>The blower motor resistor in my 2003 Chevy TrailBlazer failed...lost speeds 1, 2, 3 and 4. Speed 5 still worked. I ordered an authentic AC Delco replacement from Rock Auto and installed it. It worked fine for the 5 minutes I tested it. That afternoon I drove to the grocery store, during which time I lost speeds 2, 3, and 4. I called Rock Auto and they sent out a new resistor. I installed it and it ran on all speeds as I cycled through the settings. I drove the vehicle the next day with no apparent problem. Out of curiosity, I again cycled through the speeds (I rarely use more than 1 or 2) and found that speed 3 no longer worked. I called Rock Auto and, after a bit of a hassle over returning parts, got them to agree to send out a third part. This time I switched brands from AC Delco to Airtex, hoping it might make a difference.
The woman at Rock Auto thinks I have some other problem causing these to blow; two AC Delco parts could not both be defective (made in Slovenia, by the way, probably the same lot number if they were sitting side by side on the shelf). Based on what I think I know, and from reading on TrailBlazer forums, this is not at all an uncommon problem. It seems to me that if I had some other electrical problem, all speeds below 5 would have blown on both replacement resistors. Or the blower fuse would have blown. Neither happened.
The wiring harness shows zero signs of shorting, burning, etc. Terminals are bright and shiny.
Again, I have switched brands, hoping the Airtex was not made in the same factory and run as the AC Delco. I will know in a couple of days.
In the meantime, have you had any experience like this, or do you see that I am missing something?
p.s. AC Delco part was $$40 shipped from Rock Auto, $72 with tax from my local GM dealer. No affiliation with Rock Auto, but I was impressed with the help they have given me, and with their prices.
>My 2002 Impala has the same problem...lost speeds 1 and 2. A friend has a 2003 Impala...lost speeds 1, 3, 4. Another friend has at TrailBlazer...lost speeds 1, 2, 3. He has two buddies where he works who had the same problem...
Think it might have been/remains a design problem???
The resistor is easy to replace in the TrailBlazer...just remove an access panel under the glove box and twist your body and arm a bit. It is all but impossible on the Impala... mounted up and behind the blower motor, fairly easy to touch, but impossible to remove unless you have triple jointed elbows and fingers or unless you remove the blower fan assembly and part of the dash. Engineers and designers should have to work on anything they design before they can sell it. Maybe parts would become more accessible that way.
>I think those speed resistors depend on air flow over them to keep them cool. If the air flow is not happening they can over heat and melt. Check for obstructions in the air flow, perhaps an inline filter or dirty fan blades is not producing enough air flow..
>everthing here, ie high speed works: but, still would check out draw from blower motor. Maybe your blower motor's bearing are not up to par and pulling to many amp(?).
>What you are dealing with is a crude old solution to the problem of varying the speed of a DC motor. The resistor with fixed taps yields wildly different speeds depending on the drag provided by the motor. And when the motor draws more current than expected the resistor is simply not up to dissipating the increased power. The fuse in the circuit is of no help since the motor need not be drawing anywhere near the fuse's rated current to thoroughly fry the resistor. The more modern solution is an electronic circuit which modifies the power to the motor through pulse width modulation and dissipates little power in the process. The circuit will probably have current limiting to protect itself, the wiring and the motor.
Of course, none of that helps your problem. Were I faced with it I'd be pulling the blower motor for a thorough inspection, cleaning and lubrication. If I were forced to use "field expediency" I'd be at my local electronics supplier purchasing enough 25W power resistors of the proper ohm-age and in the metal screw-down style to duplicate the puny little resistor string. Screwed to a nice aluminum heatsink and rigged to a suitable wiring harness and connector it would provide a bullet-proof solution. And it would probably cost less than the one replacement you bought. That price was outrageous!
>My wife's Stratus has done something similar. Top speed works, and is noisy as all get out, while the bottom three don't work. It's a resistor problem that will cost at least $150 to fix.
I used to love working on cars, but arthritis now says no, and I'm getting to the point I hate cars, as I realize what the real cost of keeping one running is. Of course, the Stratus is a 2000, with well over 100,000 miles, so it's not an early event.