Actually, can happen
Bill Houghton, rainy in Sebastopol, CA
>If a thermostat's not opening at all (sticking shut), and you're flogging the engine hard enough, you can get up to very high temps very quickly. I've had it happen, followed by the same pattern of events Fred describes. I don't think it's common - the bimetal spring more often fails open, or opens slowly rather than not at all - but it does happen.
Thermostats are cheap and, in most cars, a fairly simple replacement - regardless of whether or not the sending unit's bad, replacing the thermostat makes sense, even with the little hassle of losing some coolant.
Sending units, on the other hand, get hidden in the most inaccessible places, so cleaning up the connection and ensuring that it's right may well use up some of your inventory of bad words.
Bill, spent half a morning while camping with the family years ago replacing an oil pressure sending unit that the maker had decided to put behind the exhaust manifold and which, when it began leaking, spewed oil all over the hot manifold, scaring the daylights out of his sweetie (and, well, yes, himself).