maple Shaker Tall Clock, attributed to Brother Benjamin Youngs. (PW's site isn't showing the image now - here's one, painted). So, now I'm in a quandry - which one to make?

I think either will fit their decor, which is an eclectic mix of antique styles, but nothing too formal. I really don't want to paint, since the pine's special to them (they drove to pick it up and hung it themselves). The Norm clock looks nice in pine; I'm not sure if the Shaker clock will.

Anyone have any sage words for me? Pretty please?

Scott

Re: Tall clock design options - opinions?

#2

Re: Tall clock design options - opinions?

mdclor

>FWIW, my preference in design is Norm's. The shaker it too stark for me, but that is just my taste.

Merle

Re: Tall clock design options - opinions?

#3

Re: Tall clock design options - opinions?

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>This might look good in barnwood if you do a pendulum movement. Beveled glass in the door. Case 42h x 12w x 7 1/2d

Clint


img

Re: Tall clock design options - opinions?

#4

Re: Tall clock design options - opinions?

Curly Smith

>If you like Mission Style furniture:

How to Make a Plain Oak Hall Clock


FYI - the plan seems to be excerpted from "Mission Furniture How to Make It" (Part Two, page 10 by my copy)

Re: Tall clock design options - opinions?

#5

Re: Tall clock design options - opinions?

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Presumably you are going to plane the wood rather than leave it rough. If that is the case then I think the Norm Style clock would fit in better. As others have said, teh Shaker style you showed is a bit severe on the eyes. Just my 2 cents worht.

Lee

Re: Tall clock design options - opinions?

#6

Go Thru Merrit Clocks in Douglasville

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Scott,

I like Norm's design also. However, you should visit your neighbors in Douglasville and go thru their clock museum. It will give you a million ideas. Better yet, take your inlaws thru it, and have them pick out a basic design for you to work with.

George

Re: Tall clock design options - opinions?

#7

Re: Tall clock design options - opinions?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I don't care for the clock of Norm's that you show. It looks like a cheap imitation of a high style clock. If you copy Norm's off the shelf moldings, it will look even more like a hack job. Much better would be Norm's Dominy clock, which was designed for soft wood. It has a little more interest than the Shaker clock.

If the Dominy clock interests you, you might try to get Hummel's "With Hammer in Hand" from the library. It has about 20 Dominy clocks illustrated. The small waisted clocks are hardwood (walnut cherry mahogany); the pine clocks have straight sides and more subdued decoration.

Re: Tall clock design options - opinions?

#8

If you're taking votes?

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I guess I'm out.

I really like the Shaker clock, having seen it in several publications previously.

Norm's clock doesn't do anything for me. Neither does the movement, an obvious 'early Nahm' drop in.

The Colonel's suggestion to go visit the museum/maker's site seems a really good one to me. And involving the recipients makes for a built in excuse for a late delivery. I'm just sayin'...

Re: Tall clock design options - opinions?

#9

Thanks, guys, and more info...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Wow - thanks for all the input, everyone! FWIW, I looked at the Dominy clock, and like it, but (a) don't know if I could swing the curved molding, and (b) don't kow how it'll look without paint (and, yes, I'm planing down the pine). That's the one advantage to Norm's tall pine clock - I can see how it looks finished.

And I'm planning on getting the movements (a mechanical one, not a lil' quartz one) from Merritt's. Which is about 2 or 3 miles from my house. :^D They're great in there.

I need to enlist my wife's opinion, but she's not to keen on me taking on any projects right now, so I'm a little hesitant...

Thanks for the help, and I welcome more opinions!

Scott

Re: Tall clock design options - opinions?

#10

And the winner is...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>...the Dominy clock. Wife-approved, order placed. Woot!

Scott, weaving Shaker tape tonight

Re: Tall clock design options - opinions?

#11

Just Don't Knock It over!.

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Scott,

I saw that show and remember the clock. I don't see how you can go wrong. Good Choice. Post a pix when you get it finished.

George