Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

OT: Computer croaked, help!

Posts

OT: Computer croaked, help!

#1

OT: Computer croaked, help!

Ken Platt (North Granby, CT)

>Folks - We had a "power blink" while I was working on my computer, and of course the computer shut off. That happens every so often up here at the far end of the power lines. however, when I went to restart, the computer doesn't get beyond powering up the fans. No POST, in fact nothing at all on the monitor. No beeps either. There is a brief lighting of the LED on the DVD drive, and a yellow LED on the front lights up for a while. That LED is next to a little icon that looks like a squat cylinder, but I don't know what it indicates -maybe the HD?

I've fiddled around with computers a fair bit, built a few over the years, so I'm familiar with the innards. However, I have no idea how to even start troubleshooting when the system doesn't even get to a POST or putting anything on the monitor, but does have power. (And, yes, the monitor works fine with another computer).

Can anyone suggest where to start? Besides just buying a new one....Thanks,

Ken

Re: OT: Computer croaked, help!

#2

Quick Guess

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Well, it's not the hard drive.... if it was the motherboard would sense a problem and say "Can't find boot device" or something similar.

It's not the CPU..... in all my years I've never seen a CPU fail.

So I'm going to guess it's either the Power Supply ($30) or the motherboard ($more). It's likely the PS, as they are designed to output both 5V and 12V and it's very common to have one circuit blow while the other is okay, based on what you said happened. A Power Supply tester (special device) would likely show you have lost either the 5V or 12V.

IF you were close by I'd lend you my tester, but you can buy a Power Supply for less money than the tester, so if I were you I'd get a new Power Supply before I bought a tester.

This is one of the reare times that I would recommend the guys at Best Buy (etc) because if you buy the power supply from them they'll probably test/install it for a few dollars more while you're in the store.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT: Computer croaked, help!

#3

Agree...

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

>The same thing happened to one of my computers: wouldn't post but the fans would run. A new power supply fixed it.

Re: OT: Computer croaked, help!

#4

Lee Gordon

Re: OT: Computer croaked, help!

Lee Gordon

>"This is one of the rare times that I would recommend the guys at Best Buy (etc) because if you buy the power supply from them they'll probably test/install it for a few dollars more while you're in the store."

I agree with Mark. I highly recommend the Geek Squad guys at the Best Buy in West Hartford. I had a problem that I believed was either the power supply or the on/off switch. I brought my computer in to them, and they immediately opened up the box and tested it by swapping out the power supply, which I believe was exactly the correct troubleshooting step to take first. They told me to go pick out a power supply from the shelf and bring it back to them and they would install it while I waited.

As it turns out, I had further complications (not their fault) that required that I also replace the hard drive. Same deal: go pick one out and they install it. Due to the nature of that problem, one of their tech guys had to physically hold a faulty connector in place for more than an hour as they transferred the data from my old drive to the new one.

Despite all that work, they still managed to have my computer fixed and ready for me to take home before the store closed for the day.

Re: OT: Computer croaked, help!

#5

Re: OT: Computer croaked, help!

Alex Grigoriev

>That's what UPS (uninterruptible power supply) is for. You can get one for <$100.

Re: OT: Computer croaked, help!

#6

Testing the power supply

Ken Platt (North Granby, CT)

>Mark, thanks - I'd be one happy camper if it's the power supply. I've changed a few of them over the years, quick and easy. It'd have never occurred to me that only one voltage/circuit had gone bad. I'm going to get another PS to try, but is there some way I can test with a regular multimeter? If so, and it's not the PS, I can go right to looking into another motherboard.

If I do end up trying to replace the motherboard, I gather that you wouldn't also go right ahead and replace the CPU? That'd be great; I confess I was steeling myself up for getting both if I was going to just try replacing stuff to see if I could get it back.

Many thanks -

Ken

Re: OT: Computer croaked, help!

#7

Re: Testing the power supply

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>You should be able to test the various leads on your PS with a multi meter. The various leads should be marked or identified as to what voltage they are. Any zero or extremely low readings would indicate a problem.

Lee

Re: OT: Computer croaked, help!

#8

Re: Testing the power supply

Ken Platt (North Granby, CT)

>None of the leads on my power supply seem to be marked in any way...I'll look around and see if I can find something online with the leads labeled.

I went ahead and took a shot on a new power supply. New Egg, $20, free shipping, should be here in a couple days. Not much lost if that's not it.

Too bad none of the old power supplies I had laying around had one of the 4-pin square (2x2 configuration) connectors that goes into the motherboard...looks like it's called a cpu power connector?

Ken

Re: OT: Computer croaked, help!

#9

Re: Replacing the motherboard...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Here's my experience with that: When the motherboard needs to be replaced, it's time to do all the components at the same time. They're not that expensive, and they'll all match in their technologies, sizes and connectors. The dealer, in your case New Egg, will likely have packages of things that work well together, and save you a dollar or three.

And the fellow who mentioned the UPS system made a good point. A small one would safeguard your systems pretty well for less than the cost of a new hand plane...

Re: OT: Computer croaked, help!

#10

Alas, computer still dead in the water!

Ken Platt (North Granby, CT)

>Hey Mark -

Tried a new PS, but same result. So now I'm up to a rebuild of some sort with a new motherboard. Any recommendations? This system is a P4 540 (with HT, 3.2 GHz, LGA775 socket according to the invoice), your basic mid-tower case. The invoice from the purchase (only 3 1/2 years ago, pretty lousy lifetime) says that this motherboard was an intel 915G chipset with dual channel DDR, PCI express. The video card is a PCX, be nice to be able to reuse it. At the time it was highly rated (nVidia GeForce 6600).

Thanks for any help -

Ken

Re: OT: Computer croaked, help!

#11

Re: Alas, computer still dead in the water!

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn,MI

>Ken,

My Father-In-Law just experienced a similar issue with a 2-3 year old computer.He surfs the internet and reads email and not much else on the computer.I searched Craigslist and found a guy selling "refurbished" Dell GX270 towers,2.4ghz,512mbRAM,40gb hard drives ,with a fresh install of WinXp for only $125.My FIL has been very happy as the computer does all he needs and was way less than the quoted repair price on his other computer.Depending upon what you do with a computer a used one may be the way to go.

Andy