Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

OT - Garden Apartment Wall furnace

Posts

OT - Garden Apartment Wall furnace

#1

OT - Garden Apartment Wall furnace

Steve Silca

>Does anyone have any experience with a wall furnace or general HVAC experience? I am finishing a basement level garden apartment that's about 550 square feet It will basically have two large rooms plus a bathroom. Rather than installing a furnace with ductwork and returns and all that work, i am looking into the possibility of a 25,000 or 40,000 btu wall furnace.

I have never even seen these things before. Does this seem like a good option to anyone? Can I mount it in the wall and just have vents for the intake and output, or does it have to be mounted on the outside of a wall? Does it need to have a vent to the outside like a normal furnace?

SS

Re: OT - Garden Apartment Wall furnace

#2

Re: OT - Garden Apartment Wall furnace

Fred Davis

>Steve ,

They started phasing out wall furnaces quite awhile ago, for some obvious reasons connected to improper installation , blocking of the furnace with household items, children getting burned when touched them and bad venting etc.

If you do opt for this type of heat, besides getting a licensed HVAC contractor to do the work , it is required code wise to have a Mechanical permit.

The framing has to be exposed and the top double plate cut out and a metal chase installed for the class "B" vent to pass thru the wall , and if you go to the outside , if the local ordinence allows it , you will need to use standoffs , staying away from windows and so on.

This is a job that should never be attempeted by DIYer's regardless of how many who will tell you they did it and got away with it.

You owe it to your family's health and saftey to use a contractor and have the result inspected and signed off by a Building official.

There are at least three or four equally efficent and considerably less dangerous methods of heating your basement.

FredD

Re: OT - Garden Apartment Wall furnace

#3

Re: OT - Garden Apartment Wall furnace

Kneale Brownson dreaming of snow in N. MI

>Like Fred, I'd stay away from a wall furnace. For what the professional installation will cost you, you could get electric baseboard heaters. Lots quieter, more even coverage, and possibly cheaper to operate than anything requiring a fire.

Re: OT - Garden Apartment Wall furnace

#4

Ours works fine

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>We have an electric one in the sunroom. It was here when we moved in 12 years ago. It looks like a large window mounted AC unit, but it goes through the wall and it provides AC during the summer and heat in the winter. Like some AC units, it has a switch to either bring in fresh air from otuside, or recirculate the inside air. It's 240V but I've seen newer smaller ones that are 120V. I don't know it's BTU or anything like that and it's between 12-20 years old.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT - Garden Apartment Wall furnace

#5

Re: Ours works fine

Fred Davis

>That is a good unit , attested by the fact that nearly all motels use one, not nearly the fire hazard as a gas fired unit.

FredD

Re: OT - Garden Apartment Wall furnace

#6

Re: OT - Garden Apartment Wall furnace

Howard Norman

>Where are you located? Do you need A/C also? If you need both the electric units like Mark G has would be my choice. If you need only heat that a gas unit is probable a better choice, but I could be wrong depending on energy costs in your area. In general I would agree that a gas heating unit is not the normal DYI job.

Re: OT - Garden Apartment Wall furnace

#7

Re: Ours works fine

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

>Mark, that unit is called a 'heat pump' . a combination of a/c and reversed a/c fluid flow and electric heat strips for the winter heating; but is an a/c in the summer.

Re: OT - Garden Apartment Wall furnace

#8

Re: OT - Garden Apartment Wall furnace

GalenV

>As far as I know the Empire wall furnaces are still sold. I put the LP version in my aunt's lake side cottage. It did have the optional blower to cover about a 24 foot square cottage in Iowa, but she did not use it in the dead of the winter. Simple installation and all done per manufactures spec but always a do it yourself in my family.

Being an apartment and todays safety logic I agree you need to have installtion done by certfied HVAC contractor.

On the flip side my mother has the electric heating and cooling unit through the wall that was added when a family room additon was put on. It just never had the fan to move air so was probably a poor choice for home configuration.

Re: OT - Garden Apartment Wall furnace

#9

Re: OT - Garden Apartment Wall furnace

Justin Szeliga

>The basic difficulty with using the wall furnace as I see it is you have 3 rooms & they are a 1 room heater, or heat/ac as has also been mentioned(a PTAC). The energy must be moved to the space needing it & those units only heat one room. I would guess you want heat with the efficiency of oil or gas as opposed to the cost of electric heat. I see heating a place as a trade off on what you will pay for the heat & the heating system. It costs more up front to do a hydronic system (hot water baseboard) but is the most efficient (cheapest) in use. Then forced hot air, as you mentioned wanting to avoid, which also uses space for ducting. Then there is the fast, simple, cheap to install but more expensive to run, electric baseboard. That costs more in use. A talk with a couple of heating contractors will help get an idea of what is out there & how to proceed.

Peace

Justin